The affs articulation of anti-terrorism through NATO portrays women as victims needing masculine men to save them
Hurley 14 (Hurley, M E (2014) Gendering NATO: Analyzing the Construction and Implementation of the North Atlantic Treaty-Organization’s Gender Perspective PhD, Oxford Brookes University)
These feminist critiques of the War on Terror therefore exposed the construction and the use¶ of ‘other’ (i.e. non-western) women within the narratives of this reinvigorated atmosphere of¶ war and militarism. As Krista Hunt (2002) notes the gendered natures of narratives such as:¶ “look at what they do to their women”, have ‘political currency’ (2002: 116); furthering a¶ 43¶ contrast between the ‘civilised west’ and the ‘uncivilised Afghan society’ in need of saving¶ (Ibid). Hunt identified ‘two-distinct but complementary images of Afghan women’ portrayed¶ in the media and political discourse: Afghan women were portrayed as passive victims of the¶ Taliban and on the other as vocal opponents of that regime (2002: 117), thus serving to¶ legitimise and ‘moralise’ the forceful overthrow of the regime and the subsequent¶ occupation (Ibid). The war on terror was then framed in large part by a notion of what¶ Miriam Cooke termed ‘saving brown women’ (2002: 468)21. Upon taking command of the¶ International Security Assistance Force (ISAF) in Afghanistan, NATO took up this mantle.¶ Indeed, Von der Lippe & Väyrynen (2011) suggest that the “saving brown women from¶ brown men” narrative combined with UNSCR 1325 to ‘facilitate a metamorphosis of the¶ militaristic and masculine-led NATO into a collective peacekeeper’ (2011:26) and champion¶ of women’s rights - See Figure 1. This notion of NATO as a paternal peacekeeper will be¶ returned to in Chapter 3, in a discussion of Iris Young’s (2003) notion of the ‘logic of¶ masculinist protection’.¶ Figure 1: “NATO: Keep the Progress Going!” – An Amnesty International Poster22¶ The ‘gendering’ of the war on terror was not simply limited to an ‘othering’ of Afghan¶ women and men and the ‘terrorist enemy’. Hunt (2002) notes that:¶ “the media coverage and political discourse following the attacks on the USA¶ exemplify the way that images of women…are being used to define the conflict; for¶ the most part women have been depicted as silent victims of the attacks…women¶ are cast as passive” (2002: 117).¶ In this sense the feminist literature dealing specifically with 9/11 and its aftermath detailed¶ the gendered processes, and the reassertion of specific gendered orthodoxies (women as¶ passive victims in need of saving) necessary in the production of war narratives. In this¶ respect their work draws interesting parallels with that of Susan Jeffords (1989) account of¶ the ‘re-masculinisation’ of American culture following the Vietnam war (Section 3, below).¶ In one respect the aims and findings of this thesis sit within this ‘historical-social-political’¶ context. It can be argued that the effects of 9/11 are still being felt within the international¶ political system and especially in the western security infrastructure – at the time of writing¶ this thesis, NATO, is managing a ‘transition’ from Afghanistan.¶ Detailed, experience-focused feminist analyses of the war on terror and its associated¶ conflicts (see also Enloe, 2010) built upon early feminist IR scholarship and helped to reinterrogate the gendered processes and sites of war and militarism in the first decade of the¶ twenty-first century. As Ayotte & Husain argue: “In the wake of the ‘war on terrorism’¶ feminist analysis of international relations must broaden the concept of security to consider¶ forms of violence beyond the statist security framework of realpolitik” (Ayotte & Husain,¶ 2005: 112); whilst I feel that Ayotte & Husain’s assertion somewhat neglects the important¶ contributions of early feminist writing, that began to do exactly that (Tickner, 1992; Enloe¶ 1989; Squires 1998) it represents a continuation of that work as well as a shift in certain¶ areas of feminist research towards centralising the study of war and security within a FSS¶ agenda, and Christine Sylvester’s ‘new feminist war studies’ (2013: 49 – emphasis added).¶ The research outlined above has detailed how Feminist International Relations research has¶ developed. In troubling the existing boundaries of IR and Security Studies as an academic¶ discipline the place and purpose of a distinctly Feminist IR is problematised. Should¶ Feminist IR remain embedded within the disciplinary boundaries, concepts and language of¶ IR, seeking to carve out a distinctly feminist space? Some have argued that in doing so,¶ Feminist IR would become defined by and produce work that was simply intelligible to,¶ rather than challenging to IR’s mainstream (Lobasz & Sjoberg, 2011:574; Youngs, 2004;¶ Squires & Welds, 2007; Zalewski, 2007). This debate is ongoing, yet what the research¶ outlined above (and below) demonstrate is the value of feminist research both within and¶ without IR in exposing the gendered nature of the international; in exposing the¶ incompleteness of accounts that fail to address gender and experience, and that in the words¶ of Cynthia Enloe (1989) it is gender that makes the world go round.