Free beta access. 5 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Performative contradiction isn’t a unique voter – it allows us to prevent a sedimentation of knowledge – constant fear of it causes people to not write what is important but what doesn’t contradict

Pierre Schlag, April 1991, “SYMPOSIUM: THE CRITIQUE OF NORMATIVITY: ARTICLE: NORMATIVITY AND THE POLITICS OF FORM,” University of Pennsylvania Law Review, accessed through Nexus-Uni. ZKMSU

In other words, the disciplines and sub-disciplines quite literally organize themselves around aporias and paradoxes. They achieve a [*925] respectable formalization not because they "know" anything, but because they are organized so that they don't have to know about the contradictions, aporias, and paradoxes that surround them and that effectively define and limit their intellectual jurisdiction. As an example, consider the role of the performative contradiction. Until very recently, the worst thing one could do in academic thought was to get caught in a performative contradiction. Not surprisingly, after decades of striving to avoid performative contradictions, we have a sedimented academic structure and sedimented "knowledges" all nicely arranged in discursive formations constituted to avoid performative contradictions. But after decades of avoiding performative contradictions, there is now a new concern: where don't you go, what do you miss, if you keep trying to avoid performative contradictions? And, of course, there is a political angle to all this. After all, fear of performative contradiction discourages and marginalizes reflexive inquiry into the status of our own statements and our own knowledges. Fear of performative contradiction thus has a conservative effect. And what is conserved, of course, is the jurisdictional and structural integrity of our knowledges. But, of course, because this integrity depends upon such a truncated definition and establishment of the knowledges and the disciplines, it is almost a joke: integrity as joke.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.