Free beta access. 5 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Alt fails and TURNS impacts--- The neg interpretation of Empire leads to more existential risks like war and economic collapse

Colin John, Michael Roberts 11. Brunel university, professor of sociology and communications. “Postmodern Left-Liberalism: Hardt and Negri and the Disavowal of Critique.” SAGE Journals. 2-28-2011. https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/abs/10.1177/0896920510379442 //NM

Our charge against Hardt and Negri and other similar left-liberal theorists, then, is twofold. First, they misinterpret Marx’s labour theory of value by regarding immaterial labour as historically and constitutively distinct from the relations of capital that Marx analysed. Second, and consequently, they fetishize protests whether antagonistic of capital or not, ideologically Marxist or not, strategically effective or not. Whereas Deleuze and Guattari distinguish between movements of flight and movements of interest, Hardt and Negri do not. Their use of both Marx and Deleuze and Guattari is selective at best. This has important consequences for understanding the nature of capital and formulating strategies for resisting capital. Indeed, it is with some irony that Capital and AntiOedipus are prescient of the current financial crisis of capitalism. A reading of Capital through Anti-Oedipus should have provided Hardt and Negri with the means to develop a historically important critique of finance capital and to develop ideas on resistance that are currently absent in left thinking. Instead, we get a theoretically inventive but ultimately left-liberal tome masquerading as political radicalism. In his recent book on violence Žižek makes the point that ‘the threat today is not passivity, but pseudo-activity, the urge to be “active”, to “participate”, to mask the nothingness of what goes on’ (Žižek, 2008: 183). Quoting from the same source, it is better, as Badiou argues, ‘to do nothing than to contribute to the invention of formal ways of rendering visible that which Empire already recognizes as existent.’ This is what Hardt and Negri’s work has amounted to. A misrecognition of power is present to the extent that they can celebrate the ‘carnivalesque’ king-for-a-day spectacles of protest while the capitalist class relentlessly attack forms of proletarian solidarity. The consequences are clear: when there is no depth to power, as in Hardt and Negri’s analysis, then we can all be made to feel equally guilty for poverty, oppression and environmental devastation. We each become responsible for global warming (consuming in a sustainable way), the war on Iraq (joining in global protest), and capitalist crisis (calling for better regulation of the market to stifle our desire for easy credit and quick returns on share investments). Politics becomes a vocal and spectacular demonstration of our opposition to poverty and violence, an aggregate of interpassivity. Downloaded from crs.sagepub.com at Glasgow University Library on October 12, 2014 Cremin and Roberts 195 Hardt and Negri have failed to recognize in their analysis the essential logic that drives capital to seek new ways to appropriate surplus value and therefore their ideas on social change appear unconvincing. Their ideas in this respect share a consistency with those claiming there is no alternative to the market given that there is no empirical singularity of exception to capital in their analysis, nor therefore the potentiality for contingent movements to find expression through a common or universalized cause. This has the effect of displacing critique of the market, regardless of their intentions, by focusing on the individualizing symptoms of economic liberalization through its ideological mediations. In other words, Hardt and Negri are guilty of amplifying a language of immateriality that merely reproduces what in less critical ways free-market ideologues would like to imagine: that there has occurred a decisive break with the political economy that Marx so lucidly deconstructs thereby rendering his analysis obsolete. Thus unintentionally but rather carelessly their arguments fall into the territory the left-liberal occupies. We therefore argue for a return to the Deleuze and Guattari of Anti-Oedipus, the basis for their subsequent writings such as A Thousand Plateaus. They were able to identify in the capitalist axiomatic its tendency towards financialization and the possibility for lines of flight from commodifying capture through temporally assembled desiring machines of generalized subtraction. Badiou’s subtractive (evental) politics is methodologically distinct from Deleuze and Guattari’s, but his ideas sketched out in this article are a useful reminder that difference is a politically denuded category however empirically different we are. For Badiou politics is the subtraction, in Lacanian terms, of the obscene supplement or substance that an order both depends on and disavows. It is a politics articulated through a subjective fidelity to the event, say a revolution, or truth procedure that is at once singular and universal. Given the magnitude of the current crisis of free-market capitalism, it is all the more important that a line is drawn between Marxism, inclusive of post-structuralist insights into subjectivity and desire, and those left-liberal theorists of informational post-industrial capitalism. Hardt and Negri’s analysis was false before the crisis. If their ideas continue to hold sway among theorists of the left, it will prove an obstacle to understanding the nature of crises but also undermine attempts to develop an ideologically and strategically coherent response at a time when such a response is most needed. Our starting point is to return to, repeat, and affirm our commitment to what Žižek (Butler et al., 2000) describes as ‘politics proper’ as the possibility of global emancipation that contrasts with the impossibility of substantive transformation under Hardt and Negri’s logic. Anxiety about the world in which we live from the knowledge made available to us through new means of communication will simply reinforce our interpassivity unless we are prepared to confront the real conditions underlying interpassivity. Only then can we begin to transform our post-political gestures into properly political actions.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.