The permutation has a net benefit – it avoids paradigms wars and fueling epistemic uncertainty
Christopher Whyte, June 2019, “Can we change the topic, please? Assessing the theoretical construction of international relations scholarship,” International Studies Quarterly, 63(2), 432-447, https://academic.oup.com/isq/article/63/2/432/5381953?login=true, mm
Many international relations scholars view their fundamental task as producing better and more accurate knowledge about the world around us. But individuals and groups of researchers in the field often self-organize along factional lines, which may produce practices that harm the accumulation of knowledge. Scholars routinely argue that the interparadigm debate undermined the theoretical development of new research programs. They contend that self-described “realist,” “critical,” or other typeset scholars ultimately focus more on conceptual self-affirmation than on producing nuanced understandings of aspects of world politics (see, inter alia, Cohen 2007, 2008; Blyth 2009; Maliniak and Tierney 2009; Lake 2011). However, academic “sects” that form in response to strong support for a particular perspective on world politics do not necessarily harm the pursuit of knowledge. Different perspectives may, for example, bring greater understandings of the role of particular causal mechanisms. Contestation means forums within which scholarly consensus might be achieved and from which new efforts can be shaped. Moreover, different perspectives provide institutional and philosophical ways to organize and take stock of knowledge. That said, Sil and Katzenstein (2010) argue that the intellectual benefits of factionalism come at a high price if not obtained within an environment supportive of methodological “eclecticism.” Paradigms become the object of socialization in that they are taken as given or, conversely, judged as inappropriate for inclusion in studies in certain subfields. Likewise, scholars socialized in a particular context may view certain methods as inappropriate for use in social science research on specific topics or held up as the gold standard, despite clear shortcomings or demonstrable benefits. The economic turn in the international political economy (IPE) field, for example, has diminished the prominence of qualitative analysis within top journal outlets (Lake 2006; Maliniak and Tierney 2009). This bias leads researchers to develop self-affirming research designs and to link the viability of particular methods to their personal or professional reputation (Lake 2011). When researchers exhibit these biases, they cloud the production of knowledge about world politics. Naturally, these tendencies and subsequent effects introduce some uncertainty to the field's effort to produce better knowledge about world politics.