The permutation is a form of analytic eclecticism – this is the best method for understanding and advancing IR
Jeremie Cornut, 2015, “An analytic electicism in practice: a method for combining international relations theories,” International Studies Perspectives, 16, 50-66, https://academic.oup.com/isp/article/16/1/50/1817996?login=true, mm
So far, the focus has been put on the epistemological and methodological challenges faced by post-foundational scholarship, rather than on the relations between substantive research traditions (Jackson 2011:238). It remains difficult to precisely know what post-foundationalism implies in terms of research practices. The time is ripe then to reflect on the links between different theories in a post-foundational perspective. As I show below, this means that the potential contributions of different theories and the criteria for their selection must be clarified. Given the pluralist inclinations of this perspective, these questions are particularly difficult to answer (Hellmann 2003; Smith 2003; Kurki 2008:208). Analytic eclecticism partially provides some indications on how to practice a post-foundational science of IR. Advocated for by Rudra Sil and Peter Katzenstein over the past decade, it is the most established and respected kind of problem-driven pragmatism (Sil 2000a,b, 2004, 2009; Sil and Katzenstein 2010a,b, 2011). Basically, an eclectic study uses different theories to analyze substantive problems. They explain: What we refer to as analytic eclecticism is distinguished by the fact that features of analyses in theories initially embedded in separate research traditions can be separated from their respective foundations, translated meaningfully, and recombined as part of an original permutation of concepts, methods, analytics, and empirics (Katzenstein and Sil 2008:110–111). In applying this logic to IR, Sil and Katzenstein consider realist, liberal, and constructivist approaches as potentially complementary in understanding specific phenomena. The utility of this research program derives from its giving a place to researchers using a plurality of theories. It shows that problem-driven pragmatism is interesting, coherent, and most importantly, possible. This legitimizes research that transgresses and transcends paradigmatic lines, allowing for eclectic analyses using theoretical frameworks from different parts of the epistemological spectrum.4 The extensive analysis of substantive works provided shows that analytic eclecticism and problem-driven pragmatism have already made great achievements, particularly in the study of war and peace, order and governance, and global political economy (Sil and Katzenstein 2010b). In Jeffrey Checkel’s words, “bridge builders have largely done their job well” (2012:220).