Depictions of a pristine biodiversity ignoring the un-ending violence caused by the west – their attempts to maintain Bio – D are not for protection but further surveillance and exploitation
Timothy W. Luke, Professor of Political Science at Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University, 1997, Ecocritique, p. 65-69
Until the early 1970s, TNC adhered to many essentially romantic assumptions about Nature in its various operations. Nature existed as a real presence in places left undisturbed by human beings.27 At such sites, therefore, all plants and animals embodied Nature’s substance, and as such they were all worthy of protection. Therefore, acquiring any and all land that was not now being touched by some human settlement’s economic and social activity constituted a meaningful act of Nature conservation. The battle lines were drawn across territories understood as land under active current social utilization (or artificial zones without a large Nature presence) and land no longer or not yet put to such use (or natural zones without a large social presence), making it, therefore, worthy as a site of Nature conservancy. At some point in the 1960s and 1970s, these discursive frames became obsolete, even though many people today inside and outside of the environmental movement do not recognize their obsolescence. Bill McKibben and Carolyn Merchant, to a very real extent, are right.28 Nature has ended. Nature is dead. Perhaps it was the conquest of extraterrestrial spaces in the moon landings of 1969—70, whose televisual and photographic images of the Earth sublated conceptual antinomies like Nature/Society, out-there/in-here, wilderness/settlement, and environment/economy in pictures of one undifferentiated little blue planet floating in space. Perhaps it was the penetration of transnational capitalism even into Moscow and Beijing during Nixon’s detente, whose acceptance of Pepsi, Kentucky Fried Chicken, or Pan Am passengers underscored how commercial commodities now could go anywhere anytime anyone wished them to do so. Perhaps it was the collective shudder of the 1971—73 oil shocks from OPEC, whose antics illustrated how tightly coupled all human societies were to petrochemical energy supplies mostly pumped up from under a handful of Mideastern deserts. The brittleness in the traditional categories, pitting “Nature” against “Society,” finally snapped. There really were no lands without any traces of some large social presence. Hundreds of individual plants and animals were not merely being disturbed by humanity; they were being eradicated as species in wholesale extinctions. Scientific observations of air quality, water quality, atmospheric integrity, bone composition, or milk production were indicating that human beings have profoundly disturbed what had been regarded as unalterable sovereign Nature with industrial pollution, greenhouse gases, chemical contamination, and radioactive wastes. Hence, to pretend to be conserving “the untouched and undisturbed expanses of Nature” in simple actions of land ownership made very little sense. Nature, as it had been conceptualized by the Ecologist’s Union in 1945 for The Nature Conservancy to preserve after 1951, had been disappearing right from under everyone’s noses as global modernization accelerated at even greater rates from 1945 to 1973. Once-undisturbed lands could no longer be regarded as the container of Nature as such, they had to be continuously reassessed to determine their ecological values, creating the space of surveillance, as chapters 4 and 5 argue, known as “the environment.”29 From 1951 to 1973, TNC did have a decidedly scientific air about its operations, even though with its haphazard policies of property acquisition the organization still worked as a land collection program to preserve scenic beauty, rare plants, and wild animals on whatever land it would get whenever it could get it. Low-key and nonconfrontarional, The Nature Conservancy’s style of environmental protection had been fairly cozy with big business from the beginning. Under the leadership of Pat Noonan from 1973 to 1980, however, this almost accidental precedent was turned into an article of faith. During the intensive environmental conflicts of the early 1970s, as Noonan notes, “corporations and environmentalists were butting heads, but we knew the free-enterprise system was a fantastic motivator. So the Conservancy decided to reach out to corporate America. No other environmental group was doing it.” This operational strategy was augmented with a new mission statement from Bob Jenkins, The Nature Conservancy’s in-house biologist. Dissatisfied with the Conservancy’s acceptance of land with dubious ecological worth, although it often appeared to be undisturbed as natural scenery, Jenkins saw biodiversity rather than natural appearance as that quality which TNC should be preserving.31 Instead of protecting any and all land that it acquired, Jenkins’s strategy stressed preserving only those lands populated by rare or endangered flora and fauna in unique ecosystems. Scientific surveillance was combined with high-test property management to give TNC a much clearer purpose. Noonan’s acceptance of corporate free enterprise and Jenkins’s agendas for surveying, inventorying, and guarding biotic diversity recentered The Nature Conservancy’s ideologies and institutions on the strategies they continue to follow today. Grove concludes: The Nature Conservancy would henceforth seek out and attempt to save species and biotic communities that stood in danger of disappearing under human pressures. It would buy land when necessary, but to cut down on management and overhead costs, property was often turned over whenever possible to responsible federal and state agencies for protection. Further, TNC would decentralize, establishing state field offices that could keep closer watch on the land. Coinciding with its new focus, the national staff grew out of its basement quarters in Washington and moved just across the Potomac River into a high rise office building in Rosslyn, Virginia. Emerging as well in the months and years that followed were the practical arguments for maintaining biotic diversity. . . . Although morals and aesthetics still apply, the emphasis turned to “save this plant because we may need it someday” instead of “save this plant because we have no right to kill it.” Over the past two decades, TNC has grown by leaps and bounds by sticking to the operating objectives in this “preserving biodiversity” mission statement. Because Nature has ended, material signs of its now-dead substance need to be conserved as pristine preserved parts, like pressed leaves in a book, dried animal pelts in a drawer, or a loved one’s mortal remains in a tomb. Nature is dead, but long shall Nature live in the environmentalized forms of rare species, exotic biodiversity, land preserves, and threatened ecosystems. As powerful anthropogenic actions have recontoured the earth to suit the basic material needs of corporate modes of production, these artificial contours now define new ecologies for all life forms caught within their “economy” and “environment.” The “economy” becomes a world political economy’s interior spaces defined by technoscience processes devoted to production and consumption, while “the environment,” in this sense, becomes a planetary political economy’s exterior spaces oriented to resource creation, scenery provision, and waste reception. The pickets and suits deployed by other more vocal ecological groups perpetuate a faulty one-dimensional consciousness, “believing that environmental protection and economic growth are somehow mutually exclusive.”33 These antiquated perceptions cling to the illusion that Nature is alive, and somehow avoiding its subjection to capital in the commodity form by remaining wilderness. Recognizing the true totality of transnational capital’s power, which easily commodifies wilderness in many environmental products, the goal of “The Nature Conservancy is to change this unfortunate perception,” because, as anyone attentive to capital’s dynamics can attest, “our economy and environment are not antagonists, they depend on each other. ... protecting our natural resources generates economic benefits.”34 Natural resources exist, but Nature does not. Economic survival is imperative, but the commodity logics driving it need to be grounded in sound ecological common sense lest the limitless dynamism of commodification be permitted to submit everything to exchange logics immediately. Time is now what is both scarce and centrally important in the highly compressed time-space continua of contemporary commodity chains. It is no longer a question of jobs versus the environment, because fewer jobs will not resurrect Nature. Nature is dead, and the environment generating global production assumes that jobs are necessary to define it as the space of natural resources. Doing jobs irrationally and too rapidly, however, is what destroys these environments, making jobs done rationally and at an apt pace ecologically acceptable. Consequently, the agendas of environmental protection must center on the “question of the short-term vs. the long-term,” and this is “what the Conservancy is all about.”35