Free beta access. 5 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Plan isn’t interdisciplinary cannot drive politics, but politics can disrupt implementation

General Philip Breedlove (U.S.AF, ret.), 2-25-2019, Supreme Allied Commander Europe from 2013 to 2016 and is now a distinguished professor at the Sam Nunn School of International Affairs at the Georgia Institute of Technology. Dr. Margaret Kosal is an associate professor at the Sam Nunn School, where she focuses on technology, strategy, and governance.https://www.hoover.org/research/emerging-technologies-and-national-security-russia-nato-european-theater, "Emerging Technologies and National Security: Russia, NATO, & the European Theater," Hoover Institution (ermo/sms, Acc:7-3-2022)

With respect for the need to be strategic, this potential barrier reflects the need for effective science diplomacy to reach outside of science. Rarely, if ever, does science and technology itself drive foreign policy; the potential national security, economic, or other national- and international-level consequences of the application of science and technology to human endeavors is where science intersects with policy predominantly. Science and technology can be causal, intervening, or determinant factors. The ability to recognize, communicate, and identify nodes for intervention, change, or influence are strategic requirements for effective science diplomacy.

Most international legal and regulatory approaches to technologies and to emerging technologies—robotics, biotechnologies, synthetic genomics, gain of function research, nanotechnology, cognitive neurosciences, hypersonics, AI—are still driven by 20th-Century (or earlier) conceptions and institutions. Past methods for other technologies that do not take into account the international nature of the science and the industry are not adequate. Any international regime or approach must be interdisciplinary in focus, cognizant of the multi-polar post-Cold War world, and appreciate the role of private funders, commercial development, and transnational corporations. To be clear, there’s a lot of good in the arms control and nonproliferation existing institutions. Rather, these challenges are primarily political rather than technical. Being able to navigate and affect policy at the interface of science and international affairs is where we have immense value.

The tension between adoption and governance of technology must be considered as part of the balance of power. The utility of treaties may be better viewed as more than only a guarantee against using a weapon. Weapons treaties were never an ironclad guarantee that weapons would not be used. Treaties provide stability, reduce uncertainty; enable dialogue, and are confidence building measures. The utility of weapon prohibition treaties as balancing should not be ignored, not because of an idealized imagination that prohibition effectively and permanently limits proliferation or use of a technology but because the act of meeting, networking, building relationships, and negotiating provides a forum for interacting and addressing underlying issues. From this standpoint, governance approaches should be integral to an integrated military strategy for future capabilities development, not the afterthought that attempts to put the metaphorical genie back in the bottle.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.