Framing of terrorism is based on irrational thoughts that create endless war and state control
James Der Derian, leading IR theorist, respected professor, Political Science Professor, University of Massachusetts, 12/19/2008, Critical Practices in International Theory, pg. 70-72
For some, this kind of intellectual activity might be considered subversive. Indeed, former Secretary of State George Shultz in a major policy address on terrorism stated that the US cannot effectively respond to terrorism unless Americans are of one mind on the subject: "Our nation cannot summon the will to act without firm public understanding and support." Without such a consensus we risk becoming, in Shultz's words, "the Hamlet of nations, worrying endlessly over whether and how to respond." I believe, however, that it is time to take up a position of detachment towards terrorism that Hedley Bull approvingly referred to as "political nihilism". After all, "when times are out of joint," as they were for Hamlet and as they to be for the USA as the 1980s took a radical turn, we might find in Hamlet-who through his passionate yet intellectual introspection discovered just how rotten the declining state could be-a better guide than, say, Henry V-who "because he did not know how to govern his own kingdom, determined to make war upon his neighbors." We might also discover that there are more things in heaven and earth than are dreamt of in the official terrorist discourse, perhaps even uncomfortable truth that there is some of the terrorist in us, and some of us in the terrorist. My response, then, to Shultz is more diplomatic than politic:the new antidiplomatic estrangement of international relations requires that we endlessly mediate the terrorist act and the response to it with a deeper and broader knowledge of all practices of global political violence. Otherwise, the will to act becomes inseparable from the will to know, and terrorism becomes indistinguishable from counter-terrorism. Moreover, an alternative approach is needed because the problem of terrorism is implicated by a profound predicament that now confronts advanced societies. Call it late capitalism, post-modernism, post-warring, or as I prefer, neo-medievalism, it is a disturbing anxiety-inducing condition in which traditional modes of knowledge and formations of identity no longer seem up to the task of representing, let alone managing international relations. Nation-states never enjoyed a true monopoly on the use of force, but now more than in any other post-Westphalian time- and certainly at the accelerated pace-the legitimacy of that monopoly has come under serious challenges from social, economic, technical, and military changes. Interdependent economies, global ecological concerns penetration by surveillance and media technologies, the three dimensionality and nuclearization- they have all been recognized as growing antidiplomatic forces undermining the sovereign privileges and obligations of the territorial state. Less noticed and understood is the emergence of a terrorist discourse, by which I refer to a global semiotic activity where violent powers and insurgent meanings clash. WIth a nuclear statement curtailing superpower and a global information economy boosting sign-power, it is increasingly in the discursive realm of terrorism that the "crises" of political legitimacy, national identity, and practical knowledge are being played out. Simultaneously brutalizing, repugnant, and fascinating, the terrorist repertoire-kidnapping, hijackings, and assassination- cannot alone account for its rise to the singular status of international crisis. In terrorist discourse a less visible battle is being fought-most desperately between the vanguards of aspiring powers and the rearguards of great powers-to reinscribe the boundaries of legitimacy in international relations. In short, four important yet neglected theoretical points are being made here. In the study of terrorism, method matters: but very little critical consciousness of just how much it matters has been demonstrated in the field. Second, method is matter given the symbolic practices of terrorism, limitations of physical anti-terrorism, and the simulacral projection of terrorism by the media, the representations of terrorism have taken o n a powerful materiality. Third, because of changing configurations of power that rival traditional claims of international legitimacy, new critical methods are called for. Fourth, method alone cannot substitute for an ontological step that anyone seriously seeking truths about terrorism must take: questioning how our own identity is implicated and constituted by the terrorist discourse must precede any study of terrorism. These critical considerations inform the analysis of modern forms of terrorism that follows. Taking into account the sheer volume of terrorist archive, I can make no claims for comprehensiveness. My strategy is deconstructive and reconstructive: to provide a method which might displace, critique, and historicize received accounts of terrorism and, simultaneously, to present an alternative primer for reading terrorism in its multiple, de-terroitoralized forms. What I wish to avoid is the subtextual ploy found in much of the terrorism literature where the theoretical organization of an inchoate body of thought pretends to reconcile the differences and contradictions of the terrorism, thus "taming" rather than interpreting a heavily conflicted field. At best, I hope to leave the reader with a critical method and the minimal amount of historical knowledge necessary to distinguish the politically dispossessed from the violently possessed, and to imagine possible forms of coexistence with the former, while galivanting collective action against the latter.