Free beta access. 5 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Aff positions great powers as a dangerous alien threat, which perpetuates neo-realist method that deems all violence acceptable as long as large nations are in harmony. Focus is on escalation rather than prevention. Turns case, aff thinks of other nations as enemies first — root cause of all violence. Alt solves — feminist conflict resolution rejects war as a means for peace.

Scheyer and Kumskova 19 (Victoria and Marina, graduating from Master’s degree Studies at the University for Peace mandated by the United Nations, Master degree in Human Rights from Columbia University, “FEMINIST FOREIGN POLICY: A FINE LINE BETWEEN “ADDING WOMEN” AND PURSUING A FEMINIST AGENDA”, 2019, Journal of International Affairs Vol.72 No.2 Spring/Summer, https://www.jstor.org/stable/26760832, pd)

The proliferation of feminist foreign policies has become a sign of commitment to another world order. Governments that adopt such action envision a world where women’s rights are equally important to those of men. They commit to empowering women and ensuring their meaningful participation across various issues. Such commitments, therefore, are understood as the objectives of a feminist foreign policy. This article explains that, while a commitment to women’s rights is important, the current practices of purportedly feminist foreign policies do not reflect an authentically feminist approach. We look into the theoretical background of feminist analysis in international relations, propose criteria for a feminist foreign policy based on feminist theory, and use these criteria to analyze and conduct gap analysis of existing feminist foreign policies. Overall, this study helps unpack the definition of feminist foreign policy and highlight areas that can be addressed by those willing to commit to redefining security and peace in the current world order. The state of the current world order depends on the lens through which one looks at it. While some suggest that gender considerations are starting to play a bigger role in international relations, others claim that gender analysis continues to be ignored and even pushed back against.1,2,3 While politicians paint either one of these pictures, there is a general consensus about the situation on the ground: In many places, the principles of democracy and multilateralism are being questioned, the rights of women, queer, indigenous, and rural groups, among others, are threatened, and conflicts are becoming more complex and are extending beyond the borders of states and regions. Mostly, the current world system still operates in a neo-realist way, in which states try to operate according to the principle of sovereignty and competition for world power.4 As the recent 2019 Munich Security Conference demonstrated, the worldwide increase of military and defense budgets, especially in the United States, China, and Russia, and the growing tensions between these states, indicate the rising competition for power.5 At such conferences, the idea of incorporating gender analysis or some feminist principles is artificial. Fortunately, there are a number of states that care to some degree about the principle of “We The People” enshrined in the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and the way social groups and members of the international community fit into the current world order. The last few years have also shown that the number of such states is increasing, supposedly in response to the ongoing failure of the “superpowers” to address violence and crises of their own making. At the same time, states that were peripheral to the establishment of the United Nations now act as megaphones of multilateralism, promoting the ethical norm of equal treatment among states and empowering each other in the process.6 One example of this is the multilateral action to adopt the Treaty on the Prohibition of Nuclear Weapons in 2017, in which states have united not around the principle of power but on the principle of opposing the security scheme that has not been working for everyone. The process showed the nine countries that possess nuclear weapons, and think of themselves as the world’s superpowers, that there is another means to security, one based on the principles of multilateralism, common morality, human rights, and extraterritorial accountability.7 In some scholarship, states that promote human rights and multilateralism are known as “good states.”8 Good states are those that use foreign policies to improve global justice beyond their borders and transform global politics through the pursuit of good international citizenship, which requires sensitivity to the needs and wants of “others.” The states that take on a similar view on global politics and their responsibility on the global scale rely on an alternative vision of global politics, looking at the drivers of conflict and the root causes of violence in communities, societies, and institutions. Feminist analysis represents another component of an alternative view on global politics, not an idealistic departure from it. This analysis provides a welldefined and augmented alternative to the neo-realistic framework. All three of the 2015 United Nations Reviews have admitted that the absence of gender analysis is a key challenge for peace.9 Feminist