Offensive capabilities are necessary to adapt to changing adversary capabilities – the aff just establishes a cyber Maginot Line that is begging to be pushed back
Lewis 15 – James A. Lewis, senior vice president and director of the Technology Policy Program at the Center for Strategic and International Studies, “The Role of Offensive Cyber Operations in NATO’s Collective Defence,” 2015, https://ccdcoe.org/uploads/2018/10/TP_08_2015_0.pdf
The nature of warfare is changing as opponents seek to circumvent Western military power by using a blend of political action, special forces, proxies and irregular units, unconventional tactics and cyber techniques to find a different way of applying force to gain their ends. What Russia sometimes call “hybrid warfare” will challenge NATO defence planning. A cyber defensive orientation is, however, the equivalent of a static defence, defending fixed positions rather than manoeuvring, and conceding initiative to opponents. The next public iteration of NATO cyber policy should describe how NATO members with offensive cyber capabilities would retain national control, but make these capabilities available to NATO in the event of aggression. NATO should be more explicit in how offensive cyber operations fit into its defensive and deterrent strategy. Finally, it needs to identify and describe a regular coordinating process to be established (similar to the Nuclear Planning Group) in NATO’s Cyber Defence Committee (CDC). NATO would never refrain from using fighter aircraft because they can serve offensive purposes, and say it would rely solely on air defence missiles and damage control to deal with the threat of air attack. Nor would NATO renounce armoured vehicles and rely only on static defence. A defensive approach that forsakes the possibility of offensive action is essentially a cyber Maginot Line. This defensive orientation serves no one’s interest except that of our opponents. Offensive cyber operations are similarly a part of warfare that advanced militaries cannot ignore. The mechanisms for incorporating offensive cyber into NATO will be complicated by national sensitivities, and public presentation will need to be carefully crafted to reinforce a deterrent message; but the next step, however politically difficult, for NATO transformation is to publicly embrace offensive cyber capabilities in planning and exercises. Warfare is evolving as technological and political developments change the requirements for effective operations. Military innovations create a new dynamic for calculating risk among potential adversaries. Forces and concepts that once seemed adequate for stability are called into question. It will be neither easy nor quick for NATO to discuss publicly the role of offensive cyber operations, but it is ultimately unavoidable.