Free beta access. 5 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Empire is ever present, materializing and legitimatized by crisis that demand multilateral action in the same direction.

Tabachnick & Koivukoski 9 - Chair of the Department of Political Science, Philosophy and Economics & Associate Professor of Political Science at Nipissing University, (David and Toivo, "Enduring Empire: Ancient Lessons for Global Politics," University of Toronto Press, 09-05-2009, https://ebookcentral-proquest-com.proxy.lib.umich.edu/lib/umichigan/detail.action?docID=4672959#goto_toc, Accessed 7-21-2022, LASA-CB)

It would be difficult to deny that the United States, at one time or another, has acted in an imperialist manner. If empire is defined as the domination of one people by another state separate and alien from it, then assuredly there have been episodes in which one can speak confidently of an American empire. In the 1830s an opponent of Indian[Indigenous] removal, Congressman Henry Storrs, declared that he would not sacrifice the reputation of America’s founders, who had counselled just treatment of the native inhabitants, ‘for all the Indian[Indigenous] lands that avarice ever dreamt of, and all the empire which ambition ever coveted.’ Of course he lost that argument.12 The Cherokee and other southern tribes were removed. So, too, America undoubtedly acquired an empire in the war against Spain at the end of the nineteenth century. The regeneration of the Philippines and the acquisition of protectorates over various Caribbean islands followed an imperialist script. ’Has it ever occurred to you,’ asked the Missionary Journal in 1899, ‘that Jesus was the most imperial of imperialists?’13 When facing peoples outside the society of states (then European and Christian in character), the United States did indeed act so as to displace peoples in its path. Thus far, then, those who would insist on a long imperial pedigree for America are adducing facts that cannot be denied. It is also true, however, that when America faced towards Europe and the society of states, its message was avowedly anti-imperial.

Several pertinent distinctions, moreover, are lost if the Bush Doctrine is seen as simply the latest instalment in a long imperial project. If it is true that there are precedents for an American imperialism, it is also true that Bush raised the empire business to an entirely new level. At its core, the Bush Doctrine proposed that the United States extend the position of military domination that fell to it as a consequence of victory in the Cold War; and that same doctrine was unafraid and unapologetic when it came to using force to reshape the international system. In embracing a doctrine of preventive war, the United States was abandoning the policies of containment and deterrence that it had followed during the Cold War. In announcing that it intended to preserve against all rivals its pre- eminent military status, it was jettisoning its previous commitment to arms control. In its insistence that it would no longer be bound by the laws traditionally governing the use of force – laws that forbid preventive war, torture, and the violent overthrow of regimes for the purpose of changing their political form – the United States had come to breathe a spirit of defiance towards international law. Especially in the early years of the Bush administration, America seemed recklessly indifferent to the views of traditional allies and airily dismissed the importance of showing a decent respect for the opinion of mankind.

In its pure form, as it were, the distilled essence of the Bush Doctrine was undoubtedly an imperial project, one that was far in advance of America’s Cold War policy. It proposed a mastery of the state system by one power that recalled what Schell termed ‘the hoary old nightmare of the ages, the always feared but never realized project of universal empire.’14 Whereas empire signifies the domination of one people by another, universal empire had traditionally signified the domination by one power of the state system as a whole. This vision could only really take root in circumstances of unipolarity. In this regard, a new vista had opened after the collapse of the Soviet Union that created an entirely different milieu from that which existed during the Cold War. Those observers (among both supporters and critics) who insisted that the Bush Doctrine represented a revolutionary change in American policy were closer to the mark than those who emphasized continuity.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.