AI soon to takeover politics to reaffirm authoritarian and fascist ideology to eradicate democracy
Ünver 18 (Akın, associate professor of IR at Ozyegin University, former research associate at Oxford University, The 2021 Science Academy of Turkey’s ‘Outstanding Young Scientist’, “Artificial Intelligence, Authoritarianism, and the Future of Political Systems”, 7/1/18, https://www.jstor.org/stable/pdf/resrep26084.pdf?refreqid=excelsior%3A1b398a4cb80c5f85d280d26dbc1f9669&ab_segments=&origin=&acceptTC=1)
In a public discussion with Arkady Vorozh, the CEO of Yandex, Russian President Vladimir Putin asserted that whichever country would master the A.I. in the short-term, ‘will be the ruler of the world.’ Elon Musk later shared Putin’s words on Twitter, who added ‘Competition for AI superiority at the national level most likely cause of WW3’.26 Both Putin and Musk statements constitute high-level affirmations of algorithmic feudalism, given how they both locate the A.I.’s immediate role within political anarchy and global leadership to circumvent its effects. Both, furthermore, view A.I. mastery as an inherently zero-sum game, in which one power has to dominate and others, become dominated. Although Putin’s statement referred to both military and non-military applications of A.I., the rest of his statement specifically referred to threats originating from the automation of security tools (drones, cybersecurity, 3D printing), instead of finance, healthcare or other non-military applications of A.I. Both Putin and Musk deviate significantly from Emmanuel Macron, for example, who gave an exclusive interview to Wired on France’s A.I. strategy, where he focused exclusively on healthcare, finance and political participation aspects of algorithmic structures, rather than their military applications.27 ‘A.I. feudalism’ then, has to imply a political regime, primarily geared towards eliminating systemic anarchy and revolves directly around security provision, both domestically and internationally, in exchange for financial and human capital provision. In domestic politics, it implies riot control and surveillance industries, whereas internationally it concerns cybersecurity, unmanned systems and a wide array of communication-related fronts. The most immediate impact of A.I. that might reinforce the feudalistic tendencies of the digital space is to create a production system mimicking corporatism - namely, the reconfiguration of power relations through sectoral alliances between coder syndicates and guilds. This would entail the control of algorithm-building and maintaining structures that both state and private actors rely on, and the foundation of the future economic system. The corporatization of A.I. could reinforce power-centralization through the combination of corporations that monopolize modes of code and coder production that will disproportionately influence politics, military and science affairs. This will effectively generate a feudal network that minimizes political participation and representation, leading to the eradication of democracy. The Habermasian ‘algorithmic enclosures’ that are obscure and inaccessible will establish robust control mechanisms on the society and in turn, empower coder oligarchies and corporations in charge of them. The second alarmist trend in the popular mainstream is the idea that the A.I. will create a ‘fascist system’28 - where the over-centralized A.I.-based decision-making will create a hierarchy of repression in which control-oriented, top-down practices will restrict expression, engagement, oversight and political information-seeking behavior. These fears have been intensified with the rise of the far-right groups in the US and Europe in the last years, bolstered by Internet trolls, fake news, and bots. According to the conceptualization of Foucault29 and Canguilhem30, the way technology and science are deployed by fascist regimes snowball into a social force, bursting their initial utilitarian origins and take on a life of their own. Technologism then determines the bounds of rights and freedoms in a society, becoming the real political ideology in fascist regimes. In ‘techno-fascism,’ all aspects of social life are controlled with the purpose of maximizing scientific progress and technological advances that are in turn, used to exert newer forms of sectoral control over social life. Views that don’t conform or fully converge to the hegemonic ideology are taken out of the equation through imprisonment and death. Totalitarianism is different from authoritarianism in this context since the latter denotes the centralization of political power without the need to control thoughts and actions of all citizens through a revolutionary mechanism to change the human nature or the world at whole. An ‘A.I. fascism’ or totalitarianism, therefore, has to entail a bid to change human relations and social interactions; merely political control and centralization are not enough on their own