Turkey is eroding NATO cohesion and security and disagreements inevitable
FederigaBrindi, IanBond, Heather Conley ( foreign policy directors from Center for European Reform) “Is Turkey Damaging NATO” last modified Jan 24, 2018 https://carnegieeurope.eu/strategiceurope/75345 (ESIEVER/MSDI, Acc: 7-4-2022)
Yes, it is. In Afrin, Turkish forces have launched a ground offensive against U.S.-backed Syrian-Kurdish militia. In other words, Turkey is indirectly attacking its main NATO ally. It is doing so with Russian support, as Moscow controls the skies in the area—the last act in the rapprochement between the two countries since the 2015 crisis. Western powers have timidly pleaded with Ankara to show restraint. At an emergency meeting of the UN Security Council called by France, ambassadors met behind closed doors. They did not publicly condemn Turkey for its actions. Nor there has been enough condemnation by Western allies of the repeated human rights violations by Turkey over the last few years.Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan has essentially been given the all-clear to do what he wants, knowing that Ankara’s NATO allies (not to mention the EU) will look the other way. The problem with such irresponsible behavior is that it is not only damaging NATO, it is undermining the whole Western community—and its values system. The respect of fundamental rights is what the West has used to justify the last two decades of wars;the damage is soon going to be irreparable. Turkey is causing an increasing amount of damage to NATO. Ankara has reason for concern about U.S. support for the Kurdish YPG fighters in Syria, given the YPG’s link to the PKK terrorist group inside Turkey; but allied security will not benefit from Turkey attacking one of the only forces in Syria that can consistently fight and win against the so-called Islamic State. Only Bashar al Assad and IS would gain from the defeat of the YPG. And if Turkey’s action in Syria is at least explicable, what was Erdoğan thinking when he decided to buy a long-range air defense system from Russia rather than from a NATO ally? The alliance will end up with a significant gap in coverage on its south-eastern flank. But Turkey’s drift away from democracy and the rule of law damages the alliance more fundamentally than any individual action. After more than a decade of rating Turkey as “partly free,” Freedom House downgraded the country to “not free” this year. During the Cold War, NATO held its nose and tolerated authoritarian regimes in allied countries (including Turkey). These days, shared democratic values glue NATO together. Turkey’s behavior puts that unity at risk. Turkey’s recent brinkmanship policies have definitely damaged the cohesion of NATO and the current Afrin incursion has the potential to widen the gap. However unwise Turkey’s latest move might be, it does not come as a surprise. It is not enough that the United States recognized Turkey’s legitimate security concerns along the northern Syrian border only after the Afrin offensive. Make no mistake: there are many things that Turkey is to blame for—including, in large part, for not peacefully resolving the Kurdish question. A solution might have allowed Turkey to agree to some sort of face-saving agreement with the Kurdish YPG in Syria. But if there is one thing that Washington and Ankara have in common, it’s a miscalculated Syria policy—and the current situation is the direct outcome of that. Both the United States and Turkey now face a larger question: are their long-term goals in Syria attainable? For the Turks, the incursion not only creates security risks at home (PKK terror attacks in major Turkish cities had stopped since 2016, but may very well return); it also risks serving Moscow’s agenda to drive a wedge into NATO. President Erdoğan’s agenda may be fuelled by strong survival instincts and paranoia, but even outside his circles suspicion against NATO runs deep. It does not take much to make the case for alternative alliances. Turkey has reached a point where the government might be willing to risk damaging NATO for what it sees as preserving Turkey’s sovereignty, even if this may come at a high price.Any NATO member that purposefully diminishes its democratic principles and institutions damages the alliance. Every NATO member is a signatory to the alliance’s founding document, the 1949 Washington Treaty, and its preamble states that all members are “… determined to safeguard the freedom, common heritage and civilization of their peoples, founded on the principles of democracy, individual liberty and the rule of law.” Although we associate NATO solely with its military operations, NATO is a political-military alliance with democratic principles at its core. Turkey has so greatly diminished its democracy over the past several years that an independent U.S. organization, Freedom House, has recently declared the country “not free.” Unfortunately, Turkey is not a NATO outlier in this regard but is part of a growing trend. Poland, Hungary, and Romania are also actively diminishing judicial independence, institutional transparency, and the ability to express political opposition; the very essence of democracy. These countries also damage the credibility of this crucial political alliance.
But as a critical NATO member, Turkey’s military interventions in the Middle East—whether it is the shooting down of a Russian military aircraft or repeated unilateral military interventions in Iraq and Syria—increasingly place Turkey’s national security at risk, which places NATO at risk of becoming involved in the broader regional conflict. Thus, Turkey inflicts ongoing damage to NATO politically and militarily.