foreign policy is one that includes whole populations, appreciates diversity, inspires comprehensive analysis, and leaves no one behind. This article explains that striving toward a feminist foreign policy and having one are not the same. We look into the theoretical background of feminist analysis in international relations, propose criteria for a new understanding of feminist foreign policy, and apply these criteria to analyze and conduct a gap analysis of existing feminist foreign policies. Overall, this study helps unpack the definition of feminist foreign policy and highlight areas that can be addressed by those willing to redefine security and peace in the current world order. Theoretical Background: What is a Feminist Foreighn Policy? Traditional international relations theory defines foreign policy as both the relationships between states and the structural organization of a government and its foreign affairs.10 Currently, states’ relationships and governing systems are structured through a neo-realist method: These relationships and systems are organized hierarchically and situated within a security dilemma; they serve national interests; and they are based on the principle of sovereignty.11 With a few exceptions, the top ranks of these hierarchies are occupied by men and generally dominated by masculine principles. This is often overlooked because “gender is difficult to see when only the masculine is present.”12 This represents what is referred to as “patriarchy.” Feminist Critique Of Traditional Approaches To Security Patriarchal systems and practices in foreign policy are highly criticized by feminist international relations theory.13 The foundational basis of this theory is that “gender is an integral, not an accidental, feature of the worldwide structure of diplomatic, military and economic relations.”14 As Acker claims, the feminist method is not about adding women into the system but revealing how the concept of gender is incorporated into it.15 Such a method shows that current principles of foreign policy are highly dependent on gender norms, roles, and structures, and that all institutions are inherently gendered.16 Acker asserts that gender in institutions could be understood in two ways: either as a gender-neutral structure that tries to adjust women to the existing systems of power and applies principles of representational gender equality or as gender-integrated structures that apply equality and justice within the structures, norms, and ruling ideology.17 Acker agrees with the second understanding and claims that gender is an integral part of all structures.18 For us, therefore, a feminist foreign policy requires rethinking and re-envisioning gender structures of institutions and governance systems. It cannot be equivalent to a foreign policy that merely aims to ensure equal representation or meaningful participation of women in the position of power. Using Gender Analysis True, Tickner, and Enloe deconstructed the main concepts of foreign policy and international relations using gender analysis.19, 20, 21 They revealed the gender bias of security, power, and sovereignty, claiming that these concepts are made by and for men on the basis of their experiences.22 Hence, the concept of hegemonic masculinity was established to describe gendered power distribution in hierarchies. Hegemonic masculinity is understood as a “culturally idealized form” of power, mainstreamed in personal, collective, and institutional spheres of life, and expressed through hierarchy, violence, and aggression.23 Hegemonic masculinity expresses an unequal gender structure, which should be challenged by integrating feminist principles into national and foreign policy.24 Understanding Feminist Foreign Policy What does feminist foreign policy look like? Indeed, there is no agreed upon definition of a feminist foreign policy. What we have learned from feminist theory is that gender parity and attempts to make women visible in international relations are not enough to realize a comprehensive feminist foreign policy. Such an approach, according to Enloe, only implies an attempt to embed women firmly inside a patriarchal system and fails to challenge the underlying gender norms that fuel violence and conflict.25 The claim that gender parity in foreign policy will also bring about more peace and harmony in international relations is not as effective as women’s meaningful participation achieved through structural change.26 The study by UN Women and Inclusive Peace and Transition Initiative shows that, despite the fact that women’s inclusion improves opportunities for peace, the number of women present at the negotiating table does not assure a better outcome for women: “it is the level of influence that women can assert on the process that makes a difference, not only their presence by numbers.”27 In her book Bananas, Beaches, Bases, Enloe provides deep insights into how women from diverse backgrounds play an important role in international politics but are systematically excluded, ignored, and often forgotten.28 When analyzing the qualities and characteristics embodied by those in power, one will find a surprisingly homogenous group of world leaders in economics and politics. However, it is also the case that there exist female members of parliament who vote for military conflict solutions or