Free beta access. 5 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Pre-Cautionary tech bans are bad – Innovation should be preferred

Daniel Castro and Michael McLaughlin 02-04-2019 [Daniel Castro is vice president at the Information Technology and Innovation Foundation (ITIF) and director of ITIF's Center for Data Innovation; Castro writes and speaks on a variety of issues related to information technology and internet policy, including privacy, security, intellectual property, Internet governance, e-government, and accessibility for people with disabilities; Michael McLaughlin was a research analyst at the Information Technology and Innovation Foundation; McLaughlin researched and wrote about a variety of issues related to information technology and Internet policy, including digital platforms, e-government, and artificial intelligence.

;], “Ten Ways the Precautionary Principle Undermines Progress in Artificial Intelligence,” Cut By: m.jam

Artificial intelligence (AI) has the potential to deliver significant social and economic benefits, including reducing accidental deaths and injuries, making new scientific discoveries, and increasing productivity.[1] However, an increasing number of activists, scholars, and pundits see AI as inherently risky, creating substantial negative impacts such as eliminating jobs, eroding personal liberties, and reducing human intelligence.[2] Some even see AI as dehumanizing, dystopian, and a threat to humanity.[3] As such, the world is dividing into two camps regarding AI: those who support the technology and those who oppose it. Unfortunately, the latter camp is increasingly dominating AI discussions, not just in the United States, but in many nations around the world. There should be no doubt that nations that tilt toward fear rather than optimism are more likely to put in place policies and practices that limit AI development and adoption, which will hurt their economic growth, social progress, and global competitiveness.

While some people advocate for an almost completely hands-off approach to regulating new technologies, those who recognize that there is a legitimate role for government take two distinct approaches toward action: the precautionary principle and the innovation principle.

The precautionary principle is the idea that if a technological innovation may carry a risk of harming the public or the environment, then those proposing the technology should bear the burden of proving it will not. If they cannot, governments should limit the use of the new technology until proven safe. Those who support the precautionary principle, which calls for government intervention even when there is no clear evidence of tangible and imminent threats of harm, adhere to the cliché it is “better to be safe than sorry.”4 For some technologies, such as nuclear power, the principle makes sense, because the risk of getting it wrong can be catastrophic. However, for most areas of innovation, the precautionary principle leads to more harm than good because it generates hypothetical worst-case scenarios that incorrectly suggest technological advancement presents severe and irreversible threats.5

In contrast, the innovation principle holds that because the overwhelming majority of technological innovations benefit society and pose modest and not irreversible risks, government’s role should be to pave the way for widespread innovation while building guardrails, where necessary, to limit harms. The innovation principle recognizes that market forces, tort law, existing laws and regulations, or light-touch targeted interventions can usually manage the risks new technologies pose. The principle does not, however, argue for a ban on regulation of new technologies. Instead, it advocates for a case-by-case approach, suggesting regulations only in those cases where there is a reasonable expectation that other forces will not suffice and where the potential harms are more than minor. Moreover, in cases where regulations are needed, it stresses the importance of designing regulatory interventions and structuring regulatory enforcement in ways that minimize the harm to innovation, while still achieving the regulatory goals. Finally, it focuses more on ensuring that penalties punish bad actors who cause harm than creating regulations that limit beneficial and benign uses.6 In other words, speculative concerns should not hold back concrete benefits.

Perhaps more so than any government, the U.S. federal government adhered to the innovation principle in its early regulation of the Internet, and this approach fostered a successful era of innovation and growth in the U.S. digital economy.7 In contrast, Europe’s more heavy-handed approach limited and continues to limit digital innovation. For example, many jurisdictions in Europe have restricted the use of ride-sharing apps like Uber because of concerns about the impact on the local taxi industry.8

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.