The technology used in LAWS is getting more accurate by the day. The affirmative is trying to reject a lifesaving technology based on flawed analysis
Hess 2020. Eric Hess is Senior Director of Product Management for Face Recognition & Security Solutions at SAFR from RealNetworks. “Top Five Misconceptions about Face Recognition” April 28, 2020. <https://www.securitymagazine.com/articles/92242-top-five-misconceptions-about-face-recognition> Accessed 6/30/20. ARJH
Providers and operators of any emerging technology must be held to high standards to ensure the technology is developed and deployed in a manner consistent with human and consumer rights. Face recognition is a powerful tool, but not a substitute for human surveillance operators making deliberate and actionable decisions based on corroborating evidence. Its job is to present data in real time that can be used to help security staff of potential issues or investigate incidents post-event. Yes, some facial recognition algorithms do currently show unacceptable levels of racial bias, however, the technology is far too valuable to be banned outright. Why continue to advocate use of face recognition when results aren’t always perfect? Some facial recognition systems exhibit lower levels of bias than others: A recent National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) study found that Asian and African-American faces had false-positive match rates 10 to 100 times higher than white faces across many tested algorithms. While these levels of bias are clearly unacceptable, the study also identified several algorithms that were “important exceptions.” These algorithms had fairly consistent results across racial groups with accuracy variances as low as 0.19%. This shows that facial recognition systems don’t inherently have high rates of bias and can be improved. Rather than ban this technology outright, facial recognition providers should be held accountable for reducing bias in their algorithms. A labeling system — akin to nutrition labels on foods — based on results from an independent evaluator such as NIST could provide transparency. Systems that don’t meet minimum consistency requirements across race, age, and gender should not be considered by purchasing committees. Using face recognition can reduce bias in real-world situations: The core function of face recognition — attempting to identify a face based on a knowledge bank of known faces — is something humans do all the time. Take an eyewitness to a crime, a police officer looking for a suspect based on a surveillance image, or a store clerk watching for shoplifters. Each has inherent bias informed by past interactions, the media, and amplified by the cross-race effect. All people have inherent bias — the bias found in facial recognition algorithms stems from bias in the humans developing them. There is no way to completely eradicate bias in humans or algorithms, but facial recognition technology is already as good as, or better than, humans at finding correct matches when comparing images of faces. It can also do so exponentially faster. Facial recognition algorithms are getting better: It’s much easier to train an AI model to reduce bias and eliminate the cross-race effect than it is to eradicate bias in every security guard, law enforcement officer, and witness to a crime. Face recognition has come a long way since it was first developed, and the technology continues to improve with regards to accuracy across skin tone and gender. Bias thresholds could evolve over time as the technology improves to ensure false-match rates continue to drop for all users as the technology becomes more widespread. A complete ban on face recognition would prevent this continual improvement of a technology that could be an equalizer. Accurate, low bias systems leveraged by humans who are educated on how they work — and how to account for their limitations — have the potential to dramatically reduce bias across a range of security, law enforcement, and criminal justice use cases.