uphold the patriarchal militarized system; they also serve as leaders of major military institutions.29 These are the manifestations of the traditional neo-realist security system, and its comparatively easy application drives both women and men into making decisions and setting their priorities.30 The feminist approach to foreign policy is not as easy; it demands a shift in how individuals within the system make political decisions and set priorities. It is about advancing peace and development for everyone, not through striving for the absence of conflict or serving the interests of individuals within the government, but through reimagining governance and social structures, as well as promoting nonviolent conflict solutions. We propose that the guiding principles for a feminist foreign policy framework should include intersectional analysis and inclusion, complete disarmament, security concepts centered around the wellbeing and safety of the individual, the inclusion of civil society, the promotion of international solidarity through dialogue, and the fostering of communities based on empathy. Indicators Of A Feminist Foreign Policy The guiding principles of feminist foreign policy can be practically visualized through the following set of indicators: political dialogue, feminist political economy, individual safety and wellbeing, empathic communities, inclusivity, and a gender analysis based on intersectionality. The following section elaborates our assumptions about what feminist foreign policy should look like based on the feminist international relations theory. Political Dialogue Political dialogue should be the basis of all aspects of foreign policy, including diplomacy, trade, conflict prevention, and conflict resolution. Unfortunately, practitioners in the field of international relations continue to emphasize militarized or forced solutions to the world’s security problems and trade politics. Feminist scholars criticize this approach and start their analysis with the question “where are the women?” and end by highlighting the need for a shift of the entire approach of security and militarism toward an inclusive dialogue.31 Feminist conflict resolution approaches reject war as a means to peace, viewing war as a result of institutionalized violence and a battle for power over the counterpart.32 Feminist scholars seek to prevent violence and identify root causes of conflict.33 Addressing the drivers of conflict instead of superficially fighting the symptoms, such as physical violence, differentiates military security from feminist approaches focused on safety and wellbeing. Feminist conflict resolution starts with a gender analysis of power, the inclusion of marginalized voices and local people through dialogue, and the commitment to disarmament.34 Safety and Wellbeing In traditional foreign policy approaches, security is given high priority. Concepts such as national or human security represent understandings of governments on what to target or how to achieve security. Feminists have criticized both concepts because these approaches ignore or overlook the gendered dimension of security.35 Feminist security studies emphasize and elaborate the importance of asking questions such as “security for who, by whom?”36 It is the questioning of the militarized security that is not able to protect women, children, civilians, migrants, among others, neither in times of conflict nor in times of peace.37 Feminist security studies emphasize the need to rethink traditional concepts of security. Putting the security issues of all intersectional groups and individuals at the center of security, the usefulness of the military industrial complex will have to be questioned.38 Buying tanks or fighter jets are not preventing children from dying of hunger, stopping preventable diseases from spreading, or averting genderbased violence. Instead, this form of security often perpetuates these situations.39 In an ever-changing society featuring dynamically evolving conflicts, Sylvester emphasizes that there is a need to always review, reframe, and reflect on current approaches of security and avoid the formulation of universal, timeless, and fixed security concepts.40 With this in mind, we refrain from unpacking the concept of security, and we support feminist ideas of shifting the focus from security toward the peace, safety, and wellbeing of the gendered individual. Wellbeing, in this vein, includes physical safety in addition to the social and political security of people and the fulfillment of basic social needs. We argue that the way problems are framed inherently influences the way solutions are found. While defining security not through the absence of violence but through the foundations of peace, world leaders can commit to peace through, for example, renaming the United Nations Security Council into the United Nations Peace Council. Feminist Foreign Policy demands shifting toward a positive peace model and away from security. Empathic Communities The third indicator we have identified is based on the building of empathic communities. We differentiate between alliances based on military or defense strategies and communities based on empathy and friendship. Alliances such as the North Atlantic Treaty Organization (NATO), the Collective Security Treaty Organization (CSTO), or even the current