Free beta access. 5 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Queering biotech solves a lack of cohesion on biotech

Elizabeth Reed 22. university Of Southampton, Uk Kate O’Riordan university Of Sussex, Uk correspondant . “Queering genealogies: introduction to the special section.” SAGE Journals. 3-27-2022. https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/full/10.1177/14647001211059523 //NM

Tangential to this nexus of queer theory and life story, but emerging in the same period, enter Assisted Reproductive Technologies (ART). This other kind of media is at once intensely heteronormative, and radically queer. ARTs both destabilise heterosexual reproduction and re-enforce it through access to fertility, gestation and biological genealogy. Surrogacy, gamete and sperm donation and IVF have become dominant modes in ART and have been made accessible to different populations, in very uneven but also potentially transformative ways (Farquar, 1997; Mamo, 2007). At the same time that trajectories in queer culture and other accounts destabilised biological kinship as the primary site of family, and affirmed and legitimated families of choice and made kinship, ARTs also made an industry of restoring biology as the material of kinship (Smietana et al., 2018). Although stories of biology as kinship are powerful and often represented as universal, they are also partial and linked to particular centres. Stories of inheritance and descent are bound up in European narratives of evolution, class and the circulation and inheritance of wealth. In the UK context, for example, working-class histories, histories of colonisation and slavery (McClintock 1995) and contemporary kinship stories from Black and Asian diasporas (Puar, 2007; Gunaratnam, 2014) challenge heteronormative assumptions that put biology at the centre (Lewis, 2019, 2020). In the context of scholarship in the USA, Black and indigenous feminism (Gumbs et al., 2016; Tallbear, 2018) and family abolitionism (O’Brien, 2019) also challenge heteronormative genetic kinship narratives. The scope of this special section remains fairly narrow in its White European/American focus. In this sense, it fails to inclusively open up the field and reproduces this lens. Scholarship that examines Black feminisms and queer intersectional feminisms of colour across this terrain includes that of Kim Tallbear, Allondra Nelson, Alexis Pauline Gumbs, Gail Lewis, Julia Oparah and Alicia Bonaparte. Tallbear's (2013) work on Native American belonging and genetic testing is generative in opening up critique of genetic science. The interplay of race and genetic testing is further examined by Nelson (2016) in their work on race and the genome. Examining political kinship and relation, Gail Lewis develops an object theory of Black feminism as ‘a project of ethical relation’ (2020: 8). Connecting across this issue's themes of mothering, Oparah and Bonoparte (2016) have curated a powerful collection, centring Black women, addressing maternal health care and developing a birth justice approach. Whilst attention has been paid to families, kinship of choice and new family-making, less work gives attention to the ways in which biotechnology has queered kinship relations and stabilises, disrupts or creates relationality. Notable exceptions include Queering Reproduction (Mamo, 2007), Mediated Intimacies (Andreassen et al., 2007), Making Parents (Thompson, 2007) and Bits of Life: Feminism at the Intersections of Media, Bioscience, and Technology (Smelik and Lykke, 2015). This special section attempts to redraw this focus to bring these areas together, sometimes in the same article, and to create a space of intellectual kinship for these different orientations to attend to each other. Through this section, we have aimed to craft an intervention that brings together biological and digital media forms; one that recognises, traces and amplifies the interconnection of medium specificity and biomediation. Borrowing from Dahl and Gabb (2020), we have aimed to craft this in a way that attempts to be mindful of context and is attuned to their analysis: “to not ignore the foundational questions of gender, sexuality, race, and nation that inform kinship. To […] think further about what queer intellectual kinship means, who we care for and who we consider ourselves related to […] and to how our geopolitical, sexual, gendered and generational differences and ties shape and make our affinities and solidarities” (Dahl and Gabb, 2020). Special section articles The section brings together articles which queer genealogical research and/or examine queer genealogies. Queering in this context can refer to any engagement with queer theory, and or engagement with LGBTQ+ genealogies and their intersections. We speculated that genealogy in this context might refer to ancestry, kinship, relation, reproduction, history, origin and naturalisation. The special section seeks to queer the existing field through both an attention to queering genealogical analysis and examining queer kinship across life story, media and biotechnology.

