Free beta access. 5 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

The plan plays into the Islamophobic racial capitalist terror-industrial complex

Rana 16 – Associate Professor of Asian American Studies at the University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign and Ph.D. in Social Anthropology from the University of Texas (Junaid, “The Racial Infrastructure of the Terror-Industrial Complex”, Social Text 129, Vol. 34, No. 4, pp. 111-138, https://read.dukeupress.edu/social-text/article/34/4%20(129)/111/31152/The-Racial-Infrastructure-of-the-Terror-Industrial, December 2016)

The scene Powell portrays situates mainstream American Christianity with an assumed other of Hinduism, and a notable avoidance of any direct reference to Islam, with a now familiar exhortation of the exceptionalism of the United States. And this may be the point: one does not need to mention Islam to use the dog-whistle terms that imply Muslims in the War on Terror. That there is a fear of a few “dangerous” elements threatening the “survival” of the entire system betrays a deeper issue at hand. Powell’s description contains an implicit assumption that Islam is a ubiquitous category of other that need not be named for it to lurk otherwise in the thoughts of readers. This of course is an accepted conceit of the post-9/11 world, in which the War on Terror has created a media subtext of any and all forms of terror. Earlier in the interview Powell used the pronoun they to describe “terrorists” in comparing the “American way of life” as stronger than threats of death and the destruction of property, again the presumption that war and violence are already givens in the landscape of the democratic future of the United States. The dangerous elements in Brooklyn and New Jersey that Powell referred to are an evocative object, one that names something without specifics and in a language that is understood as a proliferation of unending possibility. Like Eisenhower’s famous warning of a military-industrial complex in 1961, Powell raises this issue of a terror-industrial complex somewhat in passing to tout a sense of American superiority—a “we are better than this” sort of mentality that situates the democratic political system as the highest form of collective decision making and prosperity. For much of the mainstream media at the time, the mention of the terror-industrial complex failed to make an impact. In large part this warning from Powell was a side conversation to the lead of the story. In this same interview Powell issued an apology, admitting that he had made a mistake in reporting to the United Nations that the US government had information regarding weapons of mass destruction in Iraq. The reference to the terror-industrial complex stayed buried until 2009, when Keith Olbermann of MSNBC broadcast a video interview with Colin Powell from 2007. Here campus journalists from the University of Oklahoma newspaper the Oklahoma Daily had asked him to expand on the idea shortly after he made his original statement. Powell responded by elaborating his description of the concept of the terror-industrial complex as follows: We’re spending an enormous amount of money on Homeland Security. And I think we should spend whatever it takes. But I think we have to be careful that we don’t get so caught up in trying to throw money at the terrorist and counter-terrorist problem that we essentially are creating an industry that will only exist as long as you keep the terrorist threat pumped up. . . . We spend a lot of money to put a lot of equipment out there, kind of terrorism equipment. But now we need more money to keep that equipment running. Well, let’s make sure that what we have sent out there is absolutely essential. And let’s be cautious in our appropriations and in spending money. I don’t think we’re out of control, I think we had to respond in an aggressive way. But it’s now been six years. Let’s make sure we’re spending money on the right things, and not spending money just to spend money.2 This unusual admission of spending on the “terrorist and counterterrorist problem” is wrapped in the standard conservative discourse of fiscal restraint and government downsizing. Powell makes apparent that the term terror-industrial complex describes a relationship with money, or financial capital, in which the threat of terrorism supersedes actually existing danger, in other words, spending money in the aims of gaining an upper hand in a security situation that requires an adept military industry. In a similar vein, James Risen has recently called this formation the Homeland Security–industrial complex to reference the proliferation of companies seeking military contracts to provide the infrastructure of the Global War on Terrorism.3 In making a distinction from the military-industrial complex, Risen describes this system thus: “The new homeland security-complex operates differently. It is largely made up of a web of intelligence agencies and their contractors, companies that mostly provide secret services rather than large weapons systems and equipment. These contractors are hired to help Washington determine the scale and scope of the terrorist threat; they make no money if they determine that the threat is overblown or, God forbid, if the war on terror ever comes to an end.”4 Risen refers to details shared by these conceptual approaches through an explicit mandate through independent contractors while also highlighting a temporal frame of the security obsession with terror. This system that is so concerned with combating terrorism is indeed premised on a fundamental shift in military combat that reimagines the terms of war and the notion of an enemy. Propagating this in terms of a future sense of permanence and fixity, there is a financial interest for those who predict terrorism in such static terms. In other words, this is a system of war with no end, and the fulfillment of a system of racial capitalism that I describe as racial infrastructure. Infrastructure in the Marxist usage refers to the means of production and the category of class, or what might be referred to more generally as economic and social position. While infrastructure connotes the basic physical and organizational facilities from which society or a social system operates, I am here referring to racial infrastructure as a spatial formation in which the social, political, and economic relationships of racial systems operate through dominance and discursive power. What I find instructive in the examples used by Risen and a range of reportage on the post-9/11 security state and the War on Terror is the unspoken racialization of terror with Islam and Muslims.5 Certainly, Risen and others are critical of how the War on Terror fixates on Islam through an oversimplified syllogism that equates Muslims with terrorism, yet as I argue in what follows, the impact of the terror-industrial complex is far more extreme than a representational mistake based in the fearmongering of Islam and Muslims. Rather, it is the larger systems of structural violence that are normalized through the workings of concepts such as race and permanent war that create an unprecedented flexibility in the workings of social domination and capital accumulation. As an ideological structure it is present in a range of security and biopolitical technologies, including, for example, policing, health care, social services, and the framing of criminality and illegality in the detention and deportation regime. Whereas the military-industrial complex conjoined national military and political forces with the arms industry, the shift toward the private sector to conduct military and intelligence operations is part of the transition into the twenty-first-century development of the terror-industrial complex and what others such as Risen refer to in terms of security. Although the concomitant or analogous construction to terror in this sense is security, a concept that has often been used in political theory, I prefer to think through these conjoined forces using the notion of terror. Security is certainly an important ideological piece of how the terror-industrial complex is deployed, alongside other representations of state power such as surveillance. However, terror also indicates the shift from institutions of power to amorphous ideas so endemic in the rubrics of the War on Terror.6 The terror-industrial complex has dramatically shaped and altered social life across geographic locations with dramatic differences in scale. The wide-ranging escalation of structural and physical violence through war include, for example, the use of drones in targeted assassination and surveillance of social life, the everyday conditions of military occupation through means of war and governance, domestic and foreign mass surveillance, the militarization of policing domestically, and the use of surveillance and intelligence gathering by local law enforcement in collaboration or modeled after domestic and international spying agencies. Recent scholarship has begun to chip away at these deep transformations to social life that are guided by the racialization of Islam and Muslims.7 It is in this sense that, while the Obama administration no longer uses the specific term War on Terror to describe what rapidly developed under the Bush years after 9/11, the expansion of the security and surveillance state has brought the enormous apparatus of the terror-industrial complex into full bloom.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.