A2: Humans are more accurate but they believe the tech so it has to be removed
Shira Ovide (New York Times) “A Case for Banning Facial Recognition” June 09, 2020 https://www.nytimes.com/2020/06/09/technology/facial-recognition-software.html?auth=login-google
But a police officer or eyewitness could also look at surveillance footage and mug shots and misidentify someone as Jim Smith. Is software more accurate or less biased than humans? That depends. Our analysis showed that for many, facial recognition was way less accurate than humans. The other problem is something called automation bias. If your intuition tells you that an image doesn’t look like Smith, but the computer model tells you that it is him with 99 percent accuracy, you’re more likely to believe that model. There’s also an imbalance of power. Facial recognition can be completely accurate, but it can still be used in a way that is detrimental to certain groups of people. The combination of overreliance on technology, misuse and lack of transparency — we don’t know how widespread the use of this software is — is dangerous.