Biotech moral judgments leads to impasse
Michael Moran, 2012, Professor Emeritus of Government, University of Manchester – Chair, Nuffield Council on Bioethics https://www.nuffieldbioethics.org/assets/pdfs/Emerging_biotechnologies_full_report_web_0.pdf, " Emerging biotechnologies: technology, choice and the public good" Nuffield Council on Bioethics (ermo/sms, Acc:7-3-2022)
4.12 Different cultures and religions have found ways of ordering living beings so as to express their relative importance but also, significantly, their continuity as a class (i.e. the relatedness, by intermediate steps or degrees of genetic similarity, of all living beings). The ‘great chain of being’ developed in medieval Christianity, for example, with God at its head and other beings arranged in descending degrees of perfection, has its roots in Plato and Aristotle; Darwinian evolution, and modern genetics similarly emphasise both continuity and difference in their theories of descent and inheritance. The distinctive autonomy of living beings is apparent in the often complex ways in which living things interact with and transform themselves and their environment, and by their powers of reproduction, allowing natural purposes – or ‘ends’ – to be imputed to them. Notions of a natural order, harmony and ends are deeply engrained in almost all cultures and bind groups and societies powerfully together. The term ‘the wisdom of repugnance’ has been coined to evoke and enjoin a shared sense of distaste for certain biotechnological practices that appear ‘contrary to nature’ in this sense.260 This notion is close to what, from a less sympathetic perspective, is often referred to as the ‘yuck factor’.261 Where such sentiments are widely shared they can form a powerful basis for moral restraint and, indeed, for positive legislation262; however, where there are moral disagreements, moral arguments can quickly reach an impasse (since my sentiment towards a given action does not logically contradict your different sentiment).