US needs dod ai leadership/ai in military
NSCAI 21 “final report” National Security Commission on Artificial Intelligence: Eric Schmidt (Chair) Safra Catz, Steve Chien, Mignon Clyburn, Chris Darby, Kenneth Ford, José-Marie Griffiths, Robert Work (Vice Chair), Eric Horvitz, Andrew Jassy, Gilman Louie, William Mark, Jason Matheny, Katharina McFarland, Andrew Moore https://www.nscai.gov/wp-content/uploads/2021/03/Full-Report-Digital-1.pdf
Even with the right artificial intelligence (AI)-ready technology foundations in place, the U.S. military will still be at a battlefield disadvantage if it fails to adopt the right concepts and operations to integrate AI technologies. Throughout history, the best adopters and integrators, rather than the best technologists, have reaped the military rewards of new technology.1 The Department of Defense (DoD) should not be a witness to the AI revolution in military affairs, but should deliver it with leadership from the top, new operating concepts, relentless experimentation, and a system that rewards agility and risk. A new warfighting paradigm is emerging because of AI. Our competitors are making substantial investments to take advantage of it. This idea has been called “algorithmic” or “mosaic” warfare2; China’s theorists have called it “intelligentized” war.3 All of these terms capture, in various ways, how a new era of conflict will be dominated by AI and pit algorithms against algorithms. Advantage will be determined by the amount and quality of a military’s data, the algorithms it develops, the AI-enabled networks it connects, the AIenabled weapons it fields, and the AI-enabled operating concepts it embraces to create new ways of war. Today’s DoD is trying to execute an AI pivot, but without urgency. Despite pockets of imaginative reform and a few farsighted leaders, DoD remains locked in an Industrial Age mentality in which great-power conflict is seen as a contest of massed forces and monolithic platforms and systems. The emerging ubiquity of AI in the commercial realm and the speed of digital transformation punctuate the risk of not pivoting fast enough. The Department must act now to integrate AI into critical functions, existing systems, exercises, and wargames to become an AI-ready force by 2025. Simultaneously, DoD must develop more creative warfighting concepts that are paired with investments in future AI-enabled technologies to continuously out-innovate potential adversaries. If our forces are not equipped with AI-enabled systems guided by new concepts that exceed those of their adversaries, they will be outmatched and paralyzed by the complexity of battle.To compete, deter, and, if necessary, fight and win in future conflicts requires wholesale adjustments to operational concepts, technologies, organizational structures, and how we integrate allies and partners into operations. It will also require risk-based assessments of both the benefits and drawbacks of widespread integration of AI-enabled capabilities, to include future autonomous weapon systems. Lastly, it will require a willingness to engage in bilateral and multilateral dialogues with our allies and partners to urge them to make similar AI pivots to ensure future interoperability. CHAPTER 3 79 p How AI Will Change Warfare. AI-enabled warfare will not hinge on a single new weapon, technology, or operational concept; rather, it will center on the application and integration of AI-enabled technologies into every facet of warfighting. AI will transform the way war is conducted in every domain from undersea to outer space, as well as in cyberspace and along the electromagnetic spectrum. It will impact strategic decision-making, operational concepts and planning, tactical maneuvers in the field, and back-office support. In this new kind of warfare, traditional confines of the battlefield will be expanded through AI-enabled micro-targeting, disinformation, and cyber operations, as described in Chapter 1 of this report. AI will reshape many attributes of war, such as its speed, tempo, and scale; the relationships service members have with machines; the persistence with which the battlefield can be monitored; and the discrimination and precision with which targets can be attacked. There will be a premium on speed and accuracy in developing knowledge, acting, and reacting as the conflict unfolds. AI will make the process of finding and hitting targets of military value faster and more efficient. It will also increase accuracy of target identification and minimize collateral damage. Currently, this process generally involves passing data in a serial fashion from a sensor, through a series of humans, to a platform that can shoot at the target. AI will help automate some of the intermediate stages of the decision process. AI will also create opportunities for more advanced processes that would operate more akin to a web, fusing multiple sensors and platforms to manage complex data flows and transmitting actionable information to human operators and machines across all domains.4 In war, many of the military uses of AI will complement, rather than supplant, the role of humans. AI tools will improve the way service members perceive, understand, decide, adapt, and act in the course of their missions. However, new concepts for military operations will also need to account for the changing ways in which humans will be able to delegate increasingly complex tasks to AI-enabled systems. In the near term, this will be managed through the military’s principle of “mission command,” which stresses decentralized execution and disciplined initiative by subordinates who follow a commander’s intent. This human-centric approach to fighting should remain the standard for the foreseeable future. But as AI continues to advance into the cognitive and neuromorphic domain, and human-machine teaming becomes more sophisticated, the military will need to develop more imaginative concepts and organizational constructs that take full advantage of AI technologies without relinquishing the principles that undergird mission command. This list of how AI might transform warfighting principles and capabilities—as well as others like it—is by no means exhaustive. Innovation will lead to future capabilities that are unknowable at present and will only become clearer in time.