Free beta access. 5 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Space exploration represents the fantasy of western colonialism. White valiant masculine representation of space programs excludes women and minorities

Lanius 08 (Roger D., Senior Curator Division of Space History National Air and Space Museum Smithsonian Institution, “Heroes in a Vacuum: The Apollo Astronaut as Cultural Icon.” The Florida Historical Quarterly, vol. 87, no. 2, Fall 2008, JSTOR, http://www.jstor.org/stable/20700214, pd)

In both fact and fiction, the space suit has been a core representation of the astronaut, essentially a knight's armor worn heroically as the individual conducts his noble mission. More than any other single artifact of the Moon landing program the Apollo space suit represented the values that supported Americans going into space in the first place. It symbolized and reified the Utopian desire to colonize the Solar System and make a perfect society at a new and pristine place beyond the corrupt Earth. It also stood, as cultural historian Debra Benita Shaw wrote, "as a metaphor for the transcendent power of scientific ingenuity and technological know-how....It is thus a significant icon in contemporary cultural representations of the body in both outer and terrestrial space."56 As an enduring icon of Apollo, the space suited astronauts on the Moon conjured images of power and masculinity far beyond that actually present. The anonymity of those astronauts, with their visors down similar to Medieval knights made them even more mysterious and attractive. Without intending it, the space suit became synonymous with a set of values referring "to heroism and thus to the Cartesian (masculine) subject identified by the Proper Name but the Name itself becomes curiously disconnected from the individual to which it actually refers."57 At some level, there fore, the Apollo astronaut in his space suit projected the image of the hardbody of masculinity that Susan Jeffords believes became so prevalent in the 1980s, anticipating that later development by twenty years.58 By being consumed by a space suit, as Donna Haraway has pointed out, the astronaut essentially became a cyborg as an iconic space suit established the relationship between human and machine. Cyborg ontology is a critical element of thinking about the duality of this relationship, confounding the sense in which bodies move in apposition to the technology.59 Megan Stern's analysis of visored astronauts in spacesuits suggest that they are essentially anonymous, a screen on which anyone might project any attribute from fantasies of heroism to submission. Therefore, the Apollo astronauts in their suits became screens for the whole of America to project its hopes, wishes, fears, and horrors. Each astro naut felt this keenly, as they have lived out the remainder of their lives in the glare of American fame and the sense of expectations never fully satisfied. Unable always to reflect the qualities of strength, authority, and rationality so often projected on them, the astronauts have displayed a fragility since Apollo that is both perplexing and troubling for many who see them in later years.60 Marina Benjamin described this best when she encountered three Apollo astronauts at a celebrity and collectors show. She wrote that they were "just like movie stars; they burned brightly in the glare of publicity when they were offered good parts to play and then, when the roles dried up, so did they." Their space suits, how ever, represented the triumph of technology over living organ isms.61 Those suits dominate the essence of what it means to be an astronaut; they have since Apollo and continue to do so today. The Apollo astronauts all had an image of hard-working, fun loving, virile representations of masculinity. The expression of public comfort with the white male establishment is palpable throughout the recounting of the story of Apollo. The quintessential company man worked for NASA during Apollo. The engineering "geeks" of Mission Control, with their short-sleeved white shirts, narrow black ties, slide rules hung on their belts like sidearms, and their pocket protectors complete with compass and ruler and myriad pens and mechanical pencils all personified a conservative America that many looked back on with fondness and nostalgia. Even Norman Mailer, as much an embodiment of the Sixties counter-culture as anyone, ranted about this aspect of Apollo while covering the Moon landings in 1969. Mailer expressed fascination and not a little perplexity with the time warp that he witnessed at the Manned Spacecraft Center in Houston. He railed against an overwhelmingly white male NASA steeped in middle class values and reverence for the American flag and main stream culture. Mailer grudgingly admitted, however, that NASA's approach to task accomplishment—which he viewed as the embodiment of the Protestant Work Ethic—and its technological. and scientific capability got results with Apollo. Even so, he hated NASA's closed and austere society, one where he believed out siders were distrusted and held at arm's length with a bland and faceless courtesy that betrayed nothing. For all of his skepticism, for all of his esotericism, Mailer captures much of interest concerning rocket technology and the people who produced it in Project Apollo.62 lo.62 Mailer's critique foreshadows by