Security studies lack an empirical foundation – reject this flawed methodology in favor of pluralism
Stephanie Baele and Diana Jalea, 2022, Political Studies Review, “twenty-five years of securitization theory: a corpus-based review,” https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/full/10.1177/14789299211069499, mm
Our first axis of investigation follows the line of argument claiming that a rich and fastpaced theoretical evolution of ST [securitization theory] may have been done at the expense of a similarly strong development when it comes to methods. On the one hand, theoretical developments in ST [securitization theory] have certainly been rapid and diverse. The ‘new framework for analysis’ offered by the Copenhagen School in the mid-1990s has been persistently and significantly reinforced, expanded and broadened away from its focus on securitizing speech acts to encompass a range of different processes and factors surrounding or directly at play in securitization dynamics (Baele and Thomson, 2022); this broadening shed light on important social and political issues, enabling a fuller capture of a phenomenon as multifaceted as securitization. However, it also effectively fragmented ST [securitization theory] into different theories of securitization12 ‘committed to distinctive ontologies and epistemologies’ as well as methodologies (Balzacq, 2015: 103), a situation that prompted efforts to reconcile differing views into unified frameworks (e.g. Bourbeau, 2014). On the other hand, comparably little attention has been devoted to methods and best methodological practices when it comes to empirical work. ST’s [securitization theory’s] methods have several times been criticized as limited, if not outright weak. Calls have been voiced to move beyond theoretical debates and conduct methodologically rich empirical work (e.g. Balzacq, 2011), and the lack of methodological transparency in applied research has been pinpointed (e.g. Baele and Sterck [2015: 1122] argued that methods are ‘the Achilles’ heel of securitisation studies, casting doubt on their conclusions’). In their recent evaluation of ST [securitization theory], Balzacq et al. (2016: 519) still wondered if ‘there [is] a “better” method for studying securitization processes?’ Overall, this imbalanced development is confirmed by the data in several ways. First, ST [securitization theory] scholarship is indeed heavily geared towards theoretical development rather than empirical knowledge: more than half of the 171 papers (89) were ‘primarily theoretical’, compared with only 10 ‘primarily empirical’ articles – the remaining being ‘balanced theoretically and empirically’. As Figure 2 shows, only a minority of papers do ‘focus on a key issue’, that is, have a clearly identifiable and sustained engagement with one (or two) empirical case.13 Put differently, the majority of ST [securitization theory] scholarship remains abstract, with only thin empirical engagement. As noted above, this imbalance in favour of abstract theorizing as opposed to case(s)-based investigations can partially be explained by the nature of the journals we included in the sample; a quick glance at some area studies publications brings back articles using ST [securitization theory] in a more instrumental way to explain particular issues or events. Generalist journals, however, do not necessarily neglect empirical work when favouring theorization – they usually require both. We thus believe that what has more fundamentally driven this imbalance is the value traditionally given to ‘high’ theory, and suspicion towards ‘methods’ at times conflated with positivism, within the critical IR community.14 Theorization is not, of course, inherently problematic; what raises questions is a theoretical framework which is usually not used as such – as a tool used to better understand specific issues and solve empirical puzzles that incidentally allow for further conceptual work.