Free beta access. 5 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

The perm won’t reinforce dominant paradigms – eclecticism opens up space for marginalized views

Rudra Sil, 2020, International Journal: Canada’s Journal of Global Policy Analysis, “Analytic eclecticism - continuing the conversation,” 75(3):, mm

One thread running through all of the essays concerns the extent to which the framing of analytic eclecticism in Beyond Paradigms ends up referencing the three dominant paradigms in IR—the “triad” of realism, liberalism, and constructivism. Chernoff wonders whether we adopt too much of a Kuhnian view of paradigms in our treatment of empirical research in IR. Blanchard builds on a number of previously published critiques to argue that the benefit of eclecticism may be undercut by the emphasis on this “triad” at the expense of attention to other, less wellrepresented “isms” in the field. Similarly, Peet is troubled by the “exclusivity” implied in showcasing combinatorial frameworks that draw from some—but not other—research traditions. All three of these scholars in different ways wonder if the specification of analytic eclecticism in relation to the three dominant paradigms effectively diminishes the space for legitimate criticism. While the concerns raised by Chernoff, Blanchard, and Peet are reasonable and deserve to be taken seriously, they are hardly “damaging to the essence of the project,” as Chernoff, Cornut, and James suggest in their introduction, once the fundamental logic of analytic eclecticism is distinguished from the tactical choices about how to efficiently represent that logic in a book targeting the IR field. The more complex and generalized form of our argument appeared in our 2010 article in Perspectives on Politics, where the main case for analytic eclecticism neither depends on fully formed paradigms, nor is limited to the field of International Relations.2 Here, the problem is framed in terms of the limitations on analyses imposed by any framework founded on a fixed ontology and a fixed set of epistemological priors related to how best to analyze the complexity of social life. Such commitments, whether or not they evolve into defining features of two or three or however many paradigms, presumably enable researchers to train their sights on particular domains of social reality, particular levels of analysis, and particular kinds of mechanisms or variables—but with the risk that complex interactions and processes are overlooked.3 Thus, our underlying objective was always to create more space for scholars who may reverse this trade-off by eschewing the confining boundaries of any research tradition and more freely exploring connections between different kinds of social phenomena. In highlighting the intellectual payoffs of eclecticism, the exemplary works we referenced were drawn not only from IR, but also such fields as political economy, institutional theory, and social movement theory.4 More generally, we were inspired by—and drew liberally from—similar or complementary positions staked out in different fields by such diverse scholars as Albert Hirschman, Scott Page, and Philip Tetlock.5 In short, the core logic of analytic eclecticism was never meant to be tethered to any one discipline, let alone any specific set of paradigms. So, why, then, did we put so much stock in the “triad” in the book? First, the book was intended to be useful in advanced IR seminars still being organized around paradigms and interparadigm debates featuring (neo)realism, (neo)liberalism, and constructivism. Having laid out the more complex and generalized version of the argument in the article, in Beyond Paradigms we opted to foreground this familiar “triad” of dominant research traditions as an efficient and streamlined way to convey the logic and payoffs of eclecticism. In retrospect, perhaps we should have anticipated—and guarded against—the risk that this move might be (mis)interpreted as marginalizing alternative “isms.” Yet, our intention was precisely the opposite: to diminish the influence of the three big “isms” that we saw as disproportionately shaping research, teaching, hiring, and promotion in IR—as reflected in the 2009 version of the TRIP surveys.6 By de-centering the theoretical priors of the dominant paradigms, we hoped to create more space for not only eclectic scholarship but any research that was not “protected” (in Lakatosian terms) by one of these paradigms. This is why we specifically noted in the book that analytic eclecticism need not be limited to combinatorial approaches drawing from the “triad”: [A]nalytic eclecticism is conceptualized in this book in relation to realism, liberalism, and constructivism ... . In other countries, however, a number of other paradigms enjoy equal or greater visibility in international relations debates... [T]he English school, feminism, post-modernism, and Marxism all have a much broader following in Britain, Canada, and Australia than in the United States. On the European continent, hermeneutic and interpretive approaches are much more a part of the ‘mainstream’ than in the United States...In such settings, although the general logic of eclecticism still applies, what constitutes eclectic research practice would have to be redefined.7 If we were to rewrite the book now, we might adopt a different strategy for capturing the logic and role of analytic eclecticism. The most recent TRIP surveys suggest that fewer scholars design their research to conform to a single IR paradigm than was the case a decade ago. And as Chernoff notes, even those who work within a given research tradition, do so less because of rigid adherence to foundational principles than because their empirical questions focus attention on the kinds of variables analyzed in that tradition. At the same time, whether or not a scholar conforms to an established paradigm, the process of formulating a research problem and designing a study can still involve (often unstated) metatheoretical commitments that tend to a priori place disproportionate significance on certain kinds of variables or mechanisms. Perhaps this broader point became somewhat blurred when we opted to foreground the triad as much as we did in the book, even if we did this for illustrative purposes. What we hoped would stand the test of time is not our case for eclecticism vis-a`-vis any specific set of IR paradigms, but our broader rationale for a more open-ended and inclusive field that does not a priori stipulate what questions are most significant, what approaches are most valuable, and what factors need to be prioritized in our analyses. Such a stance is hardly inconsistent with the postures struck by Peet and Blanchard, despite their discomfort with the attention we pay to the “triad.” Looking ahead, we would gladly integrate elements drawn from less mainstream approaches. As Blanchard notes, such an approach would indeed extend the promise of a “theoretical multilingualism” we had set out to promote. In this context, we would not only be amenable to but welcome a more expansive articulation of analytic eclecticism, including one incorporating an intersectional perspective, as Peet forcefully proposes. Importantly, we do not see such a move as necessitating a fundamental reconceptualization of the core logic of analytic eclecticism. It may, however, require a more self-conscious effort to resist the temptation to either dismiss the findings in paradigm-bound research or throw everything but the kitchen sink at every imaginable puzzle.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.