Free beta access. 5 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

China’s approach to AI development creates spending issues and careless mindsets with no accountability

Roberts et al. 20 (Huw Roberts, Oxford Internet Institute, “The Chinese Approach to Artificial Intelligence: an Analysis of Policy, Ethics, and Regulation”, June 17, 2020, AI & Soc 36, 59-77, Springer Link)//SW

Concerning local governments, the political structure within China creates a system of incentives for fulfilling national government policy aims. Short term limits for provincial politicians and promotions based on economic performance provide strong incentives for following centrally-defined government initiatives (Li and Zhou ; Persson and Zhuravskaya ). Thus, local governments become hotbeds for testing and developing central government policy. The strength of this incentive system can be seen in the decision made by the administration of the city of Tianjin to establish a $5 billion fund for the development of AI, around the same time as the publication of the AIDP (Mozur ). At the same time, it is important to recognize how the absence of an effective accountability review of local government spending creates problems within this system. Notably, it has facilitated a mindset in which local politicians know that the central government will bail them out for failed projects, leading to poor budget management (Ji ). A clear example of this is the large-scale port building initiatives developed by provincial governments in East coast provinces that were based more on prestige than any economic rationale, and which led to overcapacity and disorderly competition (Zhu ).

These incentive structures contain a subtle distinction. A national team has been selected to lead the research and development in a handful of designated strategic areas. Beyond these selected companies, there are few specific guidelines provided to industry and local state agents as to which items to pursue on the AIDP’s ‘wish list’. This enables companies to cherry-pick the technologies they want to develop and provides local governments with a choice of private sector partners for integrating AI into city infrastructure or governance (Sheehan ). Subsequent documentation has emphasised the importance of strengthening organisation and implementation, including between provinces and ministries, yet it is unclear how this coordination would function in practice. Thus, the AIDP may work as a ‘wish list’, but the exact guidance, incentivisation and risk differ depending on the type of stakeholder.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.