In, ‘From the Families We Choose to the Families We Find Online’, Rikke Andreassen centres her analysis on connections made between donor siblings, facilitated through the sociality of digital media. This article draws on both the medium of semen, and social media to examine the way in which kinship is re-made through ‘finding’ donor sperm relations. In the context of a boom in queer and single families, made possible through access to sperm banks, Andreassen examines how new networks of donor siblings have emerged. These connect a relatively small number of donors to an extended network of potentially hundreds of recipients of donor treatments. This extends to a significant network of donor siblings and a generative context for new routes to kinship for the children of single and queer parents. Andreassen notes that single parents are more likely than queer parents to engage in extended donor sibling networks and argues that this offers another way of thinking about queering kinship. The article brings together donor treatments and social media to examine the convergence of these technologies as reproductive. In ‘Queering the Origin Story: Adults Raised by LBTQ Parents Narrate Kinship and Connection’, Eliza Garwood explores the experiences of adults raised by LBTQ parents. The origin stories that emerge combine genetic origin and queer kinship in the construction of narrative identity. These stories function as a resource to build connection and create family bonds, as well as to a broader sense of queer identity and politics. Garwood argues that although biogenetic ties remain central to understanding kinship, these origin stories are as social as they are biogenetic. Garwood looks at the way that ‘many adults raised in LBTQ households were interested in tracing their queer family histories, rather than solely their biological relations’. These queer family histories invoked a much broader sense of family history and identity than the immediate family. They drew on queer histories; coming out; community and activism; and media-making practices including film, documentary and memoir. These stories bring together genetic and social stories, and connect political, social and personal histories. Elizabeth Reed and Tanya Kant bring together digital and biological media in their article ‘One Donor Egg and “a Dollop of Love”: ART and de-queering Genealogies in Facebook Advertising’. They examine the targeted advertising of egg banking and egg donation through social media. Drawing on Kant's work on algorithmic targeting and Reed's work on the role of media in identity-making, they explore the construction of essentialised heterosexual femininity in the promotional culture of commercial ARTs. Their analysis demonstrates the ways in which egg donation is conjured as a relation between women, of gifts and reproductive hope. This imaginary is constructed in the service of the imperatives of biomedicalisation (Clarke, 2014) in an industry facing an undersupply of eggs. Sophie Lewis gives an account of mothers and mothering, in ‘Diary of a Family-Abolitionist's Year on Tour’, threaded together with an incredible reach of connective queer intellectual kinship-making and skill. Lewis combines political, social and personal histories through stories about her own mother, family abolitionism, xenofeminism and Black feminism, the latter particularly through the work of Alexis Pauline Gumbs (Gumbs, 2010; Gumbs et al., 2016). Lewis's manifesto Full Surrogacy Now also underpins this account, and the death of Lewis's mother in the period of writing the article frames the narrative. Lewis's account is of dystopia, reparation and kinship – or kith connection – figuring comrades, momrades, doulas and alien connection: ‘Kinship is always made, not given. By the same token, more often than we think, where kinship is assumed as a given, it fails to be made’. This premise, that kinship is always made, whether through biological relation, blood ties, adoption, political affinity or stranger-relations, furthers the conceptual reach of queering genealogy. Conclusion: genealogy and reparation Calls to radical relationality, and the recognition of new kinship patterns are emerging in the context of digital life, ecological crisis and intensifying social injustice. Techno-social structures have both transformed kinship relations and exacerbated their most reactionary formations, at the level of species, nation, kin and person. In this context, a critical re-examination of what it means to be related to life, to kin and to the world is central to understanding individual and collective identity. Bringing together this section in the context of the pandemic has necessarily pushed us all into very different timelines, even given the infamous length of time anticipated in academic publishing. This feels like a project spread over decades – in many ways it has been – and this introduction aims to give a sense of that longer timeline to enable a platform that in turn contextualises the excellent writing and thinking in the articles published here. Media-making, including the promotional cultures of biotechnology, the novels that structure Love and Cvetkovich's analysis and the media genres central to Reed's research, is a productive kinship practice (Pidduck, 2009, 2018). In tune with this thinking about media-making as kinship, and the importance of novels as connective objects, we alight on one further novel here as both appropriation and coda: Girl, Woman, Other (Evaristo, 2020). We started this project by looking for stories about intergenerational relation; stories are a technology of kinship, and ART and other biotechnologies are technologies of story: biomedia across text and test tube. These stories of the different voices across this novel speak to the challenge of reparative world-making in dystopian times, of generation and the making of hopeful genealogies of kith-ship, time, queerness and technology. Evaristo generously offers these stories to her readers, and Girl, Woman, Other came into print as the final comments were coming in for the peer review of these articles. Reading these together enabled an added passage through Evaristo's novel, which is about intergenerational kinship, telling the stories of twelve characters. It is (mostly) about Black women in the UK. It gives voice to feminism, families and friendship and draws together the past in the present, connecting and disconnecting mothers, sisters, lovers and children. It connects 1980s activism in the UK with women's land projects in the USA, and navigates gender identity, biology, queerness, feminism, class, nationality, ethnicity and racism. Towards the end of the novel, it also draws on genetic testing as a technology of life story, as a narrative device and as an agent in the story, making genealogy intelligible and opening up futures of kinship-making. For us, reading Evaristo together through the production of this special issue, writing this introduction and bringing together these excellent articles across the theme of queering genealogy has been part of a project of queer intellectual and political kinship.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.