twenty-five years a powerful nostalgia that has grown up around Apollo as a program that was done right, in no small part because it took place within the cultur al confines of an era before the social revolution of the 1960s. Nothing captures this nostalgia more effectively than the feature film, Apollo 13. Set in 1970 when an explosion crippled a lunar landing mission and NASA nearly lost astronauts Jim Lovell, Fred Haise, and Jack Swigert, it has been recast as one of NASA's finest hours, a successful failure. At 56 hours into the flight an oxygen tank in the Apollo service module ruptured and damaged several of the power, electrical, and life support systems. People through out the world watched and waited and hoped as NASA personnel on the ground and the crew worked to find a way safely home. It was a close-run thing, but the crew returned safely on April 17, 1970. The near disaster served several important purposes for the civil space program—especially prompting reconsideration of the propriety of the whole effort while also solidifying in the popular mind NASA's collective genius.63 While one must give the NASA flight team high marks for perseverance, dedication, and an unshakable belief that they could bring the crew home safely, it is quite strange that no one seems to realize that the mission had already failed, and failed catastrophically, by the time of accident.64 The fact that Apollo 13 is now viewed as one of NASA's shining moments says much about the ability of humanity to recast historical events into meaningful morality plays. In this instance, Apollo 13 became a vehicle for criticism of the social order that emerged from the 1960s and a celebration of an earlier age. When the film appeared in 1995, reviewer John Powers, writing for the Washington Post, commented on its incessant nostalgia for "the paradisiacal America invoked by Ronald Reagan and Pat Buchananan America where men were men, women were subservient, and people of color kept out of the way." In addition, Powers wrote, "Its story line could be a Republican parable about 1995 America: A marvelous vessel loses its power and speeds toward extinction, until it's saved by a team of heroic white men." If anything, Powers underemphasized the white America evoked in Apollo 13. There were no people of color in the film and the only women with speaking parts of substance was Marilyn Lovell (Kathleen Quinlin), wife of the Apollo 13 command er, whose role is distinctly one of offering proud support while pri vately fearing the worst, and their daughter whose role seems to be as spokesperson for the social revolution then underway while con sistently reflecting its least important elements. For example, she complains in a shriekish voice that the Beatles had just broken up and that her world has accordingly collapsed. The heroes of Apollo 13 are the geeks of Mission Control, with the astronauts aboard the spacecraft as spirited but metaphorically emasculated characters to be saved. Lovell, Haise, and Swigert must wait to be rescued in a manner not unlike Rapunzel, as an active participant but unable to accomplish the task alone. As historian Tom D. Crouch wrote of this film's depiction of the "studs" in Mission Control: The real heroes of this film are either bald or sporting brush cuts; wear thick glasses; are partial to rumpled short sleeve shirts; and chain-smoke an endless string of cigarettes, cigars, and pipes. For all of that, these slide rule wielding technonerds solve all of the difficult problems required to bring the crew home. They are, in the words of one of the astronauts portrayed in the film, "steely-eyed missile men."65 Apollo 13 the film, accordingly, opens the possibility of the astro naut hero as helpless surrogate of a collection of really smart nerds on a mission. The Mission Control team, in an interesting transference of masculine power from the astronauts, assume in the best sense of American reverence for the underdog canonical status. It also venerates a long past era in American history. Indeed, it may have been an era already gone by the time of the actual mission in 1970. It is a hallowing of masculinity in a nostalgic context. A recent study completed for NASA concluded that representation of space exploration on film is highly nostalgic, and Apollo fuels that perception: As a group, the public entertainments we tend to buy into are either nostalgic visions of the "space race" period ("The Right Stuff," "Apollo 13," "From the Earth to the Moon") or fantasies reflecting the romantic imagination of the Flash Gordon/Buck Rogers era ("Star Wars" rather than "Star Trek"). These are the visions people support in the most meaningful way possible: with their time and dol lars....Boomers have a great nostalgic affection for NASA, but their own priorities have shifted from a future focus to maintaining what they have. They see money spent on space exploration as threatening their future entitle ments.66 At a sublime level, the Apollo astronauts may serve as a trope for a larger lack of interest in the future expressed by Americans at the beginning of the twenty-first century. As a country, a shifting cultural center of gravity toward maintenance of the status quo rather than looking to the future may have stalled. A shared national vision that energized earlier efforts

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.