Free beta access. 5 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

These tensions AMPLIFY solvency instead of reducing it

Daniel S. Hamilton, 5-30-2022, , Johns Hopkins University School of Advanced International Studies https://networks.h-net.org/node/28443/discussions/10309905/h-diplo-roundtable-xxiii-39-hanhimaki%C2%A0-pax-transatlantica%C2%A0, "H-Diplo Roundtable XXIII-39 on Hanhimaki. Pax Transatlantica: America and Europe in the Post-Cold War Era," No Publication (ermo/sms, Acc:7-4-2022)

In this clear and compelling volume, Jussi Hanhimäki takes on the “paradox” he sees at the heart of the transatlantic relationship: a “great success story that is always at the brink of catastrophe” (7). Hanhimäki goes beyond doom-and-gloom headlines by placing recent transatlantic disputes within the deeply embedded political, economic, and security ties that hold the transatlantic community together even in times of crisis.

Hanhimäki does not dismiss very real differences that have often shaped US-European relations. He shows, however, that such tensions have never led to a transatlantic crack-up, in part because they remind policymakers and opinion leaders of the tremendous stakes each side of the North Atlantic has developed in a densely interwoven alliance of prosperous democracies. “If anything,” he concludes, such disagreements are “the creative lifeblood of the transatlantic relationship” (21).

Hanhimäki was motivated to write this book in part as a counterpoint to Robert Kagan’s celebrated analysis that “Americans are from Mars and Europe is from Venus.” Writing at the time of considerable transatlantic debate over George W. Bush’s decision to invade Iraq, Kagan hit a nerve by concluding that when it came to deciding national priorities and defining foreign and defense policies, the United States and Europe had “parted ways.''[1]

Hanhimäki’s volume is essentially a Kagan-style book that argues the opposite premise. Like Kagan, Hanhimäki does not attempt a detailed empirical study, something he has done in other works.[2] Instead, he looks at transatlantic patterns of interaction within the security space of NATO, the economic space of trade and investment flows, and the internal politics of the transatlantic political space. These three intertwined spaces form the foundation of what he refers to as Pax Transatlantica.

Despite a sense of continuing crisis, he shows how the transatlantic security space has expanded and the transatlantic economic space has become more deeply interconnected. He compares domestic political dynamics of each side of the Atlantic and finds many similar trends. His conclusion: the United States and Europe are far from ‘parting ways’; in fact, the structural interdependencies that bind the two sides of the North Atlantic together have become more, not less, important over past decades.

Hanhimäki first recounts the ups and downs of the transatlantic rollercoaster by taking issue with the notion that the Cold War had been a golden age of transatlantic cooperation. The notion of a ‘transatlantic community’ may have been born during the Cold War, but more often than not it was a community of strife, punctuated by such major internal conflicts as France’s decision to exit NATO’s unified military command, disputes over burden-sharing, nuclear deterrence, out-of-area engagements, national subsidies and trade rules. Far from threatening the transatlantic alliance, Hanhimäki argues that these disputes were sources of vibrancy and dynamism. The United States and Europe “thrived” on competition and disagreement, he argues: “Indeed, the key to the success of the West in the Cold War was its ability to remain united while being perpetually divided” (33-34).

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.