structure of the United Nations Security Council (UNSC), serve the goal of engaging in alliances to advance militarized security and national interests. These coalitions further capitalize on the fundamental values of neo-realism in international politics and represent the hegemonic security model. Because these alliances always come with implicit assumptions such as the presence of an enemy, a threat, and power conflict, violent escalation often proves inevitable. Feminism claims that there are more reasons for building communities, which are not about military and power, but rather about common goals such as peace, mutually beneficial trade agreements, or agreements on disarmament. Those can eventually build trust and dependencies so that attacks and war would seem illogical. Communities such as the Group of Friends of 1325, the Informal Expert Group on Women, Peace, and Security, and Friends of Gender Parity are built on agreements that open dialogue builds trust and empathy. Inclusion and Intersectional Approach While there is not yet diverse and inclusive representation of the heterogeneous society we live in, civil society groups, grassroots organizations, and local organizations offer key forums through which diverse experiences can be integrated in international relations. Feminist foreign policy needs to identify these forums and include these actors in policy making. This could be achieved through making space for gender lobbyism, regularly hearing and consulting with civil society, reaching out to grassroots and local organizations and refraining from supporting traditional hierarchical structures through a reference to a “bottom-up” approach, which is inherently hierarchical. Gender Analysis Feminist methodology as the overarching umbrella of all indicators represents a critical examination of power. Foreign policy and international relations are an amphitheater for power relations, and gender analysis represents a tool to change the script. Asking questions such as “who is involved?,” “why are certain decisions made?,” “who is affected?,” and “who controls resources?” represents the shared practice of feminist gender analysis, which aims to reveal underlying power relations and to deconstruct the discrimination, silencing, and marginalization of groups that do not fit existing gendered identities.41 Gender analysis reveals what is behind social and political norms and assists in providing alternative solutions. Moreover, it elucidates the experiences of different groups of people, which can help detect root causes of inequality as a starting point of correcting discriminatory policies and laws.42 As discussed above, a gender analysis needs to be applied to existing security concepts, military alliances, and militarism. Gender analysis is crucial to understand why people lack access to resources, why some communities are more prone to violence, or how policies affect different groups of people. Gender analysis, hence, is a basic tool and methodology for a feminist foreign policy. What Is “Feminist” In Current Foreign Policies? A small number of countries have already announced their adoption of feminist policies and programs within their foreign policy frameworks. With the announcement of its feminist foreign policy in 2014, Sweden is seen as the pioneer of feminist foreign policy and a norm-setter on how gender matters in international relations.43 Gender equality has also been featured prominently in some parts of British foreign policy since 2009, and the UK International Development (Gender Equality) Act adopted in 2014.44,45 Between 2011 and 2015, the Australian government also made a commitment to global gender equality and women’s empowerment as a core foreign policy goal.46 Following these examples, Canada’s government announced its adoption of feminist international assistance policies.47 In February 2016, Australia adopted a comprehensive foreign policy gender strategy.48 Similarly, Norway adopted a gender strategy within its foreign policy in October 2016.49 The latest addition to the list is Germany, which promised to take the issue of women, peace, and security seriously in its 2019-2020 tenure in the UN Security Council, and it has important political leaders, including Stefan Liebich of Die Linke and the Green Party, pushing for slightly varied definitions of a feminist foreign policy.50,51 Many of these policies are focusing disproportionately on the rights and experiences of women. If having a focus on women’s empowerment is what constitutes a feminist foreign policy, then the United States qualifies, too. The State Department, under Secretaries of State Hillary Clinton and John Kerry, crafted a collection of issue-specific foreign policies on various gender issues, including the U.S. Strategy to Prevent and Respond to Gender-Based Violence Globally, the National Action Plan on Women, Peace, and Security, and a Global Strategy to Empower Adolescent Girls.52 Feminist scholars and activists have many issues with calling any of the above-mentioned policies “feminist.” First, these policies are often criticized for being inconsistent in the feminist approach to international relations. Second, in many situations, gender considerations are not being put at the center of all of the foreign policy decisions that these countries undertake. Lastly, every