Free beta access. 5 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Democratic peace only works with globalized democracy, absent that it fails and states default to realism and conflict

Mearsheimer 2018. John Joseph Mearsheimer is an American political scientist and international relations scholar and R. Wendell Harrison Distinguished Service Professor at the University of Chicago. “Chapter 7: Liberal Theories of Peace” Great Delusion: Liberal Dreams and International Realities. 2018 Yale University Press. <https://www.jstor.org/stable/j.ctv5cgb1w> Accessed 6/30/20. ARJH

Consider, for instance, that none of the liberal theories was relevant to the superpower competition during the Cold War. The Soviet Union was not a democracy, the two sides had little economic intercourse, and few international institutions had both sides as members. Or think about how most liberals talk about the prospects of China’s rising peacefully. China is not a democracy today and shows little prospect of becoming one. One rarely hears the argument that democratic peace theory can provide the basis for peace in Asia. But one frequently hears that economic interdependence theory can explain why China’s rise will be peaceful. China’s economy is tied to the economies of its rivals, and this linkage means not only that China and its trading partners depend on each other to keep prospering, but also that prosperity depends on their peaceful relations. A war involving China would be tantamount to mutual assured destruction at the economic level. Hence, economic interdependence will keep the peace in Asia as China rises. It is possible to hypothesize a world in which one or more of the liberal theories apply universally, and one where none of them applies at all. But those are not our world. In our world, those theories are likely to cover certain situations but not others. Consider, for example, how democratic peace theory would apply to a scenario in which the United States removes its military forces from Europe and NATO disappears. There would then be three major powers on the Continent: France, Germany, and Russia. According to the theory, France and Germany would not fight each other, because they are both liberal democracies and thus would not compete with each other for power. But they would have a fundamentally different relationship with non-­democratic Russia: they would be guided by realist logic, with its emphasis on the survival motive. In that situation, all three countries would end up trying to maximize their positions in the global balance of power. Let us assume that Russia becomes a democracy. Democratic peace theory would then apply to relations among all three major powers. Yet democratic Russia would have to fear a rising China, which is not a democracy, on its southern border, and so would have to act according to balance-­of-­power logic in its dealings with China. France and Germany do not share a border with China, but they would still have to worry about a possible threat if China became a superpower. As long as there is one powerful non-­democracy in the system, no democracy can escape from acting according to realist logic. As Alexander Wendt notes, “One predator will best a hundred pacifists because anarchy provides no guarantees. This argument is powerful in part because it is so weak: rather than making the strong assumption that all states are inherently power-­seeking . . . it assumes that just one is power-seeking and that the others have to follow suit because anarchy permits the one to exploit them.”6 This logic applies even though the democracies in the system would still behave peacefully toward each other, at least according to the theory.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.