Free beta access. 5 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

–Systemic study proves alt causes AND causality is mixed

Islami 21 – Zenobia, completed a doctorate in Politics and International Studies at the University of Cambridge. Before this she was a researcher at the Centre for Social Development in Africa at the University of Johannesburg. She also worked with the Afrobarometer research programme for three years based at Idasa where she was responsible for managing survey data collection in southern Africa and outreach co-ordination across all the countries in the study. In addition she was a senior researcher at the Community Agency for Social Enquiry where she managed a number of research projects for government departments and donors. Before moving into social research she was a market researcher working in the private sector and later a lecturer at the School of Economic and Business Sciences, University of the Witwatersrand. “Interaction between Food Prices and Political Instability”, The K4D helpdesk, https://opendocs.ids.ac.uk/opendocs/bitstream/handle/20.500.12413/16721/999_Food_Prices_and_Political_Instability.pdf?sequence=1&isAllowed=y, 05-21-2021

2. Methodological issues relating to food prices and political instability

Countries that are affected by food shortages tend to be prone to conflict, violence or instability. Nineteen countries that the Food and Agricultural Organisation (FAO) classifies as being in a protracted food crisis are also affected by conflict and violence (Martin-Shields & Stojets, 2018). Thus, scholars have pondered about the relationship between the availability of food and probability of conflict, especially after 2008 when the media reported on many food related protests in low-and-middle-income countries (Van Weezel, 2016). Furthermore, Smith (2014, p. 679) states that “Dramatic weather events, diversion of crops for fuel production, and continuing volatility in international grain markets have led many to postulate that urban food riots will become more frequent, pervasive and disruptive in the future.”

There is a body of literature which argues that grievances (or relative deprivation) lead to incentives for conflict. Literature in this vein argues that rising food prices increase the propensity for protests and food riots. Young men in particular may join rebel groups to gain access to food (Brinkman & Hendrix, 2011, Raleigh et al., 2015). However, finding the evidence to support these assertions is difficult because the relationship between food prices (as an indicator of the availability or accessibility of food) and conflict is both complex and influenced by many other factors (Smith 2014, van Weezel, 2016, Martin-Shields & Stojets, 2018). Therefore, it becomes difficult to find evidence of causal linkages between food prices and conflict. Moreover, the evidence may be contradictory. This section explores the methodological issues that make the interaction between food prices and political instability difficult to conceptualize and assess.

Endogeneity challenges

It is difficult to study the causal link between food prices and political instability because they are endogenous and there is limited evidence. According to Martin-Shields & Stojets (2018) there are two key sources of endogeneity, which are (1) unobserved confounding factors and (2) reverse causality. Confounding factors are strongly correlated with both food insecurity and conflict. For example, there is much evidence which suggests that national income is negatively correlated with violent conflict and positively correlated with food security. Likewise, state capacity is also related to violence and food security. Reverse causality occurs when it is difficult to ascertain the direction of the causal links: does food insecurity exacerbate conflict or does conflict contribute to food insecurity? (De Winne & Peersman, 2021; Raleigh et al., 2015). Some scholars have dealt with reverse causality by focusing their analysis on international food prices. They argue that international food prices are unlikely to be unaffected by local conflicts and as such there is less need for concern about endogeneity. However, it is still possible that global food prices can be confounded by variables such as global economic activity or oil prices (Smith, 2014). Some quantitative studies address endogeneity by including fixed effects or instrumental variables in models, but De Winne and Peersman (2021) are not convinced that this approach eliminates endogeneity.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.