The Alternative is to reject the Aff and rethink our approach to Islamic taqwa – Only a shift away from NATO’s inherent Islamophobic rhetoric can restructure the extremist threat It solves for the affs desire of security
Farhadi 20, - Adib Farhadi is an assistant professor at University of South Florida and coordinator of USF's Executive Education Program. August 6 2020 “Countering Violent Extremism by Winning Hearts and Minds” https://link-springer-com.proxy.lib.umich.edu/content/pdf/10.1007/978-3-030-50057-3.pdf, Accessed 7-19-2022, LASA-BF)
This book argues that we ought to take all forms of Islamophobia seriously. Too often,
Americans respond to the fear of an impending terror attack by turning on our own. But
if the United States continues to leave 3.5 million Americans vulnerable to hate and
prejudice, national security can never be fully established, and the core narrative of
counterinsurgency and counterterrorism, and counterradicalization will be undermined.
Islamophobia directly and indirectly hinders the efforts of the United States and its
allies to develop strong ties with the local and global Muslim population that are critical
to achieving durable peace in Afghanistan and advancing the U.S.’s position in the
Great Powers Competition. The goal of violent extremists is not only to combat the U.
S. and NATO militarily, but also to undermine the perception of cohesion within
Western society. By creating an “us-versus-them” mentality between Westerners and
Muslims, they hope to lure people into their cause for retribution. Therefore, the
approach to combatting violent extremists should also involve undermining their
narrative and winning the support of local communities. Fostering cooperation and
supplying the communities with necessities can help prevent additional violent
extremist groups from arising and recruiting new members. Given that the U.S. and
NATO forces have unintentionally offended local communities, it would be in the best
interest of coalition forces to recruit members of the communities and those who are
knowledgeable of the values of the local and neighboring communities. Creating social
integration domestically will also be paramount to our efforts in Islamic nations.
Because the narrative of inclusivity is the only narrative that can defeat the narrative
of alienation and separation that is promoted by violent extremists, there can be no
room for any form of discrimination from the West or coalition forces. Any tinge of
Islamophobia, whether direct or perceived, puts the narrative of inclusivity at risk and
undermines the victims of 9/11, the efforts and treasury put into the war, and the blood
and sacrifices of each soldier who has fought to uphold freedom and democracy. When
negativity is broadcast, whether via national leadership, mass media coverage, social
media, or Hollywood, and whether by private individuals or organizations, it fuels the
narratives of violent extremists, who exploit them to their advantage and claim that
these actions are America’s and the West’s true intentions. The propagandists strategically attempt to create the discord and division using various media as a megaphone
to amplify the message that the U.S. and the West are out to destroy Islam and its way
of life. Respecting American Muslims and protecting their civil rights is not only the right
thing to do; it is also in line with our espoused American values and demonstrates to the
world that we live up to our values of respecting religious freedom and embracing all
law-abiding people. Embracing law-abiding Muslims refutes the claims of extremist
propaganda. In a sense, the aggregate violent extremists’ movements might be considered a form of global insurgency that can only be countered through positive relationships between the U.S. Government and Muslim communities, both domestically and internationally. Insurgents work by attempting to delegitimize the opposing government, and the easiest way to destroy the credibility of the U.S. government is to create the perception of hypocrisy (Headquarters Department of the Army 2006). If we fail to support and enforce the civil rights of American Muslims simply because of ethnic or religious differences, then we are seen as hypocrites who cannot be trusted.
Perhaps we should instead take a hard and practical look at what bureaucracy, money, military, and programs can never accomplish: inclusiveness, relationship-building, partnership, knowledge-sharing, appreciation, creativity, collaboration, dignity, respect, empathy, and equality. Effective relationships are made possible through understanding, respect, and mutual trust.