The counter plan solves via reidentification.
Eman and Dankar 2008 — Khaled El Emam, Children's Hospital of Eastern Ontario Research Institute; Fida Kamal Dankar, Children's Hospital of Eastern Ontario Research Institute, 2008 (“Protecting Privacy Using k-Anonymity,” J am Med, October, Available Online at https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2528029/?tool=pmcentrez, Accessed 07-13-2022)
There is increasing pressure to disclose health research data, and this is especially true when the data has been collected using public funds. However, the disclosure of such data raises serious privacy concerns. For example, consider an individual who participated in a clinical trial having all of their clinical and lab data published in a journal web site accompanying the article on the trial. If it was possible to re-identify the records of that individual from this public data it would be a breach of privacy. Such an incident could result in fewer people participating in research studies because of privacy concerns, and if it happened in Canada, would be breaking privacy laws.
It is therefore important to understand precisely the types of re-identification attacks that can be launched on a data set and the different ways to properly anonymize the data before it is disclosed.
Anonymization techniques result in distortions to the data. Excessive anonymization may reduce the quality of the data making it unsuitable for some analysis, and possibly result in incorrect or biased results. Therefore, it is important to balance the amount of anonymization being performed against the amount of information loss.
In this paper we focused on k-anonymity, which is a popular approach for protecting privacy. We considered the two re-identification scenarios that k-anonymity is intended to protect against. For one of the scenarios, we showed that actual re-identification risk under the baseline k-anonymity is much lower than the threshold risk that the data custodian assumes, and that this results in an excessive amount of information loss, especially at small sampling fractions. We then evaluated three alternative approaches and found that one of them consistently ensures that the re-identification risk is quite close to the actual risk, and always has lower information loss than the baseline approach.
It is recommended that data custodians determine which re-identification scenarios apply on a case-by-case basis, and anonymize the data before disclosure using the baseline k-anonymity model or our modified k-anonymity model accordingly.