Free beta access. 5 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Focusing on policy relevance does not trade off with critical analysis

Rudra Sil, 2020, International Journal: Canada’s Journal of Global Policy Analysis, “Analytic eclecticism - continuing the conversation,” 75(3):, mm

In gesturing toward pragmatism’s emphasis on the consequences of knowledge claims for action, we were also highlighting the potential role of analytic eclecticism in bringing scholarly research closer to the messiness of the real world as encountered by policy-makers and other actors. We felt that if scholars were less invested in recurrent interparadigm debates and less likely to speak past one another as a result of their uncritical acceptance of certain theoretical priors, then they might be more open to puzzles that bore some resemblance to the messy choice situations and practical dilemmas confronting real-world actors. Importantly, we did not think of these actors as limited to national or international policy-makers, but also ordinary individuals and communities contending with everyday choice situations in the midst of the multitude of forces that constituted their respective “lifeworlds.” In retrospect, I wonder whether this important nuance was not articulated clearly or fully in our limited discussion of “policy relevance.” In revisiting this issue, I would wish to be more explicit about the link between analytic eclecticism and three distinct notions of “real-world” relevance: research that is policy serving in the sense that it offers prescriptions for governmental decision-makers pursuing set agendas; research that seeks to intervene in policy debates and re-examine assumptions underlying a given policy position; and research that bears on the everyday encounters and choices of ordinary actors as experienced in their respective environments. My preference would be for eclectic scholars to liberally pursue the latter two forms of policy relevance while being more cautious with respect to the first. Expanding the scope for dialogue between academics and policy-makers is potentially a good thing, as is the need to create more space for puzzles and arguments that reflect more of the messy and complex challenges faced by actors in the real world. But, in the process, scholars need not uncritically accept given policy elites’—or any actors’—agendas and assumptions; nor should they hesitate to leverage the distinctive skill sets and intellectual commitments that feed into their choice of profession and areas of expertise. With further elaboration of the above qualifications, I believe it is possible to narrow the gap that Blanchard perceives between the deployment of analytic eclecticism to address real-world problems and policy debates and the position of those who, like Anne Norton (cf. Blanchard), are fearful of scholarly endeavours developed in the service of agendas being pursued by those in power. But, does ethics have a place in all this? It certainly should, according to Blanchard’s discussion of the role of critical scholars (whom he sees us as having undervalued) and Peet’s discussion of the centrality of “moral responsibility” in the work of Jane Addams and feminist pragmatists. Others, too, have questioned whether analytic eclecticism is sufficiently attentive to normative forms of reasoning that are part of international life.20 Looking back, I see that the term “ethics” appears nowhere in either Beyond Paradigms or our article in Perspectives on Politics. The term “normative” fares slightly better, making a fleeting appearance in the introductory and concluding chapters. In the conclusion, for example, we note that analytic eclecticism is, in part, designed “to grapple with problems that are not only theoretically interesting but also have normative and practical significance for decision-makers and the wider public.”21

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.