The negatives of securitization of disease far out weight the positives-it is grounded in a racist discourse that has empirically been used for genocide
Stefan Elbe, Paper Presented to the 45th Annual ISA Convention, Montreal, Quebec, Canada, March 17, 2004, on the panel ‘Activism and Practices of Dissent in Global Politics: Interdisciplinary and Critical Perspectives’, “The Futility of Protest? – Biopower and Biopolitics in the Securitization of HIV/AIDS”, http://www.stefanelbe.com/resources/ElbeISA2004Final.pdf, It was approved “On 10/09/2010 05:04, kentucky morrow wrote: Dear, Dr. Stefan Elbe, First sorry for our last message, we were having some email trouble, but now have it all figured out Second, hello, we am writing to you today because, we am a fifteen year old high-school student in the United States, and we have recently read one of your pieces of work, "The Futility of Protest? – Biopower and Biopolitics in the Securitization of HIV/AIDS”. we were very impressed by your piece ofwork and would like to cite it, for use in a high school debate round. We have long been a fan of critical securitization work, and believe that your article would be very helpful to advancing its cause. Thanks again, we really enjoyed your articles and hope that I will be able to cite it for usein debate rounds. That's fine. Thanks for asking ... and good luck with the debate.Stefan Elbe”
3. The Ethical Dangers of Biopolitics Many of those advocating the securitization of AIDS hope that their actions will bring about a plethora of important, long-term normative benefits. These advantages include (i) mobilising more political support and economic resources for addressing the AIDS pandemic at global and local levels, (ii) breaking the silence and stigma surrounding HIV/AIDS in many African, Asian and Latin American countries, (iii) politicising the central role of the security sector as a vector of the virus, and (iv) helping to override the legal constraints bearing on the production of affordable life-saving AIDS medicines – especially those imposed by the international regime protecting intellectual property rights (TRIPS), the provisions of which do not apply to cases of national security crises.55 These goals do seem worth striving for, but they must also be reassessed in light of the biopolitical dimension to the securitization of AIDS identified above. Foucault, after all, had been able to detect at least two serious ethical dangers historically accompanying the deployment of biopolitical strategies, and both of these concerns can, to some extent, be shown to apply to the current securitization of HIV/AIDS as well. 3.1. Biological Racism One such danger is that historically biopolitical strategies have given rise to new instances of mass death heralded on the basis of biological criteria. With hindsight it seems profoundly ironic that the European era of biopower – advanced in the name of ‘life’ – coexisted with political strategies demanding the deaths of millions. Foucault later came to understand this bizarre confluence on the basis of a new racism – a racism of biology rather than of culture.56 ‘Racism’, he contended from a biopolitical perspective, ‘is primarily a way of introducing a break into the domain of life that is under power’s control: the break between what must live and what must die.’57 The Nazi movement demonstrated this darker side of biopolitics in a particularly stark manner when it carved up the European continent using the dubious criterion of ‘blood’ for deciding which populations could be usefully ‘Germanized’ and thus spared, and which ones could not.58 This biological racism was also projected internally to the Jewish population of the German Reich; Jews were no longer prosecuted solely because of their Judaism, but because of their ‘Jewishness’, which prompted Hannah Arendt to point out in her memorable phrase that whereas in the past ‘Jews had been able to escape from Judaism into conversion; from Jewishness there was no escape.’59 A biopolitical society, in short, may still make decisions about whose life is worth preserving and whose life will be allowed to perish, and the function of racism in a biopolitical age is to make this very distinction. Indeed, biological racism may even prove to be more pernicious than the traditional cultural racism precisely in that there is no escape from one’s biological makeup. In either case, such biological racism can explain the historical irony that it was ‘as managers of life and survival, of bodies and the race, that so many regimes have been able to wage so many wars, causing so many men to be killed’.60 This darker side of the twentieth century European biopolitics, moreover, must give pause for thought regarding ongoing attempts to the frame the AIDS pandemic as an international security issue. Is there any evidence of racism operating in the international debate on HIV/AIDS? There is certainly evidence that the older, cultural racism is present in this debate, especially regarding the question of which peoples are allowed to live and which ones are left to die. Given the existence of life-prolonging medicines, the pandemic could be significantly curtailed with sufficient international political will and resources. Yet Africans’ claims to these medicines are not being satisfied; the survival of these populations is being given much less priority internationally than say
the less than 3,000 U.S. citizens who died on September 11, 2001, prompting the head of UNAIDS, Peter Piot, to remind his listeners that ‘if this would have happened in the Balkans, or in Eastern Europe, or in Mexico, with white people, the reaction would have been different.’61 It is indeed hard to imagine that this pandemic would have been allowed to rage out of control on any continent other than Africa. Of course, this kind of racism is different from the racism deployed by Germany’s National- socialists in that people are not being killed either deliberately or on biologically- defined grounds, but its effects are much the same; HIV-positive populations are being allowed to die in vast numbers despite the availability of life-prolonging medicines, thus highlighting an implicit racism between different populations at the global level. Yet, and somewhat paradoxically, it is also precisely this kind of cultural racism that the ongoing securitization of AIDS is attempting to resist; the securitization of AIDS is being driven by the desire to make more resources available internationally for addressing the pandemic, and thus it does not seem ethically culpable with regard to furthering this kind of cultural racism. Indeed, the hope of combating such cultural racism forms a considerable part of its rhetorical force. There is, however, also evidence of a second and more subtle form of biological racism operating in the international AIDS debate. This racism is not so much concerned with the traditional war between races, as with more modern attempts to guard the biological health and fitness of the whole population