Free beta access. 5 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

The military is the most fundamental representation of masculinity and justifies war in order to protect the women

Christensen 22 [Ann-Dorte, Professor of Sociology and Social work, Aalborg University, “From military to militarizing masculinites” NORMA]

In many societies, the military institution is discursively constructed as a key ‘masculinity maker’; compulsory military service is considered a disciplinary rite de passage that turns boys into men. Hence, the relationship between masculinities, warfare and the military as a social institution is an important field of inquiry for feminist research and critical masculinity studies (Connell, 1995). As such, it has provoked theoretical discussions about the reproduction of patriarchal gender relations and hegemonic masculinity as well as rich empirical work on the construction of military masculinities and the performances and experiences of being a soldier (Barrett, 1996; Do & Samuels, 2021). At the same time, critical scholarship within feminism, gender studies and military studies has widened the analysis of militarism and war to encompass cultural and institutional processes of militarization beyond the military as an institution, for instance in relation to violent masculinities, popular culture, social protest and changes (Woodward & Duncanson, 2017; see also NORMA Volume 10, Number 3–4, 2015)1 The American feminist theorist Cynthia Enloe (2000) has argued that the male soldier, represented as the hero and the warrior, is one of the most fundamental representations of masculinity, and R.W. Connell (1995) has argued that the military is the most important arena for defining hegemonic masculinity in a European and American context. This basic assumption about gender connotations, presenting men as aggressive and violent protectors and women as peaceful and non-violent caregivers, has characterized feminist studies and critical military studies during the last decades (Duncanson, 2015, 2020; Higate, 2003; Morgan, 1994; Sørensen 2015; Yuval-Davis, 1997; Woodward & Jenkings, 2011). Many feminist scholars have also used the concept of hegemonic masculinities to grasp the dynamic and the contradictions within militarized masculinities. Claire Duncanson, for instance, has argued that the concept has been an important analytical tool for critical scholars in highlighting the multiple, dynamic and contradictory character of masculinities in the military. It has underlined that the ideal of ‘combat-experienced commanding officer is not the only form of masculinity, but it is a very powerful model, which through consent, has dominated as one form of “ideal man”’ (Duncanson, 2020, p. 471). Some scholars have argued that while military studies and feminist research have given much attention to the construction of militarized masculinities within the military system, less scholarly attention has been paid to veteran masculinities in transitions from military to civilian life after deployment. This raises important questions about if, how, or to what extend militarized masculinities can be unmade and deconstructed, and how these processes interfere in family lives and social relations? (Bulmer & Eichler, 2017; Moelker, Andres, Bowen, & Manigart, 2015). War and military are closely connected to nationalist discourses. These are based on the classical distinction between citizen-the-mother and citizen-the soldier and the conceptualizations of men as aggressive and violent, fighting for the sake of women and children, and women as peaceful anti-violent mothers (Encloe, 1980; Pateman, 1988; Yuval-Davis, 1997). Even though these traditional constructions have been challenged in recent decades, they are still alive and often emerge in new forms, for instance in arguments for Western military international intervention (Messerschmidt James, 2010) as well as in presentations of women going into the army or returning from military service (Alexiyevich, 1988). In many historical and contemporary contexts, militarized masculinities are also closely related to political power and dominance. This has for instance been the case in the United States, where military position and experience have been important for political influence; for instance, the position as a war hero or the opposite – a ‘wimp’ – characterized the public image of the presidents George H.W. Bush and his son, George W. Buch (Ducat, 2004; Messerschmidt James, 2010). Important theoretical contributions have been made by critical scholars who study militarization of social and cultural institutions beyond the military (Enloe, 2000; Giroux, 2008). One of the most influential scholars, Catherine Lutz, argues that: Militarization is intimately connected not only to the obvious – the increasing size of armies and the resurgence of militant nationalisms and militant fundamentalisms – but also to the less visible deformation of human potentials into the hierarchies of race, class, gender, and sexuality, and to the shaping of national histories in ways that glorify and legitimate military action. (Lutz, 2007, p. 320) Scholars studying militarization have further explored how popular cultural representations of soldier and war romanticize and normalize violence, especially through Hollywood films (Behnke, 2006; Boggs & Pollard, 2017; Davies & Philpott, 2012; Stahl, 2010) but also through other media. Book markets have in recent decades become infused with war memories written by former soldiers (see Woodward & Jenkings, 2018). Of countless examples, two are Mark Owen – who claims to have been the one killing Osama Bin Laden – and Chris Kyle, who’s bestselling autobiography American Sniper also became a huge blockbuster movie. Persons with experience as Navy Seals have also had commercial successes in the self-help and leadership industry in recent years. An example is Jocko Willink, a highly decorated former Navy Seal commander of Seal team 3’ s Task Unit Bruiser (which included Chris Kyle) in Ramadi, Irak. Upon retiring in 2010, Willink has become somewhat of a media celebrity on YouTube, Ted-Talks, podcasts, as well as a business consultant and bestselling author of several leadership and children’s books. In these books and media appearances, Willink thus converted his embodied ‘war capital’ and military masculinity into a prospering business and in the process contributes to reproducing the symbolic relationship between military masculinity and hegemonic masculinity.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.