A new international agreement would be greatly helpful towards space security
Moltz 14 (James Clay, Chairman of the Department of National Security Affairs at the Naval Postgraduate school)
At the far end of the options spectrum is the possibility of new international agreements involving larger numbers of actors. These include codes of conduct, conventions (such as the 2007 UN Space Debris Mitigation Guidelines), and formal treaties. Depending on the nature of the agreements, the level of domestic approval required, and the intrusiveness of verification and/or enforcement mechanisms, negotiating these arrangements can be more (or less) difficult. But formal agreements do offer real advantages in terms of reliability, stability, clarity of rules, effectiveness of implementation, and longevity. U.S.-Russian nuclear arms control efforts would have been ineffective without treaties and effective verification. Similarly, worldwide efforts to prohibit and destroy chemical weapons would not have been as successful as they have been without the 1993 Chemical Weapons Convention, its timeline for dismantlement, and its verification mechanisms. Space may have specific threatening activities that could be most effectively addressed by treaties as well. To support such efforts, it may also be beneficial to create an international space monitoring organization to supplement or work alongside existing U.S. military systems. The U.S. Air Force is already working in this direction through its cooperation with allies and even, on a more limited basis, with China, to provide warning of potential collisions involving their spacecraft. But the United States cannot be expected to pay for such an international mechanism. If countries want the benefits of enhanced transparency and the stability it could bring, they are going to have to devote adequate resources to the task, just as the United States has done out of its own national security interests in developing its Joint Space Operations Center. Private companies have also begun to pool resources in the Space Data Association (mentioned in chapter 4). It remains to be seen if the countries that are worried about space weapons tests, orbital debris, and various types of harmful interference will be able to cooperate both politically and financially to support the creation of such a system.