Free beta access. 5 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Society characterizes all trans-people as dishonest through hypervisibility AND violence inflicted by states themselves isn’t recognized. The only way progress can be made is to trans-theorize about the intricacies of visibility and invisibility.

Laura Sjoberg ‘12, [University of Florida, “Toward Trans-gendering International Relations?” International Political Sociology https://watermark.silverchair.com/6-4 337.pdf?token=AQECAHi208BE49Ooan9kkhW_Ercy7Dm3ZL_9Cf3qfKAc485ysgAAAs8wggLLBgkqhkiG9w0BBwagggK8MIICuAIBADCCArEGCSqGSIb3DQEHATAeBglghkgBZQMEAS4wEQQM7GuiIZj85gLwlHCCAgEQgIICgnGPsIsldioaX8vD1V1lPJne7FPWWTeaURxHrjwnyORsiVugPRjbH8xmDXOCAJXqjU6jmPIQASlmoTSm0F8nafeTF2hdX2_3jRzgAx5b5TBQ682z410FIUrwFVQgb4ZYPada74dITOFP8dsKp3z3xqACNJQXi3XZbrxtYQLDT2fFgzHCCYlHQMZ_BmGuovUZXI2wacyhmHa0_f8sqjfEKO8nQO8iF2X3MsNBuDc0BCR7oR0f5iCPtiHdcBRq0JS_OwNGoCdDdqGizqhFEcRg2J6ItEZgXGCoRp-N8X04ou73B7W7GvUEg1SAxEK2NIAb2EaK2z7OB6sYc90dnyn-aaIMvUvEZQ_7JfhzgxKpAekI6jSwyV9ZybvFX8CyBQo3a8MU0m43cW6_srumaSkkNW3sGg6p8xY9mA3CzlN2U2vLf4xhfyv2Scnm8JYeT3B9fZNI2Uno3WnasIQN51jer0F56iBAaIdj09RapRCJIAg4sWKrCzDkvRjvzeIjJuNKWA0sxVg5eu6tpflxwiHgYbyG53uq2KqNFA1_3lGFaufM0lRLY8KjkXRFeKnMu97RTq5pjE3vPBD0Ooyfxs2zlU7ZhIyxYtCTsLepNrW3ryB9OqCMW2CkC7dRkKhr7jsjiKw1sRyvbPel4BxWwozLYvp0zf678LCTsI6gbLQab2MLrMjYRnILVhz6JLKEd1FjPJjqJnRZtfddK6hx2xUsqcnE6pPhymTSVxtiG9dk4RjpYq6GNgRZ2g2z7Q0mTUND7Bx9AXalsqNXPx89o2cnSwCQKxQzwz2ulA8C87xe6m-bd-WOYnR4jttrptS-xzFU4OPGXaA7FeemBQSdg//bxscijaclyn]

There are those who argue that “in-ness” and “outness” do not make sense for trans-people, since “trans-” is not something one is (and therefore not something one must out oneself as). Instead, “trans-” is the process of becoming what one is. Trans-theorizing has problematized the association between outness and visibility, arguing that the trans- and genderqueer bodies demonstrate the problems with assuming a clear “self” to be “out.” If being trans- is a process rather than a result, then it makes little sense to be “out” as trans-. Yet, trans-persons who do not immediately self-identify as trans- (which may or may not actually resonate with them) may be considered dishonest when their “passing” is discovered. The trans- theory problem with seeing people as “really a man” or “really a woman” (and therefore “out” as a “man” or “woman”) is that these discourses “reinscribe the position that genitalia are the essential determinants of sex” (Bettcher 2007:50). This runs directly contrary to the lived experiences of many trans-people, who see their genitalia as either not representative of or only partly representative of their “actual” sex (Bettcher 2007:50). Trans-theorists express concern that the contin- ued emphasis on the difference between how trans-people look and what they “are” is “fundamental to transphobic representations” (Bettcher 2007:50).

Trans-people are often characterized as dishonest if they are not “out” as “trans” because they are seen as presenting as a sex they are “really not,” whereas trans-people who are not “out” are seen as lying for not admitting the unreality of the sex they present as. Trans-people’s options, then, comprise being dishon- est one way or another, “disclose ‘who one is’ and come out as a pretender or masquerader, or refuse to disclose (be a deceiver) and run the risk of forced disclosure, the effect of which is exposure as a liar” (Bettcher 2007:50). Visibility, then, is pretending, while invisibility is lying.

This creates a politics of hypervisibility of trans-identities. In these terms, “visi- bility yields a position in which what one is doing is represented as make-believe, pretending, or playing dress up,” while “to opt for invisibility is to remove one’s life from the domain of masquerade into actual reality... [which] generates the effect of revelation, exposure, or hidden truth” (Bettcher 2007:50). Each begets violence, but the violence is often unrecognized as such.8 Judith Butler sees it as important to think about:

Why violence against transgender subjects is not recognized as violence, and why this violence is not recognized as violence, and why this violence is sometimes inflicted by the very states that should be offering such subjects protection from violence. (Butler 2004:207)

Trans-theorists have explained this in terms of the violent enforcement of a settled gender, where transphobic violence is actually punishment for non- conformity with settled ideas of maleness and femaleness, phrased and understood in terms of dishonesty in order to hide that it is not honesty, but reality, being policed through hypervisibility (Lamble 2009).

Trans-theorizing about visibility could inspire important research directions for IR. For example, it might be useful to ask what norms we do not see being enforced violently, what realities are policed, and whose identities are labeled less valid or genuine by definition. It might be fruitful to theorize the ways in which public gazes silence or distort certain voices, and to look at the ways that attention traps certain people as public/publicized representational forces. How does being trapped in the public gaze affect certain people at the margins of global politics? How does that relate to being trapped outside of the public gaze? Do some people and/or groups experience both simultaneously?

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.