or race vis- à-vis specific ‘diseased’ or ‘degenerate’ threats. Nazi eugenics, it is worth recalling, began in precisely such a vein – by first attempting to eradicate diseased people for the benefit of the health of the German population as a whole. Foucault thus noted how biopolitical (as opposed to cultural) racism appeals to the principle ‘that the death of others makes one biologically stronger insofar as one is a member of a race or a population.’62 This biological racism serving the population as a whole also occasionally surfaces in the debate on HIV/AIDS. In 1999, for example, one former UN Population Fund (UNFPA) official reportedly joked that AIDS would be one way of controlling population growth in Africa. Increased mortality, the official jibed, was one of three ways of controlling population growth, implying that this would be beneficial for those surviving the pandemic.63 Nor is this an isolated incident. The initial reaction of one official at the National Intelligence Council in the mid 1990s, responding to the early demand for a project on the security implications of AIDS, was reportedly: ‘Oh, it will be good, because Africa is overpopulated anyway.’64 Some have even committed such thoughts to paper. In a report by the World Bank from 1992 one can read that ‘[i]f the only effect of the AIDS epidemic were to reduce the population growth rate, it would increase the growth rate of per capita income in any plausible economic model’.65 Underlying such thinking is not a cultural racism, but a more subtle biological racism that pits the population or ‘race’ as a whole against HIV-positive persons by implying, however erroneously, that the former would be better off without the latter. Again, however, the securitization of AIDS is, at least on the surface of it, trying to combat this form of racism by calling for a more global and comprehensive response to the AIDS pandemic, and consequently does not appear ethically culpable with regard to furthering this kind of racism either. Where then, one might ask, is the evidence of the securitization of AIDS, as a biopolitical gesture, giving rise to new forms of racism in the way Foucault had warned? The extent to which novel forms of racism may emerge in the securitization of AIDS depends very much on exactly how HIV/AIDS is securitized. The tactical dilemma faced by all advocates and adherents of the securitization of AIDS is whether this securitization is to be achieved primarily on the basis of a national security or a human security framework. On the one hand, advocates of the securitization of AIDS clearly want this securitization to be successful in order for the normative benefits they envision to accrue as quickly as possible. This means casting HIV/AIDS as a security threat within the framework of national and international security, i.e. in terms that will appear most plausible and persuasive to the Security Council and the traditional security sector. This, in turn, would entail highlighting the effects of HIV/AIDS on the armed forces, on peacekeepers, and on state capacity. A human security framework, by contrast, is less likely to persuade the Security Council and the more traditionally oriented security sector to take the issue seriously at the highest levels, and is hence unlikely to achieve the same degree of political impact. So the tactical advantages of drawing on national and international security frameworks initially appear very compelling. Yet if the securitization of AIDS is to proceed solely or even primarily on the basis of national and international security, then it also inadvertently risks simply substituting the cultural racism it eagerly seeks to combat with a new strategic form of racism. Put differently, securitizing the illness in this manner could encourage an international response whereby medicines are provided not democratically and comprehensively to all who need them, but only to those populations who play a crucial role in maintaining national and international security, i.e. the armed forces and state elites. Securitizing AIDS with reference to national and international security may thus come to benefit those elites in question, but not the wider population. There is consequently a danger of the securitization of AIDS introducing a subtle put potentially disastrous new criterion for deciding who is allowed to live and who will be left to die; a criterion that assesses human beings not in terms of any intrinsic value, but on the basis of their strategic value. In this way the securitization of AIDS risks substituting a cultural racism with a new strategic racism that, from a biopolitical perspective, is still a racism because it would provide the crucial biopolitical function of deciding who must live and who must die. What is more, framing HIV/AIDS as a threat to national and international security also risks further fuelling the aforementioned biological racism that advocates of the securitization of AIDS are trying to combat. It does so by inadvertently construing persons living with HIV/AIDS as security threats. A characteristic headline from the British Daily Telegraph reads ‘African AIDS: Deadly Threat to Britain’.66 Nor is this an isolated incident; the portrayal of AIDS as being a disease that comes from foreigners, from outsiders, and especially from ‘black’ Africans, is a perennial feature of the discourse on AIDS ever since the illness was first discovered. Calls for quarantining people with HIV/AIDS not because of their skin colour but because of their biological characteristics, subjecting them to various forms of violence, attempting to bar such persons from serving in state institutions, and the refusal to issue visas to foreigners living with HIV, are only a few of the examples in which persons living with HIV/AIDS have been ostracized and even persecuted by some states for their illness. Nor are these examples confined to the dustbin of history. As recently as February 2003 the British government considered implementing compulsory HIV screening for prospective immigrants amid alleged worries that HIV-positive foreigners are traveling to the United Kingdom to seek treatment.67 Within the armed forces around the world, moreover, there has already been growing pressure to exclude soldiers living with HIV because the illness is being perceived as a security threat. As with Arendt’s aforementioned observations about ‘Jewishness’, there seems to be no escape from one’s HIV-status. Although the securitization of AIDS tries to remedy the cultural racism evident in the unequal global access to medicines, if it is conducted primarily on the grounds of national and international security it risks – contrary to its own intensions – furthering both a strategic racism that will save elites but not ordinary people, and a biological racism that fuels exclusionary practices regarding persons living with HIV. It is only by first acknowledging the biopolitical nature of the securitization of AIDS, that these novel ethical dangers can be identified.