single policy from this list focuses disproportionately on the situation of women, their rights, and needs, instead of addressing gendered power structures, identifying silenced groups, building empathic communities, and rethinking important concepts, such as sovereignty, militarism, and nationalism. Sweden’s “Handbook on Feminist Foreign Policy,” for example, defines a feminist foreign policy as a transformative agenda that aims to change structures and enhance the visibility of women and girls as actors.”53 In theory, feminist foreign policy should be about looking into the structures, addressing gendered power relations, building gender inclusive institutions and pursuing policies that incorporate the interests of and seek to benefit all. Our analysis of the nature and implementation of existing feminist foreign policies revealed the following key gaps, thus challenging the “feminist” label given to them. The Political Economy Of War The traditional approach to security supports the idea that international conflict is best solved through war and violence.54 One goal of feminist foreign policy should be to change this ideology and advance security based on individuals’ wellbeing, disarmament, and political dialogue. Militarism, Enloe claims, is both ideology and worldview: having enemies is a natural situation, that violence is a part of human nature, and that the masculine needs to protect the feminine. The military and the military-industrial complex are known to marginalize femininity, which is seen as a weakness. In this vein, the military-industrial complex exists to show the prevalence of some over others, to defeat what is seen as a weakness by what is perceived as power. Therefore, by simply addressing the situation of women, feminist foreign policies would not be able to achieve what feminism stands for, which is re-envisioning security through the understanding of power and the masculinity-femininity nexus. However, it is well known that a source of income for many governments is its arms trade and the mining of “conflict minerals,” such as wolframite and cobalt.55 This list includes the United States, the United Kingdom, Australia, Canada, Sweden, and many others. All of these countries are engaged in the political economy of war—the context in which the relationship between production, labor, trade, law, policy, and the distribution of national income are gender-blind and militarized.56 The Women’s International League for Peace and Freedom (WILPF) conducted a series of studies exposing the impact of arms transfers from Sweden and the United Kingdom to Saudi Arabia on the lives of women in Yemen.57 Similarly, WILPF also exposed how the production and mining of minerals by Canada, for example, clearly prioritizes systems of monetary profit over citizens’ human rights and governmental accountability.58 Women, in this context, are negatively and disproportionally affected. For example, gender-based violence in the mining industry is often disproportionately connected to the socioeconomic conditions in which women find themselves.59 Women are forced to work in the mines as cooks and cleaners because of the absence of jobs available to them, and the militarized atmosphere at mining sites often negatively impacts the way women are treated. Therefore, countries that claim to be pursuing feminist foreign policies are not making sincere efforts to reimagine governance and security, instead contributing to the escalation of violence and the promotion of a masculine military ideology. One rare exception is the Government of Costa Rica, which, while not having yet adopted a feminist foreign policy framework, has made great strides in reallocating its entire government defense budget to health and public services.60 In the majority of countries, however, a feminist foreign policy becomes nothing more than a label. The policies that states choose to roll out cannot be separated from the lived and highly gendered experiences of conflict, and from the new and often more complex and overlapping needs that emerge as a result of that conflict. Heteronormativity And Exclusion The concept of heteronormativity refers to the constructed norm of heterosexuality in society, and the concomitant notion that other gender identities are deviant or “abnormal.”61 The problem lies in the fact that a certain set of norms and rules determine the domination of one gender over another, including deciding over identity groups and having different rights and social recognition, a situation that highly influences the way policymaking is carried out. Some of the gender analysis toolkits across various fields assessed for this research are based on the binary definition of gender.62 In this system, lesbians, gays, bisexuals, transgender, and queer identities have been excluded from the political sphere through discrimination in law and in practice.63 Laws exert significant control over sexuality, marriage, and identity, and are also used to maintain the current distribution of power in the international system. These social norms are also reflected in institutions and organizations, the majority of which are set up according to specific gender norms. Connell calls this phenomenon “the gender regime of an institution” and claims that it creates an enabling environment for exclusion.64 The complaint brought