Free beta access. 5 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Prefer pluralism – incorporating multiple theories of IR is complementary rather than conflictual

David Lake, June 2011, “Why ‘isms’ are evil: theory, epistemology, and academic sects as impediments to understanding and progress,” International Studies Quarterly, 55(2), 465-480, https://www.jstor.org/stable/23019696?seq=1, mm

Our duty as scholars is to enhance understanding of the world and, if possible, to identify levers that when manipulated can facilitate progress toward more humane and normatively desirable ends. Society privileges us as academics with a relatively prosperous and certainly desirable lifestyle so that we can add to the stock of human knowledge and, hopefully, provide some insight into how to improve social life. Most important, society—or at least, Western society entrusts us with the power to organize our professional lives and our academic inquiries in any way that we, as scholars, think appropriate. We are a genuinely self-regulating profession both in what constitutes knowledge and in how we define and create incentives for professional success. In this essay, I probe some tensions between our professional practices in the field of international studies and the quality of our professional output. We are not giving society what it deserves, not only in terms of policy-relevant research where the "the gap" is of long-standing (George 1993). We are not giving society what it deserves even in terms of basic theoretical and empirical knowledge about world politics, a domain that we as scholars claim as our own. My critique of our profession is a common one, but one worth repeating. Most generally, we organize ourselves into academic "sects" that engage in self-affirm-ing research and then wage theological debates between academic religions. This occurs at both the level of theory and epistemology. In turn, we reward those who stake out extreme positions within each sect. Unfortunately, this academic sectarianism, a product of our own internal political struggles, produces less understanding rather than more. Some reasonably fear intellectual "monocul-tures," as McNamara (2009) has called the possible hegemony of rationalism. But the current cacophony is not a sign of productive intellectual ferment in the pursuit of meaningful knowledge.2 Rather, we have produced a clash of compet-ing theologies each claiming its own explanatory "miracles" and asserting its universal truth and virtue. Instead, a large measure of intellectual humility is in order. Theoretically, we are far from the holy grail of a universal theory of international politics—if indeed such a grail even exists. We should focus instead on developing contin-gent, mid-level theories of specific phenomena. This analytical eclecticism is likely to be more productive (Sil and Katzenstein 2010). But we also need a lexi-con for translating otherwise incommensurable theories and making them mutu-ally intelligible. In the following section, I outline the problems with theoretical sects and affirm the case for analytic eclecticism. I then end with one possible "Rosetta stone" that aims to facilitate conversation across research traditions by suggesting that all theories of international studies can be disaggregated into the basic and common concepts of interests, interactions, and institutions. Epistemologically, there is perhaps an even deeper divide that is, unfortu-nately, not so easily bridged. The nomothetic vs narrative divide cuts through all of the social sciences and possibly beyond. This divide endures because scholars—either innately or through socialization—find one form of explanation more intellectually satisfying than the other. Yet, in international studies, we have reified this divide and, as with our theories, have formed mutually exclusive churches. Rather than claiming one or the other epistemology is always and everywhere superior, we should recognize that both are valid and perhaps even complementary paths to understanding. The question is not which approach is inherently superior, but which yields greater insights under what circumstances. The second major section below takes up epistemology and its consequences for professional practice and knowledge.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.