The fundamental assumptions of liberalism ignore other more vital causes of war—the properties that make a democratic nation peaceful aren’t democratic
Buchan 02 Bruce Buchan B Arts (Hons), M Arts, PhD winner of B Arts (Hons), M Arts, PhD Senior Lecturer, School of Humanities Senior Lecturer, School of Humanities “Explaining War and Peace: Kant and Liberal IR Theory” Alternatives v. 27
This sort of argument strips bare the assumption behind much liberal IR theory, that liberalism, and in particular the creation of civil society, is held to be the key to domestic and international peace. The "liberal" states that surround and protect their own civil societies are thus taken to be "morally complete" and nonviolent because they embody the normative superiority of liberalism. (51) In theorizing the development of a zone of interstate peace, therefore, liberal IR theorists assume that liberal states are not the source of war; they may engage in war, but only because illiberal or uncivilized states pose a threat. More importantly, however, the second consequence is that liberal IR theorists seem insensible to the domestic, "civil" roots of violence, its control and intensification, alongside liberal norms and within liberal and representative institutions, nurtured and sustained in the crucible of civil society, and driven by a process of civilization. Nowhere is this more obvious than in the work of Kant, on whom many contemporary liberal democratic-peace theorists unwisely rely. (52) When they do so, the claim to the normative superiority of liberal-democratic norms collapses since it soon becomes clear that Kant's arguments for a "pacific federation" of states were based in part on military competition, and his principles of representation turn out to be anything but democratic. (53) If, as Cederman suggests, "it is our duty" to take Kant's "ethical reasoning" seriously, then we may find, contrary to Cederman's expectations, that Kant was neither a democrat nor a liberal, and certainly not a theorist of "interdemocratic peace." (54)