US is the best country to lead in AI and must create global norms.
Beier and Cunningham 19, David Beier and Nelson Cunningham, David Beier is the Managing Director of Bay Capital City. Previously Chief Domestic Policy to Vice President Al Gore. Senior corporate officer DNA and Amgen. Nelso is the President of McLarty Associates, global strategy firm. Former Clinton and Biden aide, former AUSA in SDNY, 10-26-2019, “America Must Lead the Global Charge on Artificial Intelligence,” https://medium.com/swlh/america-must-lead-the-global-charge-on-artificial-intelligence-bfa6688a1c18, OJ
When the world’s first power plant switched on in 1882 — steam engines, fired by coal, lighting lower Manhattan — policymakers probably didn’t ask what this breakthrough would mean for America’s rivalry with Germany, the rising industrial and military power of the day. This century’s breakthrough technology is artificial intelligence, as consequential today as electricity was to the 19th century. Which nation leads on AI will lead on, well, everything. And that brings us to America’s rapidly escalating conflict with today’s rising power, China. AI will profoundly improve human society, affecting the daily lives of people in every corner of the world. If you’ve ever tried Google Translate and been frustrated (or amused) by the results, you can imagine the benefits of truly intelligent translations that communicate the full cultural or social meaning into a new language. AI researchers are on the path to achieving this sort of breakthrough, which will revolutionize the ease and clarity with which we communicate across borders, cultures and societies. And that’s just a start. Artificial intelligence is more important than any single country’s agenda. It’s a breakthrough that transcends national rivalries. And yet, we can be sure AI will be weaponized both literally and figuratively. The US and China are racing to establish AI advantage, economic and military alike. An early flashpoint in the fight is Huawei. The US is determined to prevent its allies from partnering with the Chinese telecommunications giant to build next-generation 5G wireless networks. We are fast entering a new Cold War where a modern-day bamboo curtain may separate Chinese AI systems from Western systems. It’s Betamax vs VHS with military reinforcement. Whose technology will dominate the AI era? Here’s the bottom line: no country is in a stronger position to craft a framework for global AI norms than America. We have the world’s largest economy, the most advanced military and competitive advantage in AI research and education. No country has played a more important role in establishing the rules governing global policymaking than America. A Center for Data Innovation study out this summer found that the United States is indeed ahead on AI — for now. But China is rapidly closing the gap. What next? It’s time for America to step up and create a global framework for AI. What we do in America should set a course for the rest of the world to follow. China included. Some politicians and policymakers in Washington and Silicon Valley believe the government should regulate AI as little as possible, leaving markets alone. This instinct is a useful counterweight to excessive regulation, but a simplistic view of the government’s economic and industrial contributions. And, we can be sure the Chinese approach will not be laissez-faire. The truth is the public sector plays multiple roles. In the case of new products or services, it acts as regulator, promoter, standard-setter, purchaser and rule-maker of global policy. Only the government can outline a comprehensive strategy for when and how to engage in all these AI policy parameters. Despite early efforts by the Trump Administration to call attention to AI, fitful steps by individual members of Congress and ad hoc contributions from cities and states, most of the policy framework for AI is not yet mature. For instance, there is no agreement about how to prepare for the adoption of AI in the workplace and no national privacy policy. We have no uniform rules for how consumer data must be safeguarded and how it may be used. We have no plan for multilateral coordination with other countries. Above all, there is quite literally no one in the United States in charge of its national AI policy. The time has come for a policy architecture that permits the United States — through its federal government, cooperating with business and civil society — to speak definitively, ethically and with detail about AI rules for everything from workers’ rights to responsible uses of facial recognition technology and autonomous drones in armed conflict. The US needs this not only for its own needs, but to provide a path for the rest of the world to follow. With thoughtful action, we can shape whose vision of the public interest will infuse AI: the liberal Western vision, or the Chinese, collectivist, authoritarian vision? For a Western definition of public interest to prevail, we need a set of international trade rules to guide the AI era. These rules should help open markets, protect intellectual property, minimize coerced tech transfer and do away with unfair government subsidies for AI. The Paris-based Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development has made initial, think tank-style recommendations and the World Economic Forum is helping keep AI on the agenda among global business leaders. These are a good start, but not sufficient. The American agenda should focus on the adoption of a uniform framework that protects users’ data without stifling commerce. It should include the right of citizens to learn what data is being collected on them, the right to say “no,” and sensible and workable rules for correcting and deleting data. Further, a new global AI standard should place strict limitations of the use of AI tools for intrusive government surveillance. A new AI framework should mandate accountability through mandatory disclosures to assure fairness, reliability, accuracy and assurance of diversity of data collection. This American agenda will pave a path for like-minded countries to follow. We can resist Chinese pressure, but only if we come together in common cause. The alternative to US leadership may be a Balkanized constellation of policies and regulations. Or, worse, a Manichean world where nations are forced to pick between the United States and China. It is time for the US to lead on AI in a way that the world will follow. The first step is to get behind a push at home for a national AI policy. We can’t afford to let others write the rules for this critical component of the global economy while we debate — or sleep.