US maintains AI lead against China with strong universities, private sector, investment and start-up culture
Tony Bertuca 18 (Tony Bertuca, Chief Editor of Inside the Pentagon, Inside Washington, “Inside the Army”, March 19, 2018, Vol. 30, No. 11, JSTOR)//SW
The United States has a “healthy,” but tenuous lead over China in artificial intelligence and quantum computing, according to the head of the Intelligence Advanced Research Projects Activity. Jason Metheny, the director of IARPA, an organization within the Office of the Director of National Intelligence tasked with running advanced research programs for the U.S. intelligence community, said the United States has a tendency to be “alarmist” when it comes to other nations’ technological advancements. “I’m not a catastrophist when it comes to this race between the U.S. and China,” he told reporters at breakfast in Washington. “I think the United States does have a healthy lead. It doesn’t mean that we’re guaranteed to have that lead forever and regardless of policy or investment,” he continued. “This is a lead that was earned through it being a priority within the science and technology organizations. We need to continue recognizing it’s important to maintain the lead.” Metheny said China is the United States’ strongest competitor globally in machine learning and has a “very thoughtful” AI strategy, which calls for becoming a global leader in the arena by 2025. “It’s basically a Chinese translation of the U.S. AI plan, which I worked on -- there were a lot of familiar passages,” he said. “But they’ve also introduced an implementation plan for that AI strategy that includes quantitative milestones in speech recognition, imagery analysis, video analysis that are, I think, realistic, but also ambitious.” China also enjoys tighter civil-military integration than the United States does, which combines to provide a whole-of-nation effort. Still, Metheny said, such government-directed integration can be a disadvantage. “I think that the United States has an advantage in its competitive landscape,” he said. “We have the strongest universities by far. We have the strongest start-up culture and we also have risk-tolerant companies like Google and Microsoft and Amazon and Open AI that are willing to fund very high-risk research that may not pay out for five to 10 years.” Additionally, Metheny said all of IARPA’s unclassified research contracts are awarded competitively. “We engage our researchers in tournaments in which multiple research teams compete against one another toward a common set of technical goals that have highly ambitious milestones,” he said. IARPA is also the world’s largest source of academic research funding in quantum computing, which could lead to leap-ahead technological advancements in everything from global food production to data encryption and code breaking. “This is an area where I think the United States has a lead,” he said. “China is investing, but not at the levels the United States is.”