in 2014 by W.H. v. Sweden at the European Court of Human Rights shows how far the gendered regime of an institution can go. W.H., who applied for asylum because she tried to escape a forced marriage in Iraq, was determined as not having a plausible case for a refugee status in Sweden. The Migration Board of Sweden noted that she would not lack a “male network” to protect her in Iraq because her brother had also been refused asylum in Sweden.65 The European Court has upheld Sweden’s decision to reject the applicant’s application for asylum. This is but one example of how institutions of law can be highly gendered. At the same time, Germany, which has yet to develop a feminist foreign policy, has demonstrated first steps towards challenging gender-blind governance by, among other initiatives, opening a series of investigations into gender-based violence crimes committed by ISIS against Yazidi women.66 In this regard, Belgium has also made great strides. The Belgian justice system exercises what is known as “universal jurisprudence,” allowing its national courts to prosecute anyone who has committed genocide, war crimes, or crimes against humanity anywhere in the world.67 Although other countries have similar laws, Belgium’s are particularly broad, and its judges are unusually willing to use them.68 A feminist foreign policy or a policy guided by a feminist approach should start with a gender analysis that addresses gender norms, roles and relations through the inclusion of marginalized voices and experiences into institutions and sectors such as health, education, and security, among others. Security In the neorealist worldview, national security and sovereignty, the protection of borders, and the control of trade represent core security concerns. This security is often provided through standby military defense mechanisms and migration laws. While this concept seems to fail protecting people from violence and the impact of wars, feminist scholars have raised questions concerning who are the main beneficiaries of traditional security frameworks and what groups are excluded.69 Having revealed the focus on upholding sovereign power structures and state systems, feminist security studies claim that to understand security, one needs to understand power, which itself is gendered.70 Shepherd demands a shift toward security for the individual, including stateless people and migrants and the development of comprehensive positive models for peace rather than security.71 Australia, one country that faces major gender security issues related to border control and immigration detention, is one example where the concept of security has yet to be transformed through a foreign policy gender strategy. True argues that government actors in Australia have interpreted the state’s responsibility to prevent violence and protect against gender-specific crimes, primarily in relation to military, diplomatic, peace-building, and aid presences, “outside” Australian borders in conflict-affected and post-conflict states.72 They have not recognized the responsibility to include non-citizens inside or outside Australian borders who have fled conflict zones and gender-based oppression. In this context, Australia’s National Action Plan on Women, Peace and Security 2012-18, which focuses on women’s protection and prevention of sexual and gender-based violence, does not have a mandate to incorporate the protection of women and their dependents fleeing conflict zones or gender oppression and crossing Australian borders as irregular migrants or asylum-seekers.73 At the same time, Germany has made the safety of women and children refugees a priority.74 There are various programs that help refugee women obtain skills and employment, integrate within communities, and get necessary support.75,76,77 Similarly, Jordan continues to demonstrate humanitarian leadership in the Syrian refugee crisis, providing multi-sectoral services that build women’s resilience and empowerment in the support of UN Women.78 In a feminist foreign policy, the wellbeing of a population needs to be the biggest concern of a state. A feminist method, therefore, demands that the norms of women’s rights and international law be strengthened and that the focus be shifted from escalation to prevention. This implies a conceptual reorientation from a narrowly defined security policy to a comprehensive gender-responsive policy. Sovereignty And Hierarchy The logic of militarism, security, and hegemonic masculinity implies a closed hierarchical organizational and social structure. This structure distributes power to specific groups or individuals, with others submitting to it.79 Hierarchy is only one out of many forms of organization, but it is often presented as the most effective and logical one. Former civilizations even called hierarchy the “holy structure.”80 Sovereignty, in this vein, is what sustains hierarchy. As a term that came about with the Treaty of Westphalia and capitalized its importance with the signing of the United Nations Charter, it is often used as the ultimate claim to authority both domestically and internationally.81 Hierarchy and the monopoly on authority are the core characteristics of hegemonic masculinity.82 By maintaining the principles of sovereignty, masculinity is upheld through multilateral agreements such as the United