Free beta access. 5 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

The alternative is to forget---that escapes the vicious circle that gave rise to hegemonic practices. That enables a tabula rasa of the consciousness that offers opportunities to think and act beyond the confines of our desolate present.

Bleiker 1997 [Roland Bleiker; “Forget IR Theory” Bleiker teaches international relations, peace studies and political theory at the University of Queensland. Sage Publications, 1997 https://www.jstor.org/stable/40644880 Accessed 7/22/22 //jerry]

To forget orthodox IR theory is not to ignore the IR practices that have framed our realities. Countless events of the past, such as the Holocaust, cannot and should not be simply chased out of our collective memory. Nor is it to turn a blind eye toward the violent nature that characterizes present world politics. Forgetting is not only a negative process, a neglecting and overlooking, but also a necessary part of our existence, something we often do without being aware of it. Jeanette Winterson: They say that every snowflake is different. If that were true, how could we go on? How could we ever get up and off our knees? How could we ever recover from the wonder of it? By forgetting. We cannot keep in mind too many things. There is only the present and nothing to remember.5 The task, then, becomes one of turning forgetting from a selective, arbitrary, and unconscious constitution of things past into an active, conscious, and more inclusive process. Instead of perpetuating IR nostalgia, seeking comfort and security in the familiar interpretation of long-gone epochs, even if they are characterized by violence and insecurity, conscious forgetting opens up possibilities for a dialogical understanding of our present and past. It refuses to tie future possibilities to established forms of life. Rather than further entrenching current IR security dilemmas by engaging with the orthodox discourse that continuously gives meaning to them, forgetting tries to escape the vicious circle by which these social practices serve to legitimize and objectivize the very discourses that have given rise to them. Forgetting becomes an instrument of dialogue and inclusion; it reorients our memories, becomes active by turning into forge(t) and for(to)get. From this vantage point, forgetting is a process or remembering, or, seen from Milan Kundera's reversed perspective, "remembering is a form of forgetting." I will draw primarily upon the work of Friedrich Nietzsche to explore the process of forgetting orthodox IR theory. This is not to essentialize Nietzsche or render him heroic but to employ his work as a steppingstone, a source to provoke thought before it, too, has to be forgotten in order not to turn into a new orthodoxy. The process of forgetting, for Nietzsche, is a process of healing: Only now do I believe you healed: for healed is who forgot.7 Nietzsche ended up with this position by dealing with a set of methodological dilemmas similar to those I am trying to address in this article. The need to forget emerges from recognizing the problematic links that are commonly drawn between cause and effect. Such a duality, Nietzsche claims, probably never existed. We merely establish arbitrary links between things that we consider important, isolate a couple of pieces out of a continuum of complex and intertwined events. This is why it is futile to search for a causal origin in this web of human life and to think we could somehow ground a better world on this form of flawed insight. "How foolish it would be," Nietzsche claims, "to suppose that one only needs to point out this origin and this misty shroud of delusion in order to destroy the world that counts for real, so-called "reality. "8 Nietzsche's skepticism toward grounding critique in an investigation of the origins of things is important. It is one of the reasons why some consider his work as the conceptual turning point from modernity to postmodernity.9 Nietzsche's own words may explain best the importance of forgetting for a critique of orthodox IR: Why is it that this thought comes back to me again and again and in ever more varied colours? - that formerly, when investigators of knowledge sought out the origin of things they always believed they would discover something of incalculable significance for all later action and judgment, that they always presupposed, indeed, that the salvation of man must depend on insight into the ongins of things, but . . . The more insight we possess into an ongin the less significant does the ongin appear: while what is nearest to us, what is around us and in us, gradually begins to display colors and beauties and enigmas and riches of significance of which earlier mankind had not an inkling.10 By observing why Nietzsche ended up with this position, I will explore the "riches of significance" that could emerge once we liberate IR theory from the compulsion to link the search for peace with exploring the origins of present dilemmas in world politics. I will then retrace Nietzsche's next step, an engagement with what he calls "active forgetfulness," a way of thinking that enables "a tabula rasa of the consciousness," makes room for new things, new thoughts, new possibilities.11 My approach to forgetting IR theory will revolve primarily around issues of language: how they constrain and enable, how they are part of a discursive form of domination and, at the same time, offer powerful opportunities to think and act beyond the narrow confines of our present world. In that sense, my article deals with methodological concerns - with what conventionally is considered form rather than substance. Yet, the manner in which we approach, think, conceptualize, and formulate IR has a significant impact on how it is practiced. Language frames politics. Form turns into substance.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.