The CP solves growth---creates a more productive and skilled workforce
Baily 20, Martin Neil, 12-16-2020, Ph.D. in economics in 1972 at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Senior Fellow Emeritus in Economic Studies at Brookings. "How to boost long-run growth after COVID-19," Brookings, https://www.brookings.edu/research/how-to-boost-long-run-growth-after-covid-19/ //BigSasher
Members of the workforce who have not completed a college degree and receive very little on-the-job training are shortchanged by our current educational system. These workers have seen their earnings stagnate, and they are undercutting their lifetime incomes by leaving the workforce early.[11] To improve the post-pandemic labor market and to help companies be more productive, policymakers should invest in an expanded skills training program. This is not a short-term policy, it is a long-run project. Achieving stronger productivity and more inclusive growth depends on creating a more skilled workforce.
In designing a training program it is vital to avoid the problems that have plagued such efforts in the past. Anthony Carnevale, a training expert now at Georgetown, has laid out the key problems. Many previous programs were designed to train workers for manufacturing jobs even though the availability of manufacturing jobs is limited. Most past programs were run in collaboration with unions and employers have adversarial relationships with them. Some past programs have been costly to employers and workers they have trained quit for a better jobs elsewhere. Some parents are opposed to training programs, seeing them as pushing their children into second-class careers.[12 ]Carnevale notes the federal training budget is only $8 billion, so we are not really trying to train the workforce. This proposal by Brookings expert Annelies Goger includes elements I just described. It recommends scaling up “earn and learn” programs in states and regions, in which employer and community college partnerships provide workers a compensation as they receive on-the-job training.
There are also lessons to be drawn from successful training programs. Harry Holzer, also of Georgetown and a Brookings nonresident senior fellow, has written extensively on training programs, finding that those with the right design have worked well. Programs do better when they provide training through community colleges that is linked to the needs of local employers. An assessment by Mathematica of registered apprenticeship programs in 10 states concluded that program participants had substantially higher earnings than nonparticipants. Other countries’ successes with training programs are also worth considering. Germany has a very extensive apprenticeship program that trains young people not just for manufacturing jobs but also for service sector jobs. Denmark has a program called Flexicurity which provides retraining for workers who have lost their jobs. If a company lays off workers, those workers are given generous financial support, but this is linked to their participation in a training program. If workers fail to participate in training or if they turn down a suitable job, they lose the financial support.[13]
The potential for improvement is great. A recent study by Peter Q. Blair and colleagues found that as many as 30 million workers that do not have Bachelor’s degrees have the potential to obtain better jobs and earn more than they are paid the positions they currently hold. They have intrinsic skills that are not being using in their current jobs.
In designing a new program, I propose that states and cities have the flexibility to organize their efforts in accordance with local labor market conditions. Programs should be run in collaboration with employers that can specify the skills they need, provide instructors, and promise jobs to those that pass qualifying exams. In return, the employers get trained workers at low cost. Community colleges provide a natural setting for this training to take place, but instructors must have the necessary experience and skills to provide hands-on training. It is futile to train more people for manufacturing jobs than there are jobs available, but as the older generation retires there will be job openings in this sector. Further, there are many blue-collar jobs in the service sector that pay well and remain in demand, such as auto mechanics, heating and air conditioning servicers, and plumbers. Participants in training should be paid a stipend, conditional on attendance and receive a bonus for passing the program, which may help overcome resistance to vocational education.
Experimentation by local governments should be encouraged as long as data is made available to allow independent post-program evaluation of successes and failures. The federal government should underwrite the cost of the programs, recognizing that a percentage of the funds will be wasted but that a more skilled workforce benefits the whole economy. There should be extensive marketing and messaging around the training programs and investments in outreach. Providing a stipend plus a good outreach program will help overcome the resistance of younger people to a non-academic program and the resistance of older workers to re-training. Funds should be included to set up an easy interface to inform people about the programs and to help people enroll online. As part of the training, people should be coached on how to apply for jobs. Technology can help in the learning process as long as there are good teachers and mentors available.