CP solves — U.S. leadership is only possible through combined action according to the Center for Strategic & International Studies.
CSIS 22 — Center for Strategic & International Studies, a bipartisan, nonprofit policy research organization dedicated to advancing practical ideas to address the world’s greatest challenges, 2022 (“Renewing U.S. Leadership in Standards,” Center for Strategic & International Studies, June 13th, Available Online at https://www.csis.org/analysis/renewing-us-leadership-standards, Accessed 07-21-2022)
U.S. policymakers must take specific actions with clear policy objectives to preserve a rules-based global standards ecosystem, adhering to and maintain a market- and consumer-driven innovation agenda (rather than one that is state-driven), and technology selection based on consensus and merit.
Various parts of the U.S. administration have recognized the importance of maintaining U.S. leadership in standards that are critical for economic growth and national security:
Executive action: Last year, for example, the National Security Commission on Artificial Intelligence (NSCAI) released a final report making critical recommendations for maintaining U.S. leadership in AI standards. Various actions by the administration have underlined the importance of maintaining leadership in 5G standards, including the president’s Executive Order on “Promoting Competition in the American Economy” in July 2021.
Cooperate with allies and strategic partners: The United States should work with its allies and strategic partners to establish and maintain a rules-based ecosystem globally. Currently, this should include greater attention to cooperation on standards issues through the U.S.- EU Trade and Technology Council and the Quad initiative with Australia, India, and Japan.
Congressional action: Congress can outline key design principles and relevant interagency processes to guide the development and coordination of standards through the reconciliation of the USICA COMPETES In particular, Congress should give NIST a directive to work on a companion of the existing Office of Management and Budget (OMB) directive for tighter linkage between innovation and standards policy and investment. The policy of the United States regarding the role of government in the standards process is outlined in OMB Circular A-119.
Taken together, these actions should contribute to:
Maintaining a robust intellectual property rights (IPR) regime: To maintain the incentives of U.S. firms to participate in long-term and risky R&D that is required to be an innovation leader and lead in critical standards, protecting the ability of U.S. firms to monetize their IP in international markets is the first step.
Establishing strong governance principles: Setting out strong governance principles for SDOs based on openness, transparency, consensus, and majority voting will avoid gamesmanship and maintain a rules-based merit-driven ecosystem.
Maintaining global standards: It is critical that global standards are maintained, both for U.S. firms to maintain a market-driven incentive in investing in standards (due to an economy of scale that would be lost in a bifurcated world where firms are forced to work only on national standards), and for the world to have the best technologies (due to the innovation agenda being set based on the market and not based on a state’s direction).
Promoting U.S. government interagency and public-private coordination: Such action might entail reinstating and chartering the National Science and Technology Council (NSTC) interagency subcommittee on standards for this purpose, and promoting investments made by the U.S. government that leverage and accelerate private sector commitments to advance U.S. standards leadership—such as those based on tax-incentives, direct investments, and the ability to utilize federal R&D funds towards standards-relevant technologies.
Investing in standards-based skill sets for U.S. workers: Increasing the United States’ focus and investment for standards literacy in higher education and research should be a critical step in driving home the importance of this work to U.S. global leadership. The United States, via the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST), currently provides limited funding, on the order of $400,000 per year for standards education and curriculum advancement in the United States. The United States’ global competitors invest substantially in this capacity. Additionally, the investment by NIST in international relationships for standards and metrology, including education and capacity development, is dwarfed by those investments being made by Europe and Asia, and particularly by China.