Free beta access. 5 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Queer IR and queering solves a lack of AI ethics

Ann Light 11. School of Engineering and Informatics Doctor of Philosophy. “(PDF) HCI as heterodoxy: Technologies of identity and the queering of interaction with computers.” ResearchGate. 2011. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/220055189_HCI_as_heterodoxy_Technologies_of_identity_and_the_queering_of_interaction_with_computers //NM

Both examples show deliberately mischievous reclamation of the space provided by FB to present an identity. This playful resistance – neither hostile, nor demure – is the kind of intervention advocated by Butler as most effective at withstanding the tendency for norms to ‘congeal into givens’. So, users subvert tools. And Queer Theory gives us a means of recognising and scrutinising these dynamics. More powerfully for our purposes, it also offers a means of reflection on the discipline and a tool for design. I describe it as ‘analogy/method’ here, because its use in this paper is quite complex. First, it is a tool for analysis: by equating practices with queering, we learn more about the way they operate. Second, it is specifically a means for engaging with meta-values. By meta-values, I refer to a value system predicated on making space for divergent and evolving beliefs, principles, standards and morals. Thus, there is the intention to create resistance to an orthodoxy rather than seeking to assign predefined characteristics to a design outcome (in as far as it is ever possible to associate values with systems rather than the use of them). Queering, as it is used here, is predicated on letting (other) values and lifestyles surface – not the ones already in use, but ones that might come to be if allowed enough space to emerge. In this respect it differs from most critical practices: it is not concerned to ‘out’ the values of the designer or the socio-technical system, introduce new values, consider contextual socio-historical factors or reflect on ethical considerations. Agre (1997) suggests that a ‘critical technical practice will, at least for the foreseeable future, require a split identity – one foot planted in the craft work of design and the other foot planted in the reflexive work of critique’. But queering goes one stage further to a practical naughtiness based both on craft and reflection. It is a space-making exercise, using the means available at the time. And while critique is clearly one tool; hullabaloo, parody and inversion may also have their place. Its endgame is not an analysis to inform design, but an ongoing application of disruption as a space-making ploy and, thus, as a hands-on method. In a truly queered context there is no final arrival point, but an absence of dogma and a mutability that allows new truths, perspectives and engagements to emerge through a refusal to accept definition.4 If we use it as an analogy, it works to play up intersections and resist over-definition and so allows us to explore pluralist experience and remain off-centre, eccentric, critical, reflexive and self-analytic. It creates a space for change in the discipline of HCI. It offers the in-between-ness of Bassoli et al. (2007) by refusing to be wholly design or evaluation, technology or application, critique or experience. It presents an unstable zone for disciplines to meet and morph in post-disciplinary ways. To be queered out of alignment in this way is not to stand in opposition to parts of HCI or any other field, but to remain un-centred and open to new influences – such as Queer Theory itself – using the dynamics of these and other intersections. This stance allows a more fluid response to changes in the field of technology, to the methodological commitments of others and to the possible domains to be touched by developments in computing. As indicated, it can have a recursive quality. I am going to deal more thoroughly with queering as a design method because this is the more radical contribution to practice. Butler herself conceives of trouble as an action (1990). She points to theatrical practices such as parody and drag as mechanisms for troubling or throwing light on the workings of gender. I use the idea similarly, but to explore the workings of digital technology. Troubling/queering already takes place in the arena of technology design. There are critical art practices which reflect on society and technology through creating problem artefacts. They might ironicise practices: see, for instance, the instant democracy tool, repetitionr: ‘Looking for a petition service? Try a re-petition instead. Learn how to comfortably change the world from your armchair. Do-It-Yourself Democracy. A million people can’t be wrong. Improve your campaigns, get over one million votes with one click!’ (www.repetitionr.com), which mocks both social activism and parliamentary procedure without referring directly to either. There are designers whose products exist to question and raise questions, such as Dunne and Raby’s Designs for Fragile Personalities in Anxious Times: (www.dunneandraby.co.uk/content/projects/71/0), or Gaver’s studio and work on ambiguity (e.g. Gaver et al., 2003). In the same way as Butler points to the process of artifice, including her own self-stylization and role as trouble-maker, these creators make subversive entities to critique the norms of living and designing. But the trouble can be far more intrinsic. We can introduce the troubling as a process of design, not just of observation and use.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.