Women are the foundation of food security, patriarchal economics deny women their innovation towards agricultural biodiversity in their conquest to masculinize agriculture
Shiva 09’ [Vandana Shiva, Indian scholar, environmental activist, food sovereignty advocate, ecofeminist and anti-globalisation author, “Women and the Gendered Politics of Food” in Philosophical Topics Volume 37, Issue 2, Fall 2009 Global Gender Justice, pg. 17-32]
Agriculture, the growing of food, is both the most important source of livelihood for the majority of the world people, especially women, as well as the sector related to the most fundamental economic right, the right to food and nutrition. Women were the world's original food producers, and they continue to be cen- tral to food production system in the Third- World countries in terms of the work they do in the food chain. The worldwide destruction of the feminine knowledge of agriculture evolved over four to five thousand years, but a handful of white male scientists in less than two decades have not merely violated women as experts; but since their expertise in agriculture has been related to modeling agriculture on nature's methods of renewablility, its destruction has also gone hand in hand with the ecological destruction of nature's processes and the economic destruction of the poorer people in rural areas. Agriculture has been evolved by women. Most farmers of the world are women, and most girls are future farmers. Girls learn the skills and knowledge of farming in the fields and farms. What is grown on farms determines whose livelihoods are secured, what is eaten, how much is eaten, and by whom it is eaten. Women make the most significant contribution to food security. They produce more than half the world's food. They provide more than 80 percent of the food needs of food-insecure household and regions. Food security is therefore directly linked to women's food-producing capacity. Constraints on women's capacity leads to erosion of food security, especially for poor households in poor regions. From field to kitchen, from seed to food, women's strength is diversity. Women's capacities are eroded when this diversity is eroded. Diversity is the pattern of women's work, the pattern of women's planting and sowing of food crops and the pattern of women's food processing. The dominant systems of economics, science, and technology have conspired against women and girls by conspiring against diversity. Economics has rendered women's work as food providers invisible because women provide for the household and perform multiple tasks involving diverse skills. Women have remained invisible as farmers in spite of their contribution to farming. People fail to see the work that women do in agriculture.. Their produc- tion tends not to be recorded by economists as "work." And agriculture as a future vocation for girls is thus closed. These problems of data collection on agricultural work arise not because too few women work but too many women do too much work. There is a conceptual inability of statisticians and researchers to define women's work inside the house and outside the house (and farming is usually part of both). This recognition of what is and is not labor is exacerbated both by the great volume of work that women do and the fact that they do many chores at the same time. It is also related to the fact that although women work to sustain their families and communities, most of their work is not measured in wages. Science and technology have rendered women's knowledge and productivity invisible by ignoring the dimension of diversity in agricultural production. As the Food and Agriculture Organisation (FAO) report on Women Feed the World men- tions, women use more plant diversity, both cultivated and uncultivated, than agri- cultural scientists know about. In Nigerian home gardens, women plant 18-57 plant species. In Sub-Saharan Africa women cultivate as many as 120 different plants in the species left alongside the cash crops managed by man. In Guatemala, home gardens of less than 0. 1 half acre have more than ten tree and crop species.4 In a single African home garden more than 60 species of food-producing trees were counted. In Thailand, researchers found 230 plant species in home gardens. In Indian agriculture women use 150 different species of plants for vegetables, and health care. In West Bengal 124 "weed" species collected from rice fields have economic importance for farmers. In the Expana region of Veracruz, Mexico, peasants utilize about 435 wild plant and animal species of which 229 are eaten. Women are the biodiversity experts of the world. Unfortunately, girls are being denied their potential as food producers and biodiversity experts under the dual pressure of invisibility and domination of industrial agriculture.5 While women manage and produce diversity, the dominant paradigm of agri- culture promotes monoculture on the false assumption that monocultures produce more. Monocultures do not produce more, they control more. As FAO's World Food Day report, a study in eastern Nigeria found occupying only 2 percent of a household farmland accounted for h total output. Navdanya's studies on biodiversity-based ecologica that women-run farms produce more food and nutrition than in farms.6 Quite clearly, if women's knowledge was not being rendered invisible, the use of the 2 percent land under polyculture systems should be the path followed for providing food security. Instead, these highly productive systems are being destroyed in the name of producing more food. Just as women's ways of growing food produce more while conserving more resources, women's ways of food processing conserve more nutrition. Hand pound- ing of rice or milling rice with a foot-operated mortar and pestle preserves more protein, fat, fiber, and minerals in rice. Thus when mechanical hullers replace hand pounding by women as in the case of Bangladesh where 700 new mills supplanted the paid work of 100,000 to 140,000 women in one year by reducing the labor input from 270 hours per ton to 5. They not only rob women of work and livelihoods, they also rob girls of essential nutrients. Yet this process of food value destruction is called "value addition" in patriarchal economics. Feeding the world requires producing more food and nutrition with fewer resources - i.e., producing more with less. In this, women are experts and their expert- ise needs to filter into our institutions of agricultural research and development. However, instead of building on women's expertise in feeding the world through diversity, the dominant system is rushing headlong into destroying diver- sity and women's food-producing capacities, the pirating the results of centuries of innovating and breeding through patenting. Lack of women's property rights are a major constraint on women's capacity to feed the world. These property rights include rights to land, and common prop- erty rights to common resources like water and biodiversity. Women have been the custodians of biodiversity. New intellectual property rights are alienating women's rights to biodiversity and erasing their innovation embodied in agricultural bio- diversity. If the erosion of women's capacity for feeding the world has to be prevented, I PR regimes need to evolve sui generis systems that recognize and protect women's collective and informal innovation. While women are being denied their rights to resources and we are seeing the feminization of subsistence agriculture, the dominant agriculture is showing increasing signs of masculinization as it appropriates resources and rights from women in subsistence agriculture and presents itself as the only alternative for feed- ing the world.