Ontological and epistemological differences to not preclude the permutation – the alternative can still be combined with the plan without coopting their scholarship
P. Katzenstein and Rudra Sil, 2008, Oxford Handbook of International Relations, “Eclectic Theorizing in the Study and Practice of International Relations,” https://www.researchgate.net/publication/287914880_Eclectic_Theorizing_in_the_Study_and_Practice_of_International_Relations, mm
It is true that moving between research traditions founded on competing ontological and epistemological principles runs some risk of introducing conceptual fuzziness (Johnson 2002). However, as Ted Hopf (forthcoming) notes, the analytic foundations of a given tradition may not be as far apart as is often assumed, and these foundations can be adjusted or bracketed so as to enable the translation, comparison, and integration of substantive theories and narratives developed in different research traditions. So long as there is clarity with regard to concepts and definitions, differences in metatheoretical postulates do not inherently preclude recognition of complementarities and linkages in substantive processes in international life, even if these are normally represented in distinct theoretical vocabularies and cast at different levels of analysis (Sil 2000a; 2004; Katzenstein and Sil 2004; Parsons 2007). Eclectic approaches cannot ignore or substitute for the intellectual products generated within separate traditions. However, by expanding the repertoire of assumptions, analytic tools, theoretical concepts, methodological devices, and empirical data, analytic eclecticism allows for the development of complex explanations that reveal how different kinds of causal mechanisms and processes might relate to each other.