SMRs avoid meltdowns
Scott Corbin 19, Emergency Management Director, Masters in Homeland Security and Defense, “Reducing the Potential Consequences of Nuclear Power Using Small Modular Nuclear Reactors,” Naval Post Graduate School, https://www.hsdl.org/?view&did=825215 // CROSSINGS BY
The hypothesis in this thesis suggests that if the United States does not have a strategy for replacing its current fleet of commercial nuclear power plants, it might find itself short of the baseload power to sustain the population into the future. To analyze this problem, it was necessary to understand why the public perceives nuclear power as a higher risk than other forms of energy. This was accomplished by finding research already compiled that suggests the cause of these concerns and ways to improve public confidence moving forward. The research also had to examine what other nations are doing to address the recycling and storage of waste as well as new design models that could be safer and more versatile than traditional, fixed sites.
Using qualitative objectives, the Nuclear Regulatory Commission outlined its goals in a policy statement (51 Federal Register 30,028), which states,
• Individual members of the public should be provided a level of protection from the consequences of nuclear power plant operation such that individuals bear no significant additional risk to life and health.
• Societal risks to life and health from nuclear power plant operation should be comparable to or less than the risks of generating electricity by viable competing technologies and should not be a significant addition to other societal risks.
Using data from probabilistic risk assessments, this thesis concluded that moving ahead with SMRs is in line with the commission’s goals and even exceeds its expectations. The results also indicate that other forms of energy have a higher frequency of risk and with more significant impacts on health and the environment than nuclear power. The research also suggests that recycling could be to the nation's advantage by creating additional future fuel for new reactor designs and reducing waste storage. Also, SMRs can operate with a high degree of safety, and the reduction in off-site preparedness could be justified.
Various recommendations include 1) extending the license renewal of current operating facilities only as necessary to replace them with SMRs; 2) changing the national policy to permit the reprocessing of spent fuel reduce long-term repositories and keep fuel available well into the future; and 3) replacing the current nuclear power plant infrastructure with SMRs or passive systems that will reduce negative consequences and improve public confidence.