Free beta access. 5 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Aff – all the dispute you locate increase plan’s solvency

David Ryan, 5-30-2022, University College Cork https://networks.h-net.org/node/28443/discussions/10309905/h-diplo-roundtable-xxiii-39-hanhimaki%C2%A0-pax-transatlantica%C2%A0, "H-Diplo Roundtable XXIII-39 on Hanhimaki. Pax Transatlantica: America and Europe in the Post-Cold War Era," No Publication (ermo/sms, Acc:7-4-2022)

Though Hanhimäki’s work is intentionally focused on the sphere within the north and west, one has to question the identity of the shared values. After all, with NATO out of area operations, one needs to further consider the basis of the liberal values. The extent to which these values drove decisions and methods in Iraq and Afghanistan needs further consideration. Though not a part of Hanhimäki’s argument, one might consider the centrality of these values in the wars in Vietnam and in the earlier period of European colonialism. During the Cold War, with the transitions from colonialism to decolonisation, there was much for the western powers to disagree upon, but also a lot to question the basis of ‘liberalism’ in their international interactions. This was also, of course, the very period in which NATO was formed and grew.[30] In his From Plato to NATO, David Gress emphasises the cracks rather than the paint which covered the disagreements. But even in the “grand narrative” the emphasis on liberal, pluralist democracy and an uncertain commitment to the market economy, “… suffered from the weakness of liberalism: the illusion of newness, economic reductionism, and an inability to choose between the negative and positive ideas of liberty – the idea that saw liberty and freedom from coercion versus the idea of liberty as self-realization.” [31] Some of the dominant European powers could not look too far into their pasts to maintain any sense of a prevalent liberalism; in that sense, but only at the level of meta-narrative, the United States with its formal ideologies offered a new conceptual identity, centred on the narrowly defined purpose of NATO.[32] Moreover, the Cold War West, from which NATO emerged, “… could not contain any substantive definitions of liberty or democracy for no such substantive definitions could command general agreement.” These values were read in different ways, even within the same conceptual West. Gress concludes, “to enroll such contradictory ideas in a common front required that the distinctions be ignored or elided.”[33] Hanhimäki emphasises that the robust disagreements that are present add strength to the vitality of the West and NATO.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.