Free beta access. 5 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

The alt is to celebrate queerness, a stance that disrupts hierarchies of heteronormativity in a way that identity politics can’t.

Cooper-Cunningham, Dean. “Security, Sexuality, and the Gay Clown Putin Meme: Queer Theory and International Responses to Russian Political Homophobia.” Security Dialogue, Apr. 2022, doi:10.1177/09670106211055308. Accessed 7/22/2022 //ONHS IF

Queer international relations has demonstrated how sex(uality) connects to international politics, identifying, for instance, the sexualized logics through which international security works and how security discourses often rest upon gendered–sexualized–racialized constructions about what/who needs protection and what/who is a threat (Cooper-Cunningham, 2020; Leigh and Weber, 2019; Richter-Montpetit, 2014, 2018). Here, I (re)turn to queer theory through the politics of sexual shame and stigma to move beyond the identification of heteronormative power structures underpinning international politics. I bring into international relations a queer politics that is explicitly anti-normative, delights in sexual difference, revels in abjectness and embraces the disruptive force of queerness that flouts rigid and punitive norms around sex, gender and sexual desire. Queer theory acknowledges the deep connection between gender and sexuality. They intertwine in the sense that desire for the opposite sexed/gendered body is assumed natural and ‘normal’, whereas desire for the same breaks with normative sexuality and gender. We can therefore speak of a gendered heterosexual/homosexual dichotomy that is powerful, ordering and hierarchical. Heteronormativity – the structures of understanding that privilege heterosexuality – ensures that ‘if you deviate at any point from this program, you do so at your own cost’ (Warner, 2000: 38). All dichotomies privilege one side of a divide and thereby produce a hierarchical relationship between juxtaposed terms. Opposite-/same-sex sexual desires and behaviours have been constituted in hierarchical opposition as normal/perverse, natural/deviant. Consequently, those practising sexual behaviours that deviate from the heteronormative programme ‘are subjected to a presumption of mental illness, disreputability, criminality, restricted social and physical mobility, loss of institutional support, and economic sanctions’ (Rubin, [1984] 2011: 149). This has led to the persecution and securitization of supposedly deviant sexuality and gender performances. Queer theorists have shown that stigma, shame and moralism about appropriate sexual behaviour and erotic desire are essential in upholding this powerful dichotomy of sexual and gender difference. Michael Warner’s work on the politics of sexual shame is instructive: stigma is ‘a mark on the body’ that constitutes ‘the person, not the deed, as tainted’, whereas shame is linked more to the act (Warner, 2000: 27–28). To deviate from normative sexuality – which names appropriately gendered objects of desire and types of sex – is to engage in shameful acts. When these desires/acts are constituted as identities, as the essence of one’s being, they invite stigmatization. Destroying deeply entrenched and resilient systems of oppression such as patriarchal gender and heteronormativity is not as simple as pointing to their discursive, socially (re)produced, contingent nature. Destabilizing powerful discourses and showing their reliance on obedience, repetition and fear of transgression is only one step. On this, Cathy Cohen (1997) makes an important point: power and hierarchies can be rearranged and transformed but never fully eliminated. A queer politics that invites radical transformation of society and politics is itself eternally oppositional, anti-assimilationist, deliberately antisocial, attendant to every relation to power, and adopts an ethics that ‘cuts against every form of hierarchy’ (Warner, 2000: 36).9 Queer is therefore distinct from an identity-based LGBT civil rights agenda. It is a more radical and transformative politics that short-circuits the ‘hierarchies that allow systems of oppression to persist and operate efficiently’ by not only challenging how people understand sexuality but also creating oppositional space against all forms of domination and marginalization (Cohen, 1997: 437, 440). Queer is intersectional, coalitional, and rejects LGBT identity politics that turns sexual and gender ‘deviance’ (acts) into identities and assimilates lesbians, gays, bisexuals and trans people into heteronormative institutions that perpetuate cisheterosexuality as the norm. Identity-based politics fails to interrogate the politics of sexual shame and stigma that operates to quash deviance; how it is used to punish individuals for failing to conform to cisheteronormative demands, often in the name of the nation’s health (Rubin, [1984] 2011; Warner, 2000). A liberatory queer politics refuses to sanitize or morally legitimize sexual difference and instead takes delight in shame (Bersani, 1996; Warner, 2000). This is not the same as perpetuating discourses of queerness as ‘abnormal’ in insidiously phobic ways since queer does not work through a heteronormative epistemology (Sedgwick, 2008; Warner, 1993). In its refusal of normativity, queer is anti-assimilationist, oppositional, non-proscriptive, and, in rejecting society, takes ‘fierce pride in bucking political, emotional, and sexual norms’ (Gould, 2009: 264). Queer is therefore attentive to all those who endure the penalties of divergence from cisheteronormative culture. Its radical politics lies in its revelry in stigmatic and