Alt fails---the neg fails to address gender norms that make the multitude impossible
Susanne Schultz Translated By Frederick Peters 6. Earth and Environmental Sciences - Academic & Research, Department of Earth and Environmental Sciences,Manchester Environmental Research Institute, FSE Research Institutes, professor of evolutionary ecology and conservation at the university of Manchester. “Dissolved Boundaries and “Affective Labor”: On the Disappearance of Reproductive Labor and Feminist Critique in Empire.” Taylor & Francis. 8-1-2006. https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/10455750500505473 //NM
If one wants to do justice to this claim, one would have to push the organization of the boundary between paid and unpaid labor into the center of a critique of political economy*/and this in order to comprehend the very shifts in this boundary. The thesis of a dissolving boundary between production and reproduction treats this boundary as an historical relic, an object of anachronistic research agendas, and thus no longer a valid subject of study. In Hardt and Negri, the division between productive and reproductive work only appears in the form of the distinction 9 Hardt and Negri, op. cit., p. 364. 10 Frigga Haug, ‘‘Zur Theorie der Geschlechterverha¨ltnisse,’’ Argument, 243, 2001, pp. 761/787. 11Hardt and Negri, op. cit., p. 274. 80 SUSANNE SCHULTZ Downloaded by [Erciyes University] at 05:18 22 December 2014 between direct and indirect forms of capitalist exploitation.12 This may be read as a vague reference to longstanding debates about the role of household work in the generation of surplus value, debates which Hardt and Negri do not engage with explicitly. Certainly, the thesis on the dissolution of boundaries makes it impossible to critique the hierarchies that are produced in the process of dividing paid from unpaid work. This does not mean, however, that the division between productive and reproductive labor is not shifting. This becomes particularly clear when one considers hegemonic models of ‘‘‘female’’ wage labor, notably the attractive model of the ‘‘successful’’ professional woman in the fields of culture, finance or advertising. Empire correctly thematizes how qualifications acquired during so-called free time through cultural or political groups or through private relationships become valorized in the labor process. The division between work and leisure has become more mutable as a result of flexible working time. Certainly, the housewife model*/ the hegemonic model of femininity under Fordism*/no longer applies (and was never a reality for many women, in any case). In light of these displacements, one should not lose sight of the fact that these boundaries shift in significantly uneven ways. Women’s workforce participation faces extremely stable gender divisions of labor in the so-called sphere of reproductive work, notably in child and elderly care. One only has to recall that that a mere 1.5 percent of people who take official parental leave in Germany are men. In this sense, the convergence model of production and reproduction reflects less the reality of labor relations than an increasingly hegemonic image of female subjectivity, where reproductive labor disappears into the holes and gaps of the patchwork that is the neoliberal working day. The delegation of reproductive labor to underprivileged women, particularly migrant women, is certainly to be understood as a displacement of the boundaries between productive and reproductive labor as well. This case expresses everything but the dissolution of (unpaid) reproductive labor, however. One factor accounts for the extreme social and financial devaluation of this work. It is not seen as skilled and qualified labor, but rather as something that women and girls are ‘‘naturally’’ socialized to do. Also, reproductive labor remains structurally close to unpaid labor, with its extreme flexibility of hours and tasks as well as the mechanisms of emotional dependence and familial loyalty. This domestic worker model, which depends on high wage differentials, cannot be universalized. It is logically untenable for a domestic worker to pay yet another domestic to look after her own reproductive work. Finally, the thesis of a shrinking divide between production and reproduction appears absurd when one thinks of the neoliberal cutbacks to public services such as kindergartens and health care, which (re)privatize reproductive labor and force unpaid women to pick up the slack in the system. 12Ibid., p. 53. DISSOLVED BOUNDARIES AND ‘‘AFFECTIVE LABOR’’ 81 Downloaded by [Erciyes University] at 05:18 22 December 2014 How unpaid reproductive labor should be organized is no longer a question when its disappearance is quietly presupposed, as in Empire. Rather than speaking about a dissolution of the boundaries between production and reproduction, it would make more sense to analyze the restructuring of reproductive labor along the categories ‘‘race, class, gender’’ on an international level. This would be the only way to realize a materialist approach to the ‘‘production of life,’’ something Hardt and Negri promise but do not carry out. Because Empire offers no basis for a critique of the political economy of gender regimes, its claim to subvert dominant models of subjectivity must fail.