Nations Charter and the creation of a common identity referred to as nationalism.83 These principles further maintain hierarchy. When we analyze the structure of the United Nations, the hierarchical structure is clearly visible in the organization of the United Nations Security Council, where the five permanent members have the privilege of the veto and the nonpermanent members are subordinate.84 Furthermore, the international peace model is oriented around the hegemonic peace theory, in which a hegemon retains disproportionate power over resources and armaments to deter conflict.85 However, there are several states that are willing to subject themselves to international accountability to build partnerships for peace. The EU Common Position on Arms Exports requires an export license to be denied if, among other things, there is a clear risk that the equipment to be exported might be used for violations of human rights or international humanitarian law.86 This signals a very important attempt to commit to protecting human rights and preventing sexual and genderbased violence at the expense of potentially having their sovereignty subjected to questioning.87 Overcoming hierarchical and sovereign structures requires a commitment to be part of the collective process of determining how governments can create a more sustainable and just world based on empathy. Governments must be committed to a long-term vision, but they must also be flexible with the initiatives they pursue, understanding that all strategies will be subject to constant change as they strive together for a more just world. Conclusion A comprehensive feminist foreign policy remains a theoretical aspiration. In theory, feminist foreign policy aims to address gender power structures and reframe traditional concepts of security and peace, sovereignty, sexuality, governance, and nation-building. Despite criticism, feminism is not a utopian concept. It is an alternative explanation of the international system and guidance for how it can be restructured to prevent a constant state of securitization and crisis. A feminist foreign policy can build a peaceful international state system based on community-building, inclusion, gender analysis, and political dialogue. Feminism will stand on the margins of current foreign policy debates for a long time if governments continue to pursue power by traditional means and only attempt to embed women into the system rather than adopting a comprehensive feminist policy. The current examples of feminist foreign policies are often seen as gender binary, and the concept of a feminist foreign policy is operationally misunderstood. The current implementation of feminist foreign policies is yet to follow the feminist approach as it is seen by key academics in this field. Such policies focus on putting more women in decision-making positions and bringing more support to women’s rights and needs, while leaving behind numerous intersectional groups of people, references to whom are rarely included in foreign policy due to its gendered nature. At the same time, even women’s rights are not necessarily fully integrated into feminist foreign policies because governments often differ in their understanding of whose women’s rights they are protecting. They are generally less concerned about the impact of arms trade on women’s rights or security, as the government may not be directly involved in the conflict. In other cases, governments only worry about women who are nationals of their state or women who are located outside of the state, therefore once again leaving a large group of refugees, stateless individuals, and migrants vulnerable to violence and discrimination. For us, the feminist approach to foreign policy demands a shift in how states make political decisions and set priorities. It is about reaching for sustainable and inclusive peace and development for everyone—not striving for the mere absence of conflict but reimagining governance, especially social and governmental structures. The following key indicators can serve as a baseline for a feminist foreign policy: gender analysis; safety and wellbeing; peaceful models of conduct through a political dialogue; community-building based on empathy and common goals, and inclusive policymaking by integrating intersectional approaches. Gender analysis is required to respond to gender inequalities by addressing gender norms, roles, and relationships, and to thereby drive reform of governance and state institutions. Through partnerships, governments can operationalize nonheteronormative visions of organization in foreign policy. The current approach to feminist foreign policy has no capacity to challenge political economies of war, exclusion, militarized security, sovereignty, and hierarchy. The focus remains on increasing gender equality through representation, leaving no commitment for structural change. In this way, the current world order manages to deflect feminist challenges to the existing order without altering the dominant neorealist structures. Without changes—and, as we have shown, there are indications that some change is underway—this approach threatens to make a feminist approach another short-term and artificial solution that is unlikely to lift the world out of its current crisis.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.