Free beta access. 5 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

The foresight model is key to avert biosafety dangers

Cassidy Nelson, 9-8-2021 Future of Humanity Institute, University of Oxford ALSO Ilker Adiguzel, Marie-Valentine Florin, Filippa Lentzos, Rickard Knutsson, Catherine Rhodes, Paul Rutten & Annika Vergin, , https://link.springer.com/chapter/10.1007/978-94-024-2086-9_12, "Foresight in Synthetic Biology and Biotechnology Threats," SpringerLink (ermo/sms, Acc:6-25-2022)

The study of the future dates back to antiquity. Understanding what could lie ahead was of strategic importance to rulers and military leaders and was of great general interest to ancient societies and religions. While cultures developed different ways of thinking about the future that evolved over time, a historically common point of view was that there was one single predetermined future (Cuhls et al. 2012). The systematic study of different possible futures, and how these could be shaped by present actions, emerged as a new field of inquiry in the mid-twentieth century, in part due to pioneering work conducted by the Research and Development (RAND) corporation in Santa Monica, California (Kaplan et al. 1950; Helmer 1967). Since its emergence, the field of futures studies has undergone rapid expansion with the refinement of its conceptual underpinnings and development of different methodologies.

Today, futures work is undertaken by governments, militaries and scientific institutions, and other interested groups, with the aim of gaining actionable insight into possible emerging futures. In fields like synthetic biology and biotechnology that are undergoing rapid and continuous change, the ability to gain strategic insight from possible futures is highly relevant to policy development, risk assessment and threat analysis. It is particularly important to be able to identify the underlying drivers, range of uncertainty, points of convergence, and potential opportunities and challenges in these developing fields, and how these might be affected by particular policy interventions. For all of these, foresight – a process of conducting futures work – can offer strategic insight.

Foresight has been defined in multiple ways. In this chapter, we use an understanding commonly found in the literature, which highlights that it is first and foremost a process that involves “systematically attempting to look into the longer-term future of science, technology, the economy and society” through which “one comes to a fuller understanding of the forces shaping the long-term future” (Martin 1995; Miles 2010). Foresight, therefore, differs from forecasting, in that it does not aim to predict the future. Although the two terms are sometimes used interchangeably, forecasting is concerned with making “a probabilistic statement, on a relatively high confidence level, about the future” (Martin 2010).

Foresight can also be contrasted with hindsight, which is a systematic examination of the past. While the past offers useful information that can inform a foresight process, hindsight has access to outcome information that foresight does not. Care should be taken when combining these processes in order to avoid “observation selection effects” or biasing thinking towards historical occurrences (Fischhoff 1975).

Many additional terms specific to futures studies have been introduced and refined in the literature, with some confusion arising given shared and contradictory wording used in colloquial contexts (Trump et al. 2019). In order to use clear terminology in describing futures research, with the aim of developing a consistent lexicon across NATO partners, a definitions list is provided below. This is followed by examples of foresight research conducted on the topics of emerging synthetic biology and biotechnology.

The two subsequent sections provide an overview of different foresight methodologies and present an approach to foresight question choice, highlighting some specific questions for synthetic biology and biotechnology. Finally, recommendations for the design of a foresight process are offered, with the intention of providing a useable resource for NATO partners investigating emerging synthetic biology and biotechnology threats.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.