Queer visibility demands the alt – without paying close attention to the ways queerness operates in IR, the newly visible queer body is subjected to the violent whims of the state.
Lind, Amy. “‘Out’ in International Relations: Why Queer Visibility Matters.” International Studies Review, vol. 16, no. 4, 2014, pp. 601–04. JSTOR, http://www.jstor.org/stable/24758505. Accessed 22 Jul. 2022. //ONHS IF
Like SSM, anti-gay laws can also be seen as global sites of both dispute and (ironically) celebration. How hegemonic states respond to anti-gay laws fascinating in itself: David Cameron has publicly linked countries' LGBT rights record directly to UK foreign aid conditionality. Likewise, former Secretary of State Hillary Clinton has linked LGBT rights to countries' "democratic records,” and the US AID Global LGBT Development Partnership is now the largest state-sponsored initiative of its kind. Uganda, in particular, has been threatened with foreign aid suspension due to the passage of the 2014 Homosexuality Act, which broadens the criminalization of same-sex including life in prison for those found guilty and penalties for activist groups that support LGBT rights. Indeed, while the brutality of the law fortunately was dismissed by Uganda's Supreme Court, merits a response has to ask "why Uganda?" and not other countries. Interestingly, when Cameron and Obama were faced with international pressure to boycott the 20 Olympics following the passage of Russia's "gay propaganda" law, both publicly opposed a boycott. Cameron stated, "I believe we can better address prejudice if we attend, not by boycotting..." (Xydias 2013); Obama opted not to attend himself but invited LGBT celebrities to be part of the US delegation. Threats suspension or boycotts are seen as exceptionalist when clearly neither the UK nor the United States have achieved such "modernization" at home. How, then, can scholars and activists best navigate these political landscapes and understand the ambivalent nature of globalized queer visibility? Here I offer three preliminary thoughts: First, recognizing how queer visibility becomes a tool of hegemony and empire is key: As I've outlined above, queer visibility in global arenas has brought with it a series of paradoxes that involve the legitimization of a "new gay normal" (read: Western, middle class, white, masculine, gender-normative) over all else, and which often serves as fodder for broader struggles for/against colonialism, westernization, and empire. Rao (2012) has described this tension as involving those who claim to be on the "right side of history” (the normative move toward global gay rights, launched primarily by Wes and global institutions) vs. those who are simply "on the wrong side of empire”, including queers in countries deemed "uncivil," "dangerous," or "backward” according to hegemonic standards. Being "on the right side of history”, implies, then, serving empire as well. Currently, this "new gay normal" is being played out in foreign policy, security, and development arenas and is embedded in state as well as market ideologies linking gays to growth and neoliberal modernity. Second, because states and global institutions are now finally "paying attention to us" (Scott Long, quoted in Rao 2012), bringing heightened visibility to LGBT rights, it is imperative that "we" pay attention to states and global institutions as they continue to legislate, advocate, and/or construct discourses concerning LBGT rights in a global context- this being only one, albeit important aspect of thinking “queerly” and critically in our queries of IR. Major groundwork has been done to understand how hetero- and homonormativities are embedded in state practices of securitization (for example, Weber, Duggan, or Puar) and law and policy making (for example, Weiss and Bosia), yet much needs to be carried out to better understand how and why states craft both homophobic and homopositive strategies as they relate to their national political economies as well as their positions vis-à-vis other states and regions, and to address the very real consequences of pro and anti LGBT rights discourse in people’s lives. This certainly applies to nonstate communities as well (for example, Palestine) and to nonhegemonic states that invoke a heteronormative notion of nationalism (for example, Ecuador, Cuba). Finally, although here I have focused on queer visibility in relation to state practices, it is crucial, of course, that we pay attention to how other hegemonic institutions such as institutions of global finance and development convey heteronormative and/or homonormative logics in their supposedly neutral (and/or modernization) discourse, with very real effects for citizens and policy recipients (Cornwall, Correa, and Jolly 2008; Bedford 2009; Lind 2010). The World Bank's suspension of US $90 million in aid to Uganda in March 2014 is a case in point, alongside the Bank's "Economic Cost of Homophobia" project, which aims to monetize the cost of discrimination and link it to aid distribution, economic growth, and modernization. While advances in LGBT rights are important steps the political messiness of queer visibility offers IR scholars an opportunity to think more critically about how state practices contribute to and indeed power fully shape the (hetero)normative landscape in which we conceptualize our work.