abject associations; its delight in flouting rigid and punitive norms around sex, gender and sexuality in ways that are constituted as perverse, immoral, unthinkable or fundamental threats to children, society, the common good and national security (see Bersani, 1996; Edelman, 2004; Gould, 2009). If being abject – generally a negative thing – is to stand outside of and/or fail to conform with dominant identities, systems and orders – in this case, normative sexuality and gender – then queerness, which works through a different epistemology, delights in abjection by deliberately flouting heteronormative demands. To be abject is favourable. Queer is therefore a political commitment to never being nor wanting to be constituted ‘normal’ for all the power that entails. It is an outlaw existence that is antisocial in its perpetual, unapologetic anti-normativity. Identifying and destabilizing oppressive regimes of ab/normalization that constitute particular bodies and their behaviours as normal/perverse is important (Butler, 1990; Warner, 2000). However, Bersani demanded more of queer theory and politics: we may discover, within the very ambiguities of being gay, a path of resistance far more threatening to dominant social orders than vestimentary blurrings of sexual difference and possibly subversive separations of sex from gender. There are some glorious precedents for thinking of homosexuality as truly disruptive – as a force not limited to the modest goals of tolerance for diverse lifestyles, but in fact mandating the politically unacceptable and politically indispensable choice of an outlaw existence. (Bersani, 1996: 76, emphasis in original) He suggested that ‘the value of sexuality is to demean the seriousness of efforts to redeem it’, for ‘if the rectum is the grave in which the masculine ideal (an ideal shared – differently – by men and women) of proud subjectivity is buried, then it should be celebrated for its very potential for death’ (Bersani, 1987: 222, emphasis in original; see also Bersani, 1996: 19). Problematizing how anal sex has been constituted as the aberration that ‘feminizes’ the ‘passive’ man – where the rectum is the sanctum where masculinity resides – Bersani proposes embracing queer abjection and using it as a force for shattering masculine/feminine ideals and attendant power structures that constrain erotic pleasure and subjectivity to rigidly gendered sexuality; short-circuiting heteronormative sociality by taking pride in deviant sex(uality); and liberation from repression. Queer is more than resistance to heteronormativity by showing how it works. It is more than mimicry, parody, troubling or a camp reworking of hegemonic forms of the social – the compulsory practice of heterosexuality – and is instead ‘a potentially revolutionary inaptitude . . . for sociality as it is known’ (Bersani, 1996: 75). It unapologetically embraces deviation and uses it as a vehicle for social transformation. This antisocial version of queer is tied to the politics of gay shame, stigma and respectability. Recognizing gay shame in deviance from the heteronormative programme, queer people/theorists/activists argued for pride in sexual difference. This is rooted in recognition that even the most morally defended sex is perverted: we are all subject to the spectre of desire and its uncontrollable, unpredictable workings (Bersani, 1987: 222; Warner, 2000: 2–3, 36–38). This queer pride differs from that associated with the ‘politics of respectability’ that emerged in the 1980s and remains central to the LGBT political project (Gould, 2009: 245). Instead of downplaying sexual difference for a shot at inclusion in ‘an oppressive and exploitative society’ (cue sanitized slogans like ‘love is love’) – a strategy that ironically achieves the phobic goal of eliminating difference – pride in sexual deviance ‘weaponizes’ the constitution of queer sex as abject for ‘righteous rebellion’ against sociopolitical norms (Gould, 2009: 249). It resists the trap of effusing moral justifications for sexual tastes and practices – as if erotic pleasure has to be defended. To playfully delight in abjection is to take joy in being abject and to tease those who take sex too seriously by attempting to moralize it or control desire. To celebrate queerness by taking endless, playful, ridiculing delight in it, rather than hiding what might hamper social acceptance, is political. In the case of Russian political homophobia, sex is geopolitical. Celebrating queerness is recognition that bodies are the battleground upon which geopolitical struggles are fought (Russia vs. Gayropa) through control of gender performance, sexual freedoms and bodily pleasures. Rather than resignifying transgressive sexual desire or gender performance as ‘normal’ and allowing it to be subsumed – accommodated, disarmed – into dominant society, queer shortcircuits the power of heteronormativity by embracing its abject label, refusing to (be made to) conform to cisheteronormative standards of social and political life, and finding joy from the trauma of the normal imposed. This refusal does not dissolve the hierarchical straight/queer, normal/abnormal binary as such but short-circuits its power. Acknowledging the hierarchical constitution of sexual practices/desires and certain erotic pleasures as perverse, queer challenges heteronormativity and homophobic hierarchies by rejoicing in queer aberrance, delighting in it and claiming dignity in supposedly shameful erotic pleasures – ultimately laying the groundwork for new forms of (queer) subjectivity that challenge what